Private Events in ABA: What They Are and How to Teach Them

Private events are thoughts, feelings, and body states only the person can feel. See how BCBAs help learners notice, name, and act on them.

Key takeaway

Private events in behavior analysis are behaviors and feelings that happen inside the skin, where only the person can sense them. Think of a racing heart, a tight stomach, a worried thought, or a sense that something feels off.

What Does Your Body Know? Teaching Individuals with IDD to Recognize Internal Warning Signs
Watch the full CEU recording

What Does Your Body Know? Teaching Individuals with IDD to Recognize Internal Warning Signs

Tricia Lund · 1 CEU · 56 min
Watch on openceu.com →

Free learning path on this topic

Verbal Behavior: Beyond WH-Questions

Dana Pettus's three-part series on building generative verbal behavior. Why WH-question programs stall, how to establish speaker-listener repertoires, and how to scaffold advanced verbal skills like recall and simple inference. Three hours, three CEUs.

Start the path →3 courses · 3 CEUs · Watch at your own pace

Experts who cover this

9 recordings on openceu cover private events.

Private events in behavior analysis are behaviors and feelings that happen inside the skin, where only the person can sense them. Think of a racing heart, a tight stomach, a worried thought, or a sense that something feels off. Nobody else can see these events directly.

Behavior analysts still treat private events as real behavior. They follow the same rules as the actions we can see. The hard part is that we can't measure them the usual way. So clinicians watch for outside clues, and they teach learners to notice and name what is going on inside.

What counts as a private event#

A private event is anything a person feels or does that others cannot observe. Fear is one example. Discomfort, doubt, and a rising body alarm are others. In the talk What Does Your Body Know?, Carolyn Broner lists these internal warning signals. She names fear, discomfort, uncertainty, physical arousal, and "a sense that something feels off." Arousal here just means the body is revved up, like a faster heartbeat or quick breathing.

These signals connect to interoception. That is the skill of sensing what is happening inside your own body. Her co-presenter Tricia Lund set up that idea first. Then Broner asked the next question. How do behavior analysts fit these inner experiences into their science?

Her answer is simple. In ABA, these signals are private events. They are not mysteries outside the field. They are a normal part of behavior that we just can't watch from the outside. Thoughts, urges, body sensations, and feelings all fit in this group. Some researchers call them "inner behavior." The label matters less than the idea. If a person can feel it and others can't see it, it counts as a private event.

Private events are still behavior#

Some people think ABA ignores feelings. That idea is wrong. Radical behaviorism, the philosophy behind ABA, says the inner world is part of behavior too. It just happens where no one else can look. Carolyn Broner makes this point clearly.

"From a radical behaviorist perspective, private events are not outside the science of behavior. They are covert behaviors subject to the same environmental influences as our overt behavior."From the talk — Carolyn Broner

"Covert" means hidden. "Overt" means out in the open. So a hidden feeling and a visible action are shaped by the same forces. Past learning shapes both. The current setting shapes both. Consequences shape both.

This has a big effect on practice. If private events follow the same rules, we can teach around them. We can arrange the setting to help a learner notice a feeling. We can reinforce, or reward, a learner for naming it. We can build a plan for what to do next. Feelings stop being off limits. They become skills we can grow, like any other skill. This view also respects the learner. It treats their inner life as real and worth our attention.

Why we can't see them directly#

The core problem is plain. Private events happen inside the body. A clinician cannot look into a child and see fear rising. Broner describes this in concrete terms.

"We cannot directly observe a child's heart rate increasing, their stomach tightening, their breathing changing, or that internal sense of discomfort or threat."From the talk — Carolyn Broner

She contrasts these inner events with things we can see. Aggression, avoidance, crying, freezing, and moving away are all visible. We can count them and graph them. A tight stomach is different. It gives us no direct data.

So behavior analysts use a workaround. They look for what Skinner called public accompaniments. These are visible signs that tend to show up along with an inner change.

"So as behavior analysts, we often rely on public accompaniments, the observable responses that tend to occur alongside those internal changes."From the talk — Carolyn Broner

Broner gives a long list of examples. A child might tense their body or hold their breath. They might scan the room, cover their body, or move away. They might get quiet, laugh nervously, or refuse a task. They might suddenly show challenging behavior. Each of these can be a window into a private event.

Reading early warning signs as data#

Broner adds an important point about those visible clues. They may not be random. They may be what she calls collateral responses. These are actions that rise and fall together with an inner state.

When clinicians track these patterns over time, the clues become useful. They can point to arousal at the precursor level. A precursor is an early behavior that comes before a bigger one. So a held breath or a nervous laugh might come right before a meltdown. It might come before a shutdown. It might come before a child goes along with something automatically, without really choosing.

That last outcome matters a lot for safety. A child who complies on autopilot may not speak up when something is wrong. Broner also notes that high arousal can cost a learner access to good communication. In other words, the child may lose their words right when they need them most.

This changes how we read the body. Broner urges clinicians not to see a tense body only as noncompliance. Instead, that tension can be clinical information. It may be the first sign that a learner is struggling inside. Catching it early gives the team a chance to help before things escalate. It also gives a teaching moment. The clinician can help the learner connect that body signal to a word.

Emotions as private events#

Nicole Stewart brings private events into everyday life in The ADHD Exchange: Teaching Emotional Regulation. She starts with a simple group question. What do you do when you feel sad? People shared answers like alone time, a drive with loud music, or junk food.

Stewart pointed out that each answer was a visible change in behavior. Then she tied it back to feelings.

"Our emotions are private events that we are experiencing and are observable for us."From the talk — Nicole Stewart

Notice her wording. Emotions are observable, but only to the person feeling them. That is the heart of a private event. Stewart then told a story from her own week. She was making a U-turn on a busy New Jersey road. A car appeared that she didn't expect. Her body reacted fast.

She described the signs in detail. Her heart was pounding and beating differently. Her chest felt tight. She also noted that her chest feels tight when she has quick anxiety. So she could say to herself, "I bet I'm feeling anxious right now." Nobody else on the call could see any of that happening.

"it is, it's, you know, it's a private event that is happening."From the talk — Nicole Stewart

Her point was that naming the feeling made it usable. Once she could label it, she could understand it and plan for it.

Setting events and the clinician's own awareness#

Stewart's story holds a second lesson. She mentioned a car accident a few months earlier. Since then, she has felt a bit on edge while driving. Her anxiety now shows up faster. She called that past accident a setting event for her emotion.

A setting event is something earlier that changes how strongly a person reacts later. A bad night's sleep is a common one. Pain or hunger can be one too. In her case, the accident made the roundabout feel more threatening. That changed her private events, which then changed her behavior.

Her co-host added a practical idea. Now that Stewart had felt it once, she could expect it. She could be mindful the next time she reached that roundabout. That is a simple form of self-management. You predict the feeling, notice it early, and respond on purpose.

Stewart also made a point aimed at clinicians. She said part of being good at teaching emotions is having your own emotional awareness and regulation. It took her a long time to realize this. A BCBA who can tact, or name, their own private events is better at modeling that skill. They can also explain it in real, relatable terms. Learners often learn emotion words best from adults who use them out loud.

Giving children words for what they feel#

In It's Complicated: Teaching Relationship Safety That Reflects Real Life, Carolyn Broner builds on her earlier talk. She reviews a core idea first. Safety often begins in the body. Warning signals can show up before a child has words for them.

"behavioral precursor responses may reflect private events the child cannot yet articulate."From the talk — Carolyn Broner

Here is the gap she wants to close. A child can feel that something is wrong. But without words, they can't act on that feeling. They also can't tell anyone else about it. So Broner argues that interoception is not a fixed trait. It is a skill set we can teach. Learners can be taught to notice, label, trust, and act on their inner signals.

Her tool is what she calls emotional safety language. These are honest, simple phrases a child can use when something feels unclear. Examples include "I feel unsure," "Something feels different," and "My body is telling me something." These phrases don't require a final judgment. The child just reports what is true right now.

"emotional safety language gives children more than rules. It gives them language for what they are experiencing. In other words, private events."From the talk — Carolyn Broner

In behavior analytic terms, this is teaching a child to tact private events. The phrase becomes the bridge between an inner state and a trusted adult.

Why "safe or unsafe" is not enough#

Broner warns against binary language. Binary means only two choices. Many safety programs teach children to sort every situation into "safe" or "unsafe." The trouble is that real life is often in between.

When children only have those two words, some experiences become hard to report. The child may sense something is off. But it doesn't feel clearly unsafe. So they say nothing. Broner stresses that this is not because the child failed to notice. It is because they lacked a word that fit. Phrases like "something feels different" fill that gap.

She also notes a hard fact. Many safety programs focus on stranger danger. Yet people are far more likely to be harmed by someone they know and trust. Those situations rarely look clearly dangerous at first. That makes early private events, like unease, even more important to name.

Words alone are not the finish line, though. Broner says children also need something to do. She suggests a flexible set of options instead of one rigid script. A child might pause and not answer right away. They might move away to create space. They might ask questions or slow things down. They might find a trusted adult and report the discomfort. Learners who need more structure here may benefit from the full course, It's Complicated: Teaching Relationship Safety That Reflects Real Life.

What a tact is, and why it matters here#

To teach private events, it helps to know the basic verbal skill involved. That skill is the tact. Dana Pettus reviews it in Teaching WH-Questions Isn't Enough: Building True Conditional Discrimination. She asked her live audience to type the textbook definition in the chat. One attendee answered right away, typing: "A nonverbal SD, a label, followed by a generalized reinforcer."

Pettus then put it in her own words.

"What I think about a pure tact is that it's a non-ver... ...SD that results in... response that has some sort of generalized reinforcer."From the talk — Dana Pettus

Here is the plain version. An SD, or discriminative stimulus, is a cue that signals a response will pay off. With a tact, the cue is something the learner senses, not something someone says. The response is a label. The payoff is general praise or attention, not a specific item.

Now apply that to private events. With a tacted feeling, the cue is inside the learner. It might be a fast heartbeat or a tight chest. The label is a word like "nervous" or "unsure." This is why tacting private events is so tricky. The teacher can't see the cue. So the teacher has to rely on public accompaniments to know when to prompt and reinforce the label.

Pure tacts versus intraverbal tacts#

Pettus makes a second point across two related talks. In When the Foundations Are Right: Unlocking Advanced Verbal Repertoires, she describes the difference between a pure tact and an intraverbal tact. A pure tact is under one source of control. You see a chair and say "chair." An intraverbal tact is under two. Someone asks "What color is it?" while you look at a car. Your answer, "blue," is controlled by both the question and the car.

Pettus calls this convergent control. Two cues come together to produce one response. In Getting the Right Answer Isn't Enough, she repeats the core idea in simple terms.

"So a pure tax is a nonverbal SD that results in some sort of verbal response."From the talk — Dana Pettus

("Tax" is how the transcript recorded "tact.") She then asks a pointed question. How often do you walk into a room, see a chair, and just say "chair"? Almost never. Most real tacting is the intraverbal kind. She urges clinicians to look at the natural sources of control for a response.

This matters for private events. A child is rarely going to announce "anxious" out of nowhere. More often, an adult asks, "How are you feeling?" The child's answer then depends on the question and the inner state together. Teaching should practice both versions. Learners need to answer when asked. They also need to speak up on their own, as Broner's safety work shows.

Naming needs so learners can self-advocate#

Mark Malady adds a related angle in genArete: To Teach or not to Teach! He is talking about accommodations, like supports in a classroom or job. He notes that a formal written agreement is often not enough. People still may not use the supports they are given. What helps is a learner who can ask for those supports themselves.

"the man-tacked repertoire is vital to teach the person to be able to advocate for their own accommodations."From the talk — Mark Malady, BCBA

The transcript reads "man-tacked," which reflects the mand and tact working together. A mand is a request. So the learner names a state and asks for help with it. Malady says this can be an early learner skill. It does not need to be complex. It also does not need to be spoken. Signs, devices, or pictures all work. That fits private events well. "I'm tired, break please" is a tact of an inner state joined to a request.

Stu Law, Ph.D., offers useful context in Practical RFT. He sums up the two units in blunt terms.

"you manned because it gets you shit. You tact because people say, hell yeah, right? Like generalized social reinforcement and things like that."From the talk — Stu Law, Ph.D.

In plain terms, you mand because it gets you things. You tact because people give you social praise back. He also notes a limit. Skinner's verbal behavior explains why speakers speak. It says less about why listeners listen. That is worth remembering when we teach children to report feelings to an adult.

Where the experts agree#

Across these eight talks, the speakers come at private events from different angles. Carolyn Broner focuses on body signals and safety for learners with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Nicole Stewart focuses on emotions and ADHD. Dana Pettus focuses on the verbal mechanics of the tact. Mark Malady focuses on self-advocacy. Stu Law gives a broader view of verbal behavior theory.

Even so, their views fit together well. None of them directly disputes another on how private events work. Broner and Stewart both describe private events as real, felt events that only the person can sense. Both say naming them is what makes them useful. Pettus explains the tact, which is the verbal skill behind that naming. Malady shows how pairing a tact with a request lets learners get the support they need.

Law's critique targets the limits of Skinner's 1957 framework in general. It is not a disagreement with how these clinicians teach private events today. The common thread is clear. Private events are behavior. We can't see them, but we can watch for clues and teach words for them.

What the research says#

Published studies back up the core ideas from these talks. Researchers have taught children with autism to tact the private events of other people. They used visible clues, like a bandage meaning "hurt," along with a most-to-least prompting procedure. All three children learned the skill quickly (Belisle et al., 2019).

Other work taught children with autism to tact sensations on their own bodies. Objects like a hairbrush created feelings like "prickly." Children generalized to new objects and, to a lesser degree, new body parts. They did not generalize to brand new sensations, which suggests those need direct teaching (Rajagopal et al., 2021).

Measurement is possible too. A review of precision teaching studies found that inner behaviors like thoughts, urges, and feelings can be reliably counted and changed. Most participants showed real shifts in level, trend, or variability (Van & Kubina, 2026). A conceptual paper proposes that private body signals can act as stimuli that cue, motivate, or reinforce behavior. The authors argue this can sharpen assessment and treatment (Meindl & Ivy, 2023).

FAQ#

What is an example of a private event in ABA? A racing heart before a test is a private event. So is a worried thought or a tight stomach. Nicole Stewart describes her own pounding heart and tight chest after a near miss while driving. Only she could feel those signs. Others could only see what she did next.

Can private events be measured? Yes, but not directly by an outside observer. Clinicians watch public accompaniments, which are visible signs that go along with the inner state. The person can also self-record their thoughts or feelings. Research in precision teaching shows these self-counts can be reliable and can change over time.

How do you teach a child to tact private events? Start by spotting the visible clues that come with a feeling. When those clues show up, prompt a simple label, like "I feel unsure." Then reinforce the label with praise and help. Practice both answering "How do you feel?" and speaking up without a question. Pair the label with an action, like asking for a break or finding a trusted adult.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch What Does Your Body Know? Teaching Individuals with IDD to Recognize Internal Warning Signs with Tricia Lund and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert

Keep going with a free learning path

Verbal Behavior: Beyond WH-Questions

Dana Pettus's three-part series on building generative verbal behavior. Why WH-question programs stall, how to establish speaker-listener repertoires, and how to scaffold advanced verbal skills like recall and simple inference. Three hours, three CEUs.

Start the path →3 courses · 3 CEUs · Watch at your own pace