Pathological Demand Avoidance (PDA): A Guide for BCBAs
What pathological demand avoidance (PDA) is, why many now call it a persistent drive for autonomy, and how behavior analysts can assess and support it.
Key takeaway
Pathological demand avoidance (PDA) is a pattern of strongly resisting ordinary, everyday demands, driven by a need to feel in control. Many people in the autism and PDA communities now call it a "persistent drive for autonomy" instead.

PDA Caregivers, Complex Profiles, Replacement Behaviors, and Being Trauma Informed
Experts who cover this
6 recordings on openceu cover pathological demand avoidance.
- Featured talk1.5 Learning CEUs
PDA Caregivers, Complex Profiles, Replacement Behaviors, and Being Trauma Informed
B. Kuerine GrayThe Behaviorist Bookclub
The core topic of the whole talk: B. Kuerine Gray covers why PDA is hard to program for, walks through five complex case examples, and argues intervention…
- 2 CEUs (1 Learning, 1 Ethics)
Alternatives to Extinction for Supporting Extreme Demand Avoidant Behavior
Nicola Schneider, LBA-NJNRS Compassionate Behavior Services
The core topic of the workshop, extreme demand avoidance is operationally defined as a response class of escape/avoidance behaviors toward demands rather than…
- 1 Learning CEU
Real World” BCBAs, the “Behavior Crisis”, and Pathological Demand Avoidance
Kaitlin WilderThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Wilder frames PDA as a behavior profile (not a DSM diagnosis) often co-occurring with autism, characterized by extreme avoidance of everyday demands, and…
- 1 Learning CEU
PDA: Collaborating for Success
B. Kuereine GrayThe Behaviorist Bookclub
The core topic of the talk. The presenter frames PDA as a response class rather than a diagnosis, traces the emerging (non-peer-reviewed-heavy) research base…
- 1 Learning CEU
PDA: What it is and What it isn't
B. Kuereine GrayThe Behaviorist Bookclub
The core topic of the talk: B frames PDA as a profile marked by resisting ordinary, previously-mastered demands through social strategies, high masking, and a…
- 2.5 Learning CEUs
Confessions of a New Behavior Analyst in Functional Analysis
Matt HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
In the Q&A, the speaker gives his opinion that PDA (not in the DSM-5, a proposed ASD subset) shouldn't change the FA approach itself; conditions should still…
On this page · 11 sections▾
Pathological demand avoidance (PDA) is a pattern of strongly resisting ordinary, everyday demands, driven by a need to feel in control. Many people in the autism and PDA communities now call it a "persistent drive for autonomy" instead. Autonomy just means having a say over your own choices.
PDA is not a formal diagnosis in the United States. Still, behavior analysts see it often in homes, schools, and clinics. This page pulls together what several OpenCEU presenters teach about PDA. It covers how it looks, how to assess it, and how to support people who show it.
What PDA looks like#
B. Kuereine Gray, who teaches several OpenCEU courses on PDA, starts with the core feature. It is resisting or avoiding the ordinary demands of life. Gray stresses that these are familiar demands, not new ones. The person already has the skills. They have shown the task before. They still resist.
In ABA terms, the request is often a familiar SD. An SD is a cue that signals a behavior will be reinforced. So the problem is not a skill gap. It is the demand itself.
Gray says the second key feature is a need to be in charge. Gray sees this from early intervention all the way into adulthood. Children may dictate how you play, what you say, and what you wear. They may decide where you sit, what room you are in, and who talks first. Gray adds that they may struggle with demands unless those demands are carefully presented. They may also seem unaware of the difference between themselves and adults in charge.
Gray also warns about language. Older descriptions use words like "social manipulation." Gray calls this stigmatizing language. It still shows up in research, but it is not right to use with families. Gray also admits that some PDA language sounds mentalistic, meaning it talks about inner states. In Gray's view, the field is still learning to break these behaviors down in plain behavioral terms.
Why the name is changing#
The word "pathological" means a disease or disorder. Many people with PDA do not want their behavior framed that way. Gray describes this as part of a wider conversation happening in the autism and PDA communities.
It's a persistent desire for autonomy or a pervasive drive for autonomy. From the talk — B. Kuereine Gray
In a course on collaboration, Gray goes further. Gray says the field is "no longer discussing pathological demand avoidance." The preferred phrase is now persistent drive for autonomy. Gray still teaches both terms. Professionals need to know the clinical name. But with caregivers and teachers, Gray leads with the autonomy framing.
The reason is practical. It is hard to get caregiver buy-in when you call a child's behavior a disorder. The words you choose set the tone for how open families will be. Kaitlin Wilder, another OpenCEU presenter, takes a softer stance on the name. Wilder says PDA can stand for either pathological demand avoidance or pervasive drive for autonomy. In Wilder's view, both of those names are accurate.
Gray also shares a story from home. Gray's youngest child has a PDA profile. Gray once asked a school psychologist what they knew about PDA. The psychologist thought Gray meant public displays of affection. Gray uses this to show how much awareness work is still left.
Is PDA a diagnosis?#
Every presenter in this set agrees on one fact. PDA is not a formal diagnosis in the United States. Wilder notes it is not in the DSM, the main U.S. manual for diagnoses. Nicola Schneider, a BCBA who teaches about extreme demand avoidance, makes the same point about the ICD-10, the international manual used to code diagnoses. Schneider says PDA is not in the ICD-10 either, whether you think of it as a trait or a profile.
Gray explains why PDA has not reached diagnostic status. Gray points to two gaps. There is not much peer-reviewed research. And there is no clear, shared definition of how PDA presents.
Because of the lack of peer-reviewed research, because of the lack of specificity in defining how it presents for people, that has prevented PDA from becoming its own recognized diagnostic category. From the talk — B. Kuereine Gray
Gray says PDA has no ICD code and is not in the DSM-5. It is also not being considered for a later DSM edition. Gray mentions an article by Carlazi from 2025 that tracks the rise in PDA interest. Gray sees pros and cons in that rise. More people are talking about PDA, but the definition is still loose.
Wilder describes PDA as often treated as a profile of autism. A person may have an autism diagnosis with a PDA profile. Wilder finds this tricky because many people identify with PDA without an autism diagnosis.
Thinking about PDA as a response class#
Since PDA is not a formal diagnosis, how should behavior analysts talk about it? Both Gray and Schneider land on the same answer. Treat it as a response class. A response class is a group of behaviors that serve the same purpose, even if they look different.
Schneider makes this the main teaching point of the workshop. Schneider lists ODD, ADHD, ASD, and PDA as medical labels that come with symptoms. Behavior analysts, Schneider says, are not there to treat symptoms. They are there to target the actual behaviors in front of them. These behaviors may show up whether or not a person has a diagnosis.
Schneider also notes that many families on Schneider's caseload are not seeking a diagnosis at all. Parents may not want a mental health or medical label. So Schneider has shifted toward a new mindset. The focus is now on the behaviors a person shows, not the traits of a diagnosis.
Gray agrees. Gray notes that some people call PDA a subtype of autism, or a profile, or a presentation. But in behavior analysis, Gray treats it as a response class. This keeps the focus on what you can observe and measure. It also keeps you from guessing about causes you cannot see.
Masking, threat, and fast escalation#
PDA can be hard to spot early. Gray says it is common to see masking until the setting becomes too much. Masking means hiding your distress so you look fine on the outside. When the mask drops, you may see what looks like a big reaction out of nowhere.
Gray uses an escalation wheel to show how this can unfold. A person may start by engaging. Then they get distracted, start putting things off, and then pull away. Gray says escalation with a PDA profile can be very rapid. You may not see a neat antecedent, behavior, and consequence pattern. The steps can blur together.
Gray shares words from a teen with PDA, posted by a UK support group. The teen describes the brain splitting in two. One part forces the body into shutdown. The other part feels guilty toward the parent or teacher. Even picking up a pencil can feel like a threat.
PDA rarely happens because the demand is hard, but your brain tricks you into thinking it's really hard. A teen contributor via PAST UK, read aloud by B. Kuereine Gray
This view matters for treatment. If the demand feels like a threat, then pushing harder can make things worse. It helps explain why the escalation can look so sudden and so strong.
Assessment and functional analysis#
How should PDA shape your assessment? Schneider points to the EDA-8, a short survey for extreme demand avoidance. Gray notes that the EDA-8 has grown into the EDA-10. In Gray's experience, most people with a PDA profile score threes across the board on it.
Schneider is careful about what this tool can and cannot do. Schneider calls it reliable. But it does not diagnose PDA. It shows how much extreme demand avoidance is affecting a person's life.
Matt Harrington raised PDA during a Q&A on functional analysis. A functional analysis is a test that sets up conditions to find out why a behavior happens. Harrington said PDA is not his area of expertise and that he was sharing his opinion. When he works with someone with PDA, he learns all he can. He asks the client and caregivers questions and seeks mentorship. Then he builds his conditions from indirect assessment, like interviews, and descriptive assessment, like direct observation.
I'm not just saying, well, it's pathological demand avoidance, so there's no reason to include an attention function because we know it's probably going to be something to do with demands. I'm still considering all the variables and I'm still going off the indirect and descriptive assessment rather than just the diagnosis. From the talk — Matt Harrington
Harrington also flags assent. Assent means the person shows they are willing to take part. If a client is not assenting, he says you may need to rethink the assessment or plan.
Supporting people through a PDA lens#
Gray's main message on treatment is simple. You do not need a whole new set of PDA treatments. You need to present proven treatments in a way that gives the person choice.
It's not about reinventing the wheel as far as, oh, we now need to have all these new interventions just for PDA. It's how do we present these interventions through the lens of PDA, where our first goal is to provide autonomy to the individuals that we're working with so that they have some choice. From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray
Gray names several ways to do this. Use universal protocols, general strategies that help everyone in a setting, not just one person. Validate the person's emotional response. Offer chances to co-regulate, which means staying calm together so the person can settle. Troubleshoot problems with them, not for them.
For replacement behaviors, Gray suggests planning for flexibility. Instead of teaching one right response, teach several responses that get the need met. Then accept them when they happen. Gray also points to an enhanced choice model, where the person can choose to engage or opt out. Gray says that when people with PDA responses get that choice, they often keep going. They keep going because it was their choice.
Schneider adds a point about timing. Many teams drop a demand once behavior peaks, for safety. Schneider asks why not reinforce earlier instead. If you will have to drop the demand later anyway, drop it sooner. The workshop is built around alternatives to extinction. Extinction means withholding the reinforcer that keeps a behavior going. Schneider also points to Sidman's book Coercion and Its Fallout as a warning about harsh practices.
Wilder brings in ACT, short for Acceptance and Commitment Therapy. Wilder is clear that BCBAs are not being asked to act as mental health therapists. Wilder uses ACT to help people understand themselves, take back responsibility, and make their own choices.
Staying trauma informed#
Gray asks providers to pause before labeling a behavior as a problem. A behavior that looks defiant may be a response to feeling a loss of control.
instead of assuming like, oh, this is a maladaptive behavior I need to respond to in X way, is this a PDA thing? Like, is this a perception of a loss of autonomy, and a response to that perception? From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray
Gray then asks about the end goal. If the goal is a certain outcome, Gray says the path matters less than reaching it. Can you shape slowly toward it? Can you change how you present the task? Can you offer more accommodations? Gray gives providers a short self-check. Am I lowering anxiety? Am I raising autonomy? Am I giving support so we get there together?
Gray also turns the lens on the provider. A PDA response can trigger feelings in adults. It can look like behavior society calls rude or disrespectful. Gray says providers must care for themselves and plan ahead. They are responsible for their own histories and for changing their own patterns. This helps them respond calmly and avoid harm.
Gray closes the series with humility. Gray says the loss of autonomy behind these responses can be either very real or only perceived.
no one's going to be an expert in PDA. I am not an expert in PDA. We are still learning so much about it, but I hope that you have an understanding of the history and how the profile can present. From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray
Where experts disagree#
The presenters agree on a lot. All say PDA is not a formal U.S. diagnosis. All favor careful, person-centered support. But they frame what PDA is in different ways, and that changes how you approach it.
Wilder describes PDA as a behavior profile of autism. Harrington, sharing his opinion, calls it "kind of a subset of autism spectrum disorder." Both of these views tie PDA closely to autism.
Schneider and Gray take a different angle. They treat PDA as a response class that can show up with or without any diagnosis. Schneider says the label should not drive the work at all. The behaviors should. Gray notes the subtype and profile debate, then sets it aside for behavior analysis.
This is more than wording. If PDA is part of autism, you might lean on autism-based supports. If it is a response class, you start from the behaviors and their function. The research below also complicates the autism link.
There is a smaller difference on naming. Gray has moved away from "pathological" when talking with families. Wilder calls both names accurate. Neither presenter says the clinical term should vanish. They differ in how strongly they lead with the autonomy framing.
What the research says#
The research base is still small, which matches what the presenters say. A systematic review titled "Pathological demand avoidance in children and adolescents" found 13 relevant studies. All of them drew on the original descriptions by Newson and colleagues. Most relied only on parent reports. None asked people with PDA for their own views. The review notes critics who say the concept may overlook anxiety as a cause.
A study titled "Pathological demand avoidance: exploring the behavioural profile" compared three groups of children. These were 25 children labeled with PDA, 39 with autism, and 28 with conduct problems. The PDA group had autistic traits and peer problems similar to the autism group. The study also notes that routine and repetition are described as unhelpful for PDA. Reward-based methods also seem not to work as well.
Not every study ties PDA mainly to autism. A study titled "Individual differences, ADHD, adult pathological demand avoidance, and delinquency" surveyed 132 adults. ADHD was strongly linked to PDA scores. The link with autism was small. Another study, on children with epilepsy, found that 4 of 85 children showed strong PDA symptoms. All four also met criteria for ADHD.
One 2022 article in the journal Frontiers in Psychiatry (Philippe, 2022) compares Newson's account of PDA with other ways of describing autism. It shows how hard it is to draw clear lines between profiles.
For a fuller look at the history and identifying features, see Gray's course PDA: What it is and What it isn't.
FAQ#
Is pathological demand avoidance the same as being defiant? No. The presenters frame PDA as a drive for autonomy, not plain defiance. Gray points out that the person already has the skills for the task. The resistance comes from the demand itself, which can feel like a threat.
Can you diagnose PDA with the EDA-8? No. Schneider says the EDA-8 is a reliable tool, but it does not diagnose PDA. It shows how much extreme demand avoidance affects a person's life. PDA is not in the DSM-5 or the ICD-10.
Do behavior analysts need special interventions for PDA? Not according to Gray. Gray says to keep using proven, evidence-based methods. The change is in how you present them. Offer real choices, accept flexible responses, and lower anxiety while raising autonomy.
Turn this topic into a CEU
You just studied this. Now get credit for it.
Watch PDA Caregivers, Complex Profiles, Replacement Behaviors, and Being Trauma Informed with B. Kuerine Gray and earn 1.5 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.



