Manding: Teaching Kids to Ask for What They Want
Manding is asking for what you want. Learn how ABA teams pick a mand type, use real motivation, shape longer requests, and replace problem behavior.
Key takeaway
Manding is asking for something you want or need, like saying "juice" to get juice. In ABA, a mand is a request that is shaped by motivation and paid off by getting the thing asked for.

Solving Clinical Challenges with Research
Free learning path on this topic
Verbal Behavior: Beyond WH-Questions
Dana Pettus's three-part series on building generative verbal behavior. Why WH-question programs stall, how to establish speaker-listener repertoires, and how to scaffold advanced verbal skills like recall and simple inference. Three hours, three CEUs.
Experts who cover this
6 recordings on openceu cover manding.
- Featured talk2.5 Learning CEUs
Solving Clinical Challenges with Research
Matthew HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Case study 2 centers on a nonverbal six-year-old whose caregiver wants language development; Harrington walks the search from 'no identifiable echoics, tacts…
- 1 PDU
Beyond Table Work
Noah McAmisABA Collective / Camber
Repeated examples of creating manding opportunities (snack, swing, cereal aisle) by using naturally motivating moments rather than contrived trials.
- 1 Learning CEU
Collaboration and Building Rapport: Starting a Strong Foundation With Caregivers and Stakeholders in the Home
Eric SoltysikThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Described through a client using an AAC device: the team prioritized the manding goal first rather than running it alongside waiting/accepting-denied-access…
- 0.5 PDUs
Bite-Size Behavior Analysis: Differential Reinforcement
Anlara HoskinsCandid Contingencies, LLC
Used in a worked example of a client working on manding skills to access an iPad, where different topographies (two-word mand, one-word mand, screaming…
- 1.5 Learning CEUs
PDA Caregivers, Complex Profiles, Replacement Behaviors, and Being Trauma Informed
B. Kuerine GrayThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Used across multiple case examples (S's food refusal, O's advocacy skills, F's augmentative communication) as part of building functional communication before…
- 1 Learning CEU
Article Club: The Social Validity of Behavioral Interventions- Seeking Input from Autistic Adults
Pauli Catanese & Jasmine AbdelAchieve Behavior Partners
Used as an example of a functionally useful skill (contrasted with eye contact) that helps a client obtain things in daily life, illustrating the distinction…
On this page · 12 sections▾
Manding is asking for something you want or need, like saying "juice" to get juice. In ABA, a mand is a request that is shaped by motivation and paid off by getting the thing asked for. Mand training is the teaching that helps a person make those requests on their own.
Manding is often one of the first language skills a team teaches. A child who can ask has less reason to scream, hit, or grab. The ideas below come from clinicians who teach mands every day. They cover how to pick a way to ask and how to use real wanting. They also cover how to build longer requests and how to fit mands into bigger plans.
Why manding is usually taught first#
A mand gives a person power over their world. When a child cannot ask, they still want things. That wanting has to come out somehow. Often it comes out as crying, dropping to the floor, or aggression.
Matthew Harrington walked through this idea while reading a study for a real case. His client was a six year old who did not speak. The caregiver wanted language. The child had no clear echoics (repeating sounds or words), tacts (naming things), or intraverbals (answering or chatting). So the first question was about mands. The study's introduction made the point plainly.
So in the absence of functional man's behaviors occur. Recommended man's be targeted early. From the talk — Matthew Harrington
His short summary was "target man's ASAP." The goal is functional communication, which means talking or signing that actually works for the person in daily life. A mand pays off right away. The child asks and gets the thing. That quick payoff makes the mand more likely to happen again. It also gives the team a strong base for every other language skill that comes later.
Choosing how the learner will ask#
A mand does not have to be spoken. It can be a sign, a picture handed to an adult, a word, or a tap on a device. Picking the right mode is one of the first big choices in mand training.
Harrington's case used a study on brief prerequisite assessments. These are short checks of skills a learner may need before a given mode will work. The study compared three modes: sign, picture exchange, and vocal speech. It also added checks of echoic skills. The purpose was to see whether a quick assessment could predict which mode a child would learn fastest.
The participants matched his client closely.
13 kids could not engage in one word functional man's. From the talk — Matthew Harrington
Most of the children were autistic and between two and eight years old. Ten were new to ABA services. Some had already tried vocal mand training without success. The main goal for all of them was one word mands. Harrington noted that this fit his case almost perfectly. A study only helps if its learners look like yours. Checking the participant section first saves time and keeps the team from copying a method built for a very different child.
Motivation is what makes it a mand#
A mand only counts as a mand if the person wants the thing right now. Behavior analysts call this wanting an establishing operation, or EO. An EO is anything that makes an item more valuable in the moment. Being hungry is an EO for food. Being bored can be an EO for a toy.
This matters because a child can say "cookie" for many reasons. They might be copying an adult. They might be naming a picture. It is only a mand when they say it because they want the cookie and the cookie is what they get.
Noah McAmis built a whole exercise around this. He set up a simple scene for clinicians to practice.
The target is manding for preferred items. From the talk — Noah McAmis
The scene was a four year old in a clinic. The child had just finished table work and had a five minute break. The room had toys, blocks, a play kitchen, and a swing. McAmis asked clinicians to count how many natural chances to mand they could find in those five minutes. His point was that the break is not dead time. It is full of moments when the child already wants something.
Turning everyday play into mand practice#
McAmis walked through the room item by item. Each idea used something the child already wanted. None of it needed flash cards or a table.
With the swing, he suggested one push, then a stop and a wait. The child wants more.
So that's a mand for push or swing or more. From the talk — Noah McAmis
He noted that a clinician can get a mand on every single push. With blocks, the adult holds the pieces. Each block the child wants is a new reason to ask. With the play kitchen, the adult is the cook and has the food. The child has to order it, like "apple," "cookie," or "I want pizza." Then they switch roles. Now the adult orders, which gives a chance to model longer requests. With toys, he suggested putting a loved item in a container the child cannot open. Wind up toys work well for this.
The pattern is the same each time. Find what the child wants. Control access to it in a kind way. Then wait for the ask. McAmis told clinicians not to overthink it. Short answers like "hold the swing until they ask" count as a full idea.
Shaping longer requests with differential reinforcement#
Once a child can ask with one word, teams often want longer mands. A tool called differential reinforcement helps here. It means giving a better payoff to the form of behavior you want most, and a smaller payoff to other forms.
Anlara Hoskins used an iPad example. Her client could get the iPad several ways. They could scream. They could hit. They could say "iPad." They could say "want iPad." All of these are different topographies, or forms, of behavior. But they share one function. They all get the iPad. That makes them one response class.
The team picked "want iPad" as the best form.
We want those two-word mans. And so when they say one iPad, they get the champion outcome. From the talk — Anlara Hoskins
The "champion outcome" means the best possible consequence. The child gets the iPad faster, keeps it longer, gets better apps, or gets more praise. But Hoskins added an important detail. Saying just "iPad" still works too. Some days a child is not bringing everything to the table. The team does not want to punish any vocal communication. So the one word mand still earns the iPad, just a smaller version of the reward. Screaming and hitting are the forms the team wants to fade out.
Mands as a replacement for problem behavior#
Many families come to ABA because of tantrums or aggression. They may ask why the team is teaching requests instead of "fixing" the tantrums. Eric Soltysik spoke to this directly. Sometimes the beginning goal is simply getting the client what they need. Then they do not have to go through a full tantrum to get it.
This is the logic of a replacement behavior. The tantrum and the mand often do the same job for the child. If the mand works faster and easier, the tantrum has less reason to happen. Hoskins's iPad example shows the same idea from a different angle. Screaming, hitting, and "want iPad" all sit in one response class. Teaching the mand gives the child a better path to the same result.
B. Kuerine Gray used mand training this way across several hard cases. For one client with extreme food refusal, she described the early work.
we worked on pairing, shaping, and man training From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray
Pairing means building a link between the clinician or setting and good things. For this client, the table where food appeared had to become a place with nothing but positive associations. The goals of functional communication and food acceptance were valued by the family and the client. They were also needed to avoid a hospital stay.
Two ways clinicians sequence mand training#
The sources share the same core view. Mands come early, and they work as a replacement for problem behavior. But they show two different ways of timing mand goals against tolerance goals. Tolerance goals teach a person to wait, to hear "no," or to handle a demand without escalating.
Soltysik argued for doing the mand goal first and on its own.
I have a client who utilize ANA. AAC device and when we were starting treatment, we had the manding goal, we also or had a waiting and an accepting. From the talk — Eric Soltysik
AAC stands for augmentative and alternative communication, such as a speech device. His full plan also had an "accepting denied access" goal. He told the parents and team they would focus on the mand goal first. In his view, doing everything at the same time would confuse the client and work against the overall goal.
Gray described a different pattern for a 14 year old with severe aggression.
we worked on advocacy skills, man training, and SBT for tolerance of demand presentation From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray
SBT stands for skill-based treatment, a method that pairs functional communication training with teaching tolerance of waiting and demands. Here the mand work and a tolerance plan ran side by side. The two speakers were not debating each other, and their clients were very different. Still, the contrast is real. One clinician holds tolerance goals until the mand is solid. The other builds both at once. Teams may want to weigh the learner's history, safety needs, and how fast the mand is coming along when they choose.
Mand training in complex profiles#
Mand training is not only for young children learning first words. Gray's cases show how it fits into care for older clients and complex profiles.
Her 14 year old client had severe aggression. Mand training sat next to advocacy skills, which teach a person to speak up for their own needs. The caregiver side of the plan mattered just as much. Caregivers learned to offer chances for autonomy and to adjust their expectations. They learned to change how they framed demands. They also learned to honor and reinforce requests when the client made them.
One part of that caregiver training stood out. The client had physical conditions that could cause pain. There were signs of pain in their behavior, but the signs were subtle and were being missed. Gray's team taught all caregivers to read those cues and respond. A mand only works if someone is listening for it. Teaching the listener can be as important as teaching the person who asks.
Another client of Gray's had some augmentative communication but did not start using it on their own, even after years of exposure. Cases like this show that access to a device is not the same as a working mand.
Why manding counts as a quality of life goal#
Not every goal in ABA serves the client. A study discussed by Pauli Catanese asked autistic adults about this. They strongly backed goals tied to safety, independence, and quality of life. They rejected goals aimed at normalization, which means making someone look more typical.
During the discussion, a question came up. How should a BCBA tell the two kinds of goals apart? Catanese's answer was to ask whether the skill actually helps the client in daily life. She used manding as her example.
Manding. Manding. You can. Mand. For a lot of things. And that helps you. From the talk — Pauli Catanese
She set this against eye contact, which does not necessarily help a person in everyday life. Manding helps someone function on their own. It lets them get food, breaks, help, and comfort. That is why mand goals tend to pass the social validity test. Social validity means the people affected agree the goal is worth it. Catanese also suggested talking with parents about what matters to them, and then explaining that normalization goals fall outside the team's practice.
Bringing families into the plan#
Every speaker touched on families in some way. Mand training works best when the people around the learner understand it and use it.
Soltysik stressed open talk between the family and the team. Families may want the tantrums gone first. Explaining why the team starts with the mand helps everyone pull in the same direction. He noted that if the team is not talking, no one knows what is going on. That ongoing dialogue keeps the plan steady.
Gray used behavioral skills training, or BST, with caregivers. BST is a teach, show, practice, and feedback method. Her team used it to teach caregivers about communication and about setting up a calmer, more accommodating home. Caregivers also worked on building positive interactions and a stronger relationship with the client.
For a deeper look at working with caregivers in the home, see Collaboration and Building Rapport: Starting a Strong Foundation With Caregivers and Stakeholders in the Home.
What the research says#
Research backs up the clinical focus on motivation. A recent tutorial defines the mand as a response under the control of an establishing operation (Frampton et al., 2024). It also stresses that teaching nonverbal and minimally verbal autistic learners to ask for wants and needs is a top priority. The same tutorial explains that pointing or reaching, called indicating responses, can tell a teacher whether motivation is present.
A large review found a gap in many mand training studies (McCammon et al., 2024). Few studies checked whether the learner actually used or consumed the item they asked for. Without that check, it is hard to say the response worked as a true mand. The authors suggest teaching learners to ask when they want something and to hold off when they do not. They also suggest that staff and parents do a correspondence check, watching whether the learner engages with what they requested.
Other studies look at how prompting shapes mands. One study compared dense and lean prompt schedules, meaning frequent prompts versus infrequent ones, while keeping reinforcement rates similar. It looked at how well the mands held up under change (Ringdahl et al., 2023). Another study adjusted concurrent schedules of reinforcement, meaning the team offered more than one reward option at the same time. With and without added prompts, this approach led three autistic boys to ask for a wider variety of items (Seaver et al., 2023). That variety can help learners reach more kinds of reinforcers.
FAQ#
What is the difference between a mand and a tact? A mand is a request driven by wanting something. A tact is naming something you see, hear, or touch. Saying "ball" to get a ball is a mand. Saying "ball" because you see one is a tact.
Does a mand have to be spoken? No. A mand can be a sign, a picture exchange, a word, or a button on an AAC device. Teams often use a short assessment to pick the mode a learner is most likely to learn quickly.
How do you create chances to mand during play? Find what the child already wants and gently control access to it. Push a swing once and wait. Hold the blocks. Put a favorite toy in a clear container. Then wait for the child to ask.
Turn this topic into a CEU
You just studied this. Now get credit for it.
Watch Solving Clinical Challenges with Research with Matthew Harrington and earn 2.5 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.
Keep going with a free learning path
Verbal Behavior: Beyond WH-Questions
Dana Pettus's three-part series on building generative verbal behavior. Why WH-question programs stall, how to establish speaker-listener repertoires, and how to scaffold advanced verbal skills like recall and simple inference. Three hours, three CEUs.

