Differential Reinforcement of Other Behavior (DRO)
DRO gives reinforcement when a target behavior does not happen for a set time. Learn how to set intervals, avoid resets, and use DRO well.
Key takeaway
Differential reinforcement of other behavior (DRO) is a procedure that gives a reward for the absence of a target behavior. The reward comes only after that behavior stays away for a set amount of time.
Crash Course in Behavior Analytic Toilet Training: Translating Research to Practice
Free learning path on this topic
Ethics Essentials
Three free courses worth 5.5 CEUs, 4 of them ethics. Start with Matt Harrington's assent and data course, then ethical guardrails in behavior reduction, then cultural considerations in clinical practice. Each course issues its own certificate.
Experts who cover this
6 recordings on openceu cover differential reinforcement of other behavior.
- Featured talk2 CEUs (1 Ethics, 1 Supervision)
Crash Course in Behavior Analytic Toilet Training: Translating Research to Practice
Dr. Jessica OsosCopper Consulting Group
DRO for staying dry — reinforcing intervals of continence rather than punishing accidents — is presented as the key evidence-based replacement for punishment…
- 2 CEUs (1 Learning, 1 Ethics)
Alternatives to Extinction for Supporting Extreme Demand Avoidant Behavior
Nicola Schneider, LBA-NJNRS Compassionate Behavior Services
DRO is described as still containing an escape-extinction component since zero rates of the problem behavior are required, teaching tolerance of aversive…
- 1 Learning CEU
Contingency Management: Applied Behavior Analysis's Evidence-Based Contribution to Substance Use Treatment
Hal FosterThe Behaviorist Bookclub
When abstinence is the target behavior in CM, the procedure functions like DRO: reinforcement is delivered for the absence of a response across an interval…
- 2.5 Learning CEUs
Solving Clinical Challenges with Research
Matthew HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Harrington uses a DRO-with-break example to show that demographics and real-world implementation can flip a reinforcement-based program into de facto…
- 2 Learning CEUs
Prediction and Probabilities: Three foundational equations to successful behavior reduction
Matt HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
DRO is discussed as riskier than NCR when an extinction burst can't be tolerated, since a DRO resets its interval contingent on behavior occurring. Matt gives…
- 2.5 Learning CEUs
5 Days of Manding Mastery
Matt HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Contrasted with the DRA variant of contingency-based progressive delay: reinforcement is delivered only after a required interval passes without challenging…
On this page · 12 sections▾
Differential reinforcement of other behavior (DRO) is a procedure that gives a reward for the absence of a target behavior. The reward comes only after that behavior stays away for a set amount of time. If the behavior does happen, the timer starts over and no reward is given for that stretch.
DRO is often used to reduce problem behavior like aggression or self-injury. It also shows up in toilet training and in addiction treatment. The idea sounds simple. In practice, small choices about timing and delivery decide whether DRO helps or quietly fails.
How a DRO works, step by step#
A DRO has three parts. First, you pick the behavior you want to see less of. Second, you pick a time window, called the interval. Third, you pick a reward the person actually wants.
Then the clock runs. If the person gets through the whole interval without the target behavior, they earn the reward. If the behavior happens, the clock resets to zero. The person has to start the wait again.
Notice what DRO does not do. It does not name a specific new behavior to teach. The person can do almost anything "other" than the target behavior and still earn the reward. That is where the name comes from.
Matt Harrington describes a common setup with a break as the reward.
let's say there is a DRO approach, um, in a DRO in place. And the idea is that the client doesn't aggress for, you know, one minute and every one minute they get reinforced with a break. From the talk — Matthew Harrington
In this example, the reward is escape from work for a short time. The target is aggression. The interval is one minute. Each of those three choices matters, as the next sections show.
How DRO differs from DRA#
DRO is easy to confuse with DRA, or differential reinforcement of alternative behavior. The two sound alike, but they ask different things of the learner.
In a DRA, you name a specific replacement behavior. The person earns the reward by doing that behavior. In a DRO, you only ask the person to not do the target behavior. Any other behavior is fine.
Harrington shows the contrast while describing ways to fade functional communication training. That is when a person has learned to ask for what they want, and the team slowly teaches them to wait. In the DRA version, a caregiver might say, "I can come play with you, but first put away the dishes." Over time the task grows. It becomes dishes, then dishes and cleaning the room, then homework too.
The DRO version works differently.
The other is the DRO, which is a typical DRO. So you have to go X amount of minutes without a challenging behavior. From the talk — Matt Harrington
Once that time passes with no challenging behavior, the person's request is honored. Both paths stretch out the wait for the reward. But only the DRA path builds a named skill along the way. That difference is worth keeping in mind when choosing between them.
Setting the interval with inter-response time#
The interval is the most important design choice in a DRO. If it is too long, the person rarely earns anything. If it is too short, staff may struggle to keep up. So how long should it be?
Harrington offers a starting point based on inter-response time. That is the average time between one instance of the behavior and the next. You find it by looking at baseline data before treatment starts. He describes a rule of thumb he was taught for setting the interval.
interval you use is half of the inner response time of the behavior. From the talk — Matt Harrington
He gives a clear example. Say self-injury happens about once every two minutes. Half of two minutes is one minute. So the rule for reward becomes "no self-injury for one minute." If the person makes it, they get the reward.
The logic is simple. A person who already goes two minutes between behaviors will often make it to one minute. That means they earn rewards early and often. Success comes fast, which helps the new pattern take hold. Harrington frames this as a rule of thumb, not a fixed law, so baseline data still has to guide the final call.
Why short intervals help prevent extinction bursts#
An extinction burst is a short spike in behavior when it suddenly stops working. The behavior may get louder, faster, or more intense before it fades. For mild behavior, a burst is a nuisance. For severe behavior, it can be dangerous.
Harrington points to head banging as an example. If that behavior spikes, a trip to the hospital could follow. In those cases, he notes that noncontingent reinforcement, or NCR, may be the safer pick. NCR gives rewards on a schedule no matter what the person does. It keeps the environment rich in rewards from the start. DRO does too, he says, but only if things go well.
That is because a DRO resets every time the behavior happens. If resets pile up, rewards dry up. A short interval protects against this.
The smaller the inner response time for a DRO, the more reinforcement-rich the environment is, thus the less fearful of an extinction burst you have to be. From the talk — Matt Harrington
A short interval means more chances to win, and more wins mean less of the frustration that drives a burst. When a team cannot risk a burst at all, that is when to weigh NCR against DRO.
When the timer never runs out#
Here is a trap that is easy to miss. A team writes a DRO plan. On paper, it is a reward-based program. But the person never makes it through a single interval.
the client never makes it to one minute so the DRO keeps resetting and they never received that break. From the talk — Matthew Harrington
Harrington explains what this really means for the person. The plan says reinforcement. The person's daily life says something else.
but what the client's experiencing is, is extinction. There, there is no skills being taught there, right? From the talk — Matthew Harrington
Extinction means the behavior no longer gets its usual payoff. In this case, the person also gets no reward for anything else. They are simply cut off. Nothing new is being taught.
The lesson is to watch what the person actually experiences, not just what the plan says. Check how often rewards are being delivered. If the count is near zero, the interval is too long for this person right now. Shortening it is often the first fix. The half inter-response time rule from the last section is one way to reset it.
DRO as a replacement for punishment in toilet training#
DRO is not only for aggression or self-injury. Dr. Jessica Osos describes how it has become a core part of modern toilet-training packages. There it is called "DRO for staying dry."
So this is the newer common component that is supposed to replace punishment. From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos
Older toilet-training programs often used punishment to reduce accidents. Osos explains that DRO works the opposite way.
the function of it is to reinforce the absence of accidents From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos
Punishment aims to decrease accidents directly. DRO instead rewards the stretches of time when no accident happens.
How this looks depends on the protocol. In one 2020 study she reviewed, children got a preferred item before every scheduled sit on the toilet. In her own studies, children got a lower-preferred item every 30 minutes that they stayed dry.
That choice of reward is deliberate. Osos notes that research often saves the top item for successful voids on the toilet. That item comes from a preference assessment, a formal test of what someone likes most. Lower-preferred items are used for things like the DRO for staying dry. This keeps the strongest reward tied to the most important skill.
What the toilet-training evidence suggests about punishment#
Osos also points to results from Perez and colleagues. Their package included a preference assessment, training to request the bathroom, and DRO for staying dry. It also used a dense sit schedule of every 30 minutes. All children wore underwear during the study. Perez and colleagues trained 11 of their 13 participants without using any punishment component.
a punishment component may only be necessary for a limited number of individuals From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos
Osos treats this as a central point for practice. Teams do not need to start toilet training with punishment to see results. DRO for staying dry gives a reward-based way to target accidents from day one. She also notes the study's own limits. Adding request training led to faulty stimulus control of requesting. That means children did not always ask at the right times. DRO is one part of a package, not the whole answer.
DRO logic in contingency management#
Contingency management is an addiction treatment that gives rewards for meeting goals. The rewards are delivered right away. They might be a voucher, a prize draw, or a gift card. Hal Foster explains that the target can vary. Some programs reward a negative drug test. Others reward attendance, taking medication, or other healthy habits.
When the target is attendance, the program rewards a behavior directly. But when the target is abstinence, Foster points out a link that behavior analysts will recognize.
notice that when abstinence is the target, the procedure kind of works like differential reinforcement of other behavior. Reinforcement is delivered for the absence of a target response across an interval and verified by a biological test. From the talk — Hal Foster
The interval might be days instead of minutes. The check is a lab test instead of a staff member's eyes. But the shape is the same as a DRO. Reward comes when the behavior did not happen.
Foster is careful about this framing. He calls it an analytic point for discussion, not a claim drawn from the contingency management research. He also says he prefers rewarding attendance or medication adherence. Those are things a person actively does. Still, he notes that anyone who has built a DRO schedule in autism services has already made these kinds of design choices.
The debate about whether DRO is really reinforcement#
One question about DRO has not been settled. Does it work by rewarding other behavior? Or does it work mostly by taking away the payoff for the target behavior?
The speakers frame DRO in different ways. Osos describes it as reinforcing the absence of accidents and as a reward-based stand-in for punishment. Foster says abstinence-based programs "kind of" work like DRO, and he flags that view as open for discussion. Harrington is the most cautious. He calls DRO a "reinforcement ish" intervention. He also notes there are ongoing discussions about whether DRO counts as reinforcement at all, without taking a side.
His reset example shows why the question matters in daily practice. If a person never earns the reward, DRO acts like plain extinction. In that case, calling it a reward-based plan is mostly a label.
The research described below adds nuance without settling the debate. Studies generally find that other behavior does rise during DRO, at least for a while. But that rise does not always last, even as the target behavior stays low. Rey et al. and Hangen et al., covered below, each found pieces of this pattern. Together, their findings point to a mix of extinction and reinforcement rather than one explanation alone. For clinicians, the practical upshot is the same either way. Track both how often the target behavior happens and how often the reward is actually earned.
Matching the plan to the person#
Harrington ties DRO to a bigger point about clinical judgment. A person's diagnoses and the way they interact with the world shape how they experience any intervention. Two people on the same DRO plan may live it in very different ways.
He warns against assuming we know how a client will experience a plan. Demographic variables do matter, he says. But it is hard to make sweeping statements about any group, since needs vary so widely within a spectrum. So the answer has to come from the person in front of you.
For DRO, that means a few things. Base the interval on this person's own baseline data, not a standard number. Pick a reward this person actually wants right now. Then watch the first sessions closely. Is the person earning rewards? Is behavior getting worse before it gets better? Is the plan feeling like reward or like loss?
For more on this way of thinking, see Solving Clinical Challenges with Research.
What the research says#
Lab and clinical studies have tried to explain why DRO works. One line of research asks whether DRO strengthens other behavior by chance. In a long-duration study with university students, DRO lowered target responding and raised other responding more than control conditions. But the rise in other responding usually did not last, even as the target behavior stayed low (Rey et al., 2020). The authors concluded that chance reinforcement of other behavior could not fully explain the drop.
A related study with children found that other behavior rose in at least one DRO condition. That held true for every participant (Hangen et al., 2020). That supports the idea that DRO boosts other behavior, at least early on. The authors framed the results in terms of both extinction and reinforcement.
Treatment fidelity also matters. Fidelity means how closely staff follow the plan. Both kinds of errors weakened DRO for some participants. Those were giving a reward when it was not earned and failing to give one that was. In some cases, giving unearned rewards pushed behavior above baseline levels (Hronek & Kestner, 2025).
Finally, DRO is not always the strongest option. One study looked at stereotypy, repetitive actions like hand-flapping or rocking. This stereotypy was maintained by automatic reinforcement, meaning the behavior itself produced the reward with no other person involved. DRA produced better results than DRO on every measure in that study (Hedquist & Roscoe, 2020). That included less stereotypy and more task engagement and completion.
FAQ#
What is an example of differential reinforcement of other behavior?
A child earns a short break for every minute without aggression. If aggression happens, the one-minute timer starts over. In toilet training, a child might get a small treat every 30 minutes they stay dry.
How do you choose a DRO interval?
A common rule of thumb is to use half of the behavior's inter-response time. If self-injury happens about every two minutes, the interval would be one minute. Adjust from there based on how often the person earns the reward.
What is the difference between DRO and DRA?
DRO rewards the absence of a target behavior for a set time. DRA rewards a specific replacement behavior that you choose and teach. DRA builds a named skill, while DRO does not.
Turn this topic into a CEU
You just studied this. Now get credit for it.
Watch Crash Course in Behavior Analytic Toilet Training: Translating Research to Practice with Dr. Jessica Osos and earn 2 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.
Keep going with a free learning path
Ethics Essentials
Three free courses worth 5.5 CEUs, 4 of them ethics. Start with Matt Harrington's assent and data course, then ethical guardrails in behavior reduction, then cultural considerations in clinical practice. Each course issues its own certificate.


