Practical Functional Assessment (PFA): An Expert Guide

Practical functional assessment (PFA) pairs a caregiver interview with a short, safe test of why behavior happens. See what ABA experts and research say.

Key takeaway

Practical functional assessment (PFA) is a way to find out why problem behavior happens. It starts with a caregiver interview, then tests the caregiver's hunches in a short, safe analysis.

12 days of PFA & SBT
Watch the full CEU recording

12 days of PFA & SBT

Matt Harrington · 3 CEU · 156 min
Watch on openceu.com →
Free learning pathStep 1 of 3 in Master PFA and SBTSee the whole path →

Experts who cover this

6 recordings on openceu cover practical functional assessment.

Practical functional assessment (PFA) is a way to find out why problem behavior happens. It starts with a caregiver interview, then tests the caregiver's hunches in a short, safe analysis. It was developed by Dr. Greg Hanley and colleagues. It tests a whole package of triggers and rewards together, instead of one at a time.

PFA usually leads straight into skill-based treatment (SBT). SBT teaches communication and tolerance skills that replace the problem behavior. Experts who use PFA every day agree on the basics. They differ on when to use it, how to adapt it, and how much to trust it.

Where PFA came from and what it is called#

Matt Harrington traces PFA back to one key paper. In 2014, Hanley and his team tested a new kind of functional analysis. A functional analysis is a test that shows what keeps a behavior going. Harrington explains what that paper set out to do.

The purpose of Hanley et al. 2014 was to demonstrate a model of functional analysis that included synthesized contingencies in the analysis and then the treatment of said challenging behavior.

From the talk — Matt Harrington

A synthesized contingency is an "if this, then that" rule with many parts. For example, problem behavior might earn a break, a toy, and attention all at once. Harrington stresses that social validity was the focus from the start. Social validity means the families and clients find the process helpful and acceptable.

The names can be confusing. The test inside PFA is often called an IISCA. That stands for interview-informed synthesized contingency analysis. Harrington treats the terms as close cousins.

So, I'm going to use the term ISCA. That's similar to PFA, which is similar to synthesized contingency analysis, just like I'm going to use the term traditional FA or trad FA.

From the talk — Matt Harrington

A "traditional FA" tests one reward at a time, such as attention alone. In Hanley's 2014 data, Harrington points to a client named Gail. Her behavior showed a clear pattern only in the synthesized test. When the team split tangibles and attention apart, the pattern disappeared.

The three steps of a PFA#

Dr. Joshua Jessel helped Hanley design the PFA. He calls himself a "practitioner scientist" rather than a scientist first. He says he built the PFA as something he would want to use as a clinician. He lays it out simply.

The process of the practical functional assessment has three steps.

From the talk — Dr. Joshua Jessel

Step one is an open-ended interview. Open-ended means the questions do not have set answer choices. Caregivers describe the behavior and what is going on around it.

The PFA begins with an open-ended interview that asks caregivers about their experiences with problem behavior and the context in which it occurs.

From the talk — Dr. Joshua Jessel

Step two is an unstructured observation. Here the clinician sees the behavior and the caregiver's routine up close. Jessel says this is where you "test out those hunches a little bit." Step three is the analysis itself, built from what the first two steps showed.

Jessel gives one firm warning about planning. He says if you can picture your test conditions before meeting the child, "you're assuming far too much." He never walks in with standard conditions already in mind. Each analysis is built from that family's story.

Happy, relaxed, and engaged comes first#

Every PFA has a calm state at its center. Clinicians call it happy, relaxed, and engaged, or HRE. In plain words, HRE means the person is content, calm, and busy with something they like. It is the "off switch" for problem behavior.

Lindsay Anderson uses SBT to help children with sleep problems. She explains how the interview finds that off switch.

So during the interview portion of the practical functional assessment, parents will provide information on what needs to be in the environment for the child to be happy and have very little risk of challenging behaviors

From the talk — Lindsay Anderson

The team then builds a synthesized reinforcement context. That is a setting filled with the child's favorite things and the attention they like. It leaves out everything the child dislikes. Anderson says HRE must happen before any other step. Sometimes the team tries a few setups before getting it right.

Nicky Schneider, who works in schools, ties HRE directly to the test.

HRE is part of the skill based treatment framework. Within the practical functional assessment, we're looking to establish HRE so that we can turn the behavior off immediately.

From the talk — Nicky Schneider

During the analysis, the clinician moves between HRE and a test condition. A test condition, also called an EO, is a short, planned moment that might bring on behavior. EO is short for establishing operation. It means a change that makes a reward more wanted, such as taking away a tablet.

Why the interview carries so much weight#

Early PFAs could take an hour or more. Matt Harrington notes that research by Jessel and others has shrunk that time a great deal. He now says time is no longer an issue for most clinicians. The bigger risk, he argues, is a weak interview.

In a single-session ISCA, the clinician may only present the test condition once. Harrington explains the stakes.

in order to do a single session ISCA you have one chance to get it right you have one instance of test

From the talk — Matt Harrington

If the guess is wrong, he says, you lose five to ten minutes of the client's time. Then you go back to the drawing board. His fix is a strong caregiver interview and a strong caregiver observation. Both feed the design of that first test.

Jessel makes a similar point about why the interview matters. He says that knowing how the triggers and rewards show up for caregivers "allows us to make function hunches." Eric Soltysik adds a rapport angle. He points to Greg Hanley's "learn by listening" message from the PFA website. Soltysik's view is that parents are the experts on their child. Listening before jumping to conclusions helps clinicians see what they might miss.

Control as its own reason for behavior#

B. Kuereine Gray works with people who show a pathological demand avoidance (PDA) profile. PDA describes a strong drive to avoid everyday demands. For years, she heard clinicians say there must be a "control" function. She used to push back and call it an access function.

PFA changed how she sees it. Because PFA tests what the person actually wants, it can capture a need for control.

For many years, I heard many clinicians who were like, oh, there's got to be another function. It's for control. And I was like, well, that's an access function. But we do have some individuals that we work with that control is a huge part of their behavior repertoire.

From the talk — B. Kuereine Gray

Gray gives real examples of control. A person may insist you sit in one spot and not another. They may object when you change your hair. They may need you to repeat their exact words before they can move on. They may need the same clothes or the same route home every day. A PFA interview can surface these details. A test of attention or escape alone might miss them.

Changing a PFA in the moment for a trauma response#

Gray also shares one of the most striking PFA cases on record. About three years ago, she ran a PFA with a clinical supervisee. The assessment was for an adult's planning through their state disability agency.

Gray already knew this person well. They had been very social. They started conversations often. They liked holding hands and giving high fives. By the time of the assessment, all of that had gone away.

The team presented the test condition. Problem behavior showed up at a low level. They returned the person to HRE. The person pulled Gray to sit on the bed with them. Then, during that second calm period, something changed. The person began staring into space and stopped responding.

Normally, a clinician would stop the PFA at that point. Gray did not. She says this is the only PFA in her career where she continued the trial instead of stopping it.

She explains the choice came down to how the behavior looked. Because she knew the person's trauma history, she could read the staring as a trauma response, not as the target behavior. That knowledge let her change course instead of quitting. Her lesson is clear. A PFA is not a script. Knowing a client's history can change how you read what happens in the room.

When PFA meets older, more verbal learners#

Matt Harrington warns that PFA research does not always fit every client. He points to his own work on ISCA and trauma-informed care. Early PFA and SBT studies mostly involved people with limited language and daily living skills.

When you went to apply PFA and SBT all the way up to teens and adults who did have more functional living skills, things got a little weird. We had more problem behavior. We had more precursors.

From the talk — Matt Harrington

Precursors are small, early behaviors that often come before bigger problem behavior. Harrington's lesson goes beyond PFA. Before copying a study, look at who was in it. Language level, diagnoses, resources, and staff skill all shape results. If your client looks very different from the study's participants, adjust your plan.

This lines up with Gray's trauma case. Both involve adults with complex histories. Both suggest a PFA designed for young children may need changes for older clients.

Building the relationship before the assessment#

Valerie Weber shares a case from a school summer program. Her student had restraints in his history and many unsafe behaviors. Her first instinct was clear.

I immediately thought, OK, I need to conduct a practical functional assessment and start skill based treatment with a student.

From the talk — Valerie Weber

In her talk, Weber describes coaching that steered her to build a strong, connected relationship first. That relationship worked, maybe a little too well. It then changed how SBT played out.

Because we had developed such a great relationship, whenever I would put in a demand, he would try to run away and laugh so we could play chase. And so it made me have to rethink a little bit and do SBT in a little bit different order.

From the talk — Valerie Weber

Her story shows that rapport is not just a warm-up. It can change what the child wants from you. A child who loves playing with you may treat demands as a game. Clinicians should expect the PFA and SBT steps to bend around the relationship.

Setting boundaries on the synthesized reinforcer#

Nicky Schneider learned a hard lesson about HRE in schools. She once went to great lengths to find everything a student needed to be happy, relaxed, and engaged. Then she realized some of it was not safe. Some of it would also not work when she was not there.

She says synthesized reinforcement is "not something you can just hold in your hand." It may be many things together. In a school, parts of that package may be off the table. Staff may not have time for the attention a student wants. A student cannot play video games all day.

Schneider also will not use food rewards in school, since it is usually not snack or lunch time. If the PFA points to food, she asks more about meals instead. She checks whether the student is eating enough. She credits mentors who taught her about setting kind but firm limits. Her takeaway is that HRE should be realistic for the setting where treatment will happen.

When to bring caregivers into treatment#

Matt Harrington notes that PFA and SBT practice has shifted on caregiver training. Early on, many clinicians worked through treatment first and handed it off to families at the end.

The other approach I've seen in the beginning of the PFA and SBT that I was trained in, it was typically, I'm going to get us to the finish line and then generalize at home.

From the talk — Matt Harrington

Generalize means getting the new skills to show up in other places and with other people. Today, Harrington says, many clinicians do full caregiver training from the very beginning. He compares this to feeding research. That field now focuses on renewal, which is when behavior comes back after a change of setting. Training caregivers early may lower that risk.

Neither choice is wrong in every case. But the trend is moving families into the process sooner.

Choosing PFA over other functional analysis formats#

Is PFA always the best choice? Matt Harrington says no single format wins every time. He calls PFA a strong tool among several.

I think it's important to consider the practical functional assessment as an extremely powerful tool in your wider functional analysis format or toolbox.

From the talk — Matt Harrington

He lists latency-based and trial-based formats as strong choices too. All are backed by research. His rule is to let the client's data decide. If caregiver interviews point to a package of triggers and rewards, use a synthesized test. Then build treatment from it.

He also urges clinicians to begin with the end in mind. Ask where treatment will need to go before choosing a format. And learn the method before using it. He points to training resources and a PFA and SBT Facebook group. He covers this format choice in more depth in Confessions of a New Behavior Analyst in Functional Analysis.

Where experts disagree#

The speakers agree PFA is useful. They do not all agree on how much we can trust what it tells us.

Dr. Tom Szabo raises the sharpest concern. He credits Hanley with framing the core strategy as manipulating EOs and AOs. AOs, or abolishing operations, are changes that make a reward less wanted. But Szabo also points to questions raised by Jeff Tiger.

One of the things I think that has been very important in the last year was that Jeff Tiger posed some questions regarding the practical functional analysis because when you start synthesizing different elements that could be controlling variables together, to what extent does your test establish predictive validity?

From the talk — Dr. Tom Szabo

Predictive validity asks whether a test actually predicts which treatment will work. Szabo adds a second worry. When you lump many parts into one package, you lose the ability to tell which part caused the result. Researchers call this discriminant validity.

Dr. Joshua Jessel and Matt Harrington lean the other way. Jessel designed the PFA to be quick and usable in real clinics. Harrington's reading of the Hanley 2014 data is that some behavior only shows a clear pattern when tested as a package. Still, Harrington admits the debate is live. He says research can feel like "ping pong," with one group favoring PFA and the other favoring isolated tests.

Valerie Weber's case adds a quieter tension. Her first move was to start a PFA. The coaching she describes put the relationship first.

What the research says#

Studies show both promise and open questions for PFA.

One study looked at whether two separate PFA processes for the same child agreed (Rajaraman et al., 2022). Agreement varied depending on how strictly it was judged. But treatments built from either PFA worked, and the gains carried over. The authors concluded the PFA has strong treatment value even when parts are less reliable.

A school-based study ran PFA and SBT with six children with autism (Slaton et al., 2024). Problem behavior dropped to near zero across staff and settings. One year later, the effects held. Restraint and other crisis procedures were no longer used for any participant.

Another study tested the full model with two young people who also had mental health diagnoses (Coffey et al., 2021). The PFA found useful reinforcers, and problem behavior stayed low as demands increased. Parents and teachers rated the results as valuable.

Not all reviews are glowing. One paper argues that most PFA training materials focus on its strengths (Kranak & Briggs, 2025). The authors say many clinicians now treat it as the best FA without enough attention to its limits. They call for clearer guidance on when PFA should be used.

FAQ#

What is the difference between a PFA and a traditional functional analysis?

A traditional functional analysis tests one reward at a time, such as attention alone or escape alone. A PFA starts with an open-ended caregiver interview. It then tests the whole package of triggers and rewards together. It also keeps the person happy, relaxed, and engaged between short test moments.

How long does a practical functional assessment take?

Early versions could take an hour or more. Newer single-session versions can take much less time. Matt Harrington says time is no longer an issue for most clinicians. A strong caregiver interview matters more than the clock.

Is PFA safe for clients with severe behavior or trauma?

PFA was designed to keep behavior at low levels and end each test quickly. B. Kuereine Gray's case shows that trauma responses can still appear. Knowing a client's history helps clinicians spot those moments and adjust. Experts also recommend formal training before running a PFA alone.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch 12 days of PFA & SBT with Matt Harrington and earn 3 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert
Free learning pathStep 1 of 3 in Master PFA and SBTSee the whole path →