Enhanced Choice Model: Letting Learners Opt In or Out

The enhanced choice model lets learners join treatment, hang out, or leave at any time. Learn how it works, why kids stay, and how to use it.

Key takeaway

The enhanced choice model is a way of running skill-based treatment where the learner can join the work, take a free break, or leave at any time. Every option still leads to good things.

12 days of PFA & SBT
Watch the full CEU recording

12 days of PFA & SBT

Matt Harrington · 3 CEU · 156 min
Watch on openceu.com →
Free learning pathStep 1 of 3 in Master PFA and SBTSee the whole path →

Experts who cover this

7 recordings on openceu cover enhanced choice model.

The enhanced choice model is a way of running skill-based treatment where the learner can join the work, take a free break, or leave at any time. Every option still leads to good things. The learner is never trapped and never punished for saying no.

The model was built to treat dangerous behavior without physical holds or forced compliance. It keeps the core teaching tools of practical functional assessment and skill-based treatment. Then it adds trauma-informed pieces, meaning changes designed to avoid re-triggering past trauma, like choice, safety signals, and a real exit. The surprising result is that most learners choose to stay and work.

Where the enhanced choice model came from#

The model grew out of skill-based treatment, often called SBT. SBT teaches a learner to ask for what they need, wait, and follow directions. It is usually paired with practical functional assessment, or PFA, which finds out why a behavior happens. Matt Harrington calls the enhanced choice model a trauma-informed redesign of that package. Its purpose was to strip out the harsher parts, like extinction. Extinction means no longer giving the payoff that used to follow a behavior. In its place, the team built assent into every step. Assent is the learner's ongoing "yes," shown through words or actions. Harrington lists the key changes to the PFA and SBT methods in his own words.

all physical prompting being removed, an increase in role play and demonstration... an increase in choice availability at all times and the opportunity to end the practice session or terminate the session. From the talk — Matt Harrington

He stresses that this research shows the field is still changing. A clinician who stopped reading new studies a few years ago would have missed it. He sees it as a big push in the right direction for how behavior treatment is done.

The three paths open at every moment#

The heart of the model is a set of three choices that never go away. The learner can take part in treatment. The learner can hang out in a calm space with their favorite things. Or the learner can leave the clinic for the day. In some cases the work was done at home instead. Harrington describes it simply.

Essentially with the enhanced choice model, you had one person and they had the option to go to participate in the intervention, hang out and just get reinforcements for free or leave the clinic. From the talk — Matt Harrington

The hang-out area works like noncontingent reinforcement, or NCR. That means the learner gets good things for free, with no work required. Researchers call this kind of setup a concurrent chains arrangement. In plain words, the learner has several paths side by side and picks one. Harrington notes that this setup is common in research but rare in clinics. The enhanced choice model is one of the clearest examples of it working in real treatment. The learner does not have to earn the right to leave. The door is open the whole time, and everyone in the room knows it.

What changed from standard skill-based treatment#

The enhanced choice model kept the parts of SBT that work. It still uses shaping, which means rewarding small steps toward a goal. It still uses chaining and fading, which link small skills together in order and slowly remove extra help. It still relies on synthesized reinforcement, which bundles all the things a behavior gets the learner into one rich payoff. What it changed was how the learner experiences the session.

First, all physical prompting was removed. Nobody guided the learner's hands or body. Second, there was a lot more role play and demonstration before hard moments. Staff would say something like, this part might be upsetting, but we will work through it together. Then they would check how the learner felt. These are safety signals. They tell the learner what is coming so it is not a shock. Third, choice was everywhere. Learners picked where to work, what to work on, and how to do it. Even small things counted, like a pen, a marker, or a highlighter. Harrington sums up the blend this way.

you had the promoting of choice and skill acquisition and assent based of the trauma-informed care model married to the shaping, the fading, and the reliance on synthesized reinforcement of the pfa and sbt model. From the talk — Matt Harrington

He argues the result is better than either model on its own.

Why a clear exit lowers challenging behavior#

Harrington admits his first guess about the model was wrong. He assumed learners would leave the clinic all the time. He thought they would just sit in the hang-out zone and skip the work. That is not what happened.

Really amazingly, there wasn't much hanging out in NCR, and there was almost none, there was almost no behavior of leaving the clinic. From the talk — Matt Harrington

His point is that offering a way out does not mean the learner will always take it. Many learners in the study moved all the way through SBT with no challenging behavior at all. Harrington links this to the "clear out" they always had. There was no judgment from the staff or the researchers. The message was always the same. Do you want to hang out with us and work, or not? It is up to you.

This matters because these were children with a long history of severe behavior under other treatment models. When a learner knows they can stop, they do not need to fight to stop. Problem behavior often works as a way to escape. If escape is free and safe, that behavior has less to do. The enhanced choice model removes the need for the fight before it starts.

Keeping the good and bad even across choices#

A choice only counts if each option is truly open. Harrington uses a simple picture of two bubbles. One bubble holds the bad parts of a path. The other holds the good parts. If the work path has a lot of bad and little good, the learner will avoid it. If the hang-out path has little bad and lots of good, the learner will pick it every time.

So in the enhanced choice model, it's all about evening out the amounts of bad and good across conditions. And if possible, aligning what you're learning with learner values. From the talk — Matt Harrington

In another talk, he explains that every path in the model led to the learner's functional reinforcers. Those are the specific payoffs that keep a behavior going. Working led to them. Taking a break led to them. Leaving led to them. He uses a "degrees of freedom" idea to describe this. Three equal options give the learner real room to choose.

He also shares a mistake he made for years. He set up what he thought were fair choices. But the "yes" path gave the learner lots of one-on-one attention in a playroom. The "no" path did not. So the options were not equal, even though they looked like a choice.

What happened when kids were allowed to leave#

The data on leaving is one of the most talked-about parts of the model. People expect the exit to be used a lot. In practice, it was used very little. Harrington retells what he learned from the study team.

None of the learners left except for one kid three times in the middle of like the 60-day. And the reason that kid left... was because he was getting sick. From the talk — Matt Harrington

That child left for three days in a row. On the fourth day, his mother called to say he was very sick. Nobody had seen any signs of illness. But he was choosing to leave, and by leaving he avoided dangerous behavior. Harrington uses this story to explain what flexibility means in trauma-informed care. It means changing goals based on what is possible for the client that day. It does not mean pushing through a plan no matter what.

The story also shows why an exit can be good data. A learner who suddenly starts leaving may be telling you something you cannot see. In this case, the exit protected a sick child and kept everyone safe.

Opting out as a source of information#

Dr. Holly Gover tells how her team found the value of opting out almost by accident. She was running a feeding study. A boy wanted out of the room, and she stood in front of the door. He was angry, and she knew that was not how the study should go. So they shut the session down. At the next research meeting, the advice was simple. If he wants to leave, let him leave.

It was actually like the first time we started letting kids opt out. From the talk — Dr. Holly Gover

The team built a "chill space" in the room with a beanbag, books, and blocks. It did not hold his very favorite toys. But anytime he did not want to do something, he could go there. He used it right away without getting upset. Gover says it eased so much tension that it became part of the process. This happened at the same time her group was adding enhanced choice features for kids with severe behavior.

When you let kids opt out of the treatment, it actually gives you so much data on what's going on in the treatment. From the talk — Dr. Holly Gover

Each opt-out is a signal. It shows when a step is too hard or a session is too long.

Building choice into every session#

Choice does not have to mean only the big exit. Penny Holloway describes using the model in small ways all day long. She and her colleague put it into everything they do.

Ellie and I put the enhanced choice model in everything we do actually we really want the clients to have input in their programming we always want to ask them what is the hardest EO you want to contact today From the talk — Penny Holloway

An EO, or establishing operation, is a condition that makes something matter more right now. Here it means a hard demand that makes the learner want to escape. Holloway asks clients which hard thing they are ready to face. She gives them a list of tasks for the day. They pick which one goes first, which goes last, and which they really do not want to do.

She also welcomes a client saying "I don't want to do that task." To her, that is useful. It tells her that one is really hard for this person. This lines up with Gover's point about opt-outs as data. When learners can say no without losing anything, they tell you where the hard spots are. The treatment team can then adjust targets instead of guessing.

Reinforcing earlier in the chain#

The model also changes when reinforcement shows up. In standard plans, a learner might only get a break after asking the right way. In the enhanced choice model, staff also respond to early warning signs. These are called precursors. A precursor is a smaller behavior that tends to come before a bigger, dangerous one. Harrington explains the idea.

This is common in the enhanced choice model. It's a great way to try and suppress severe behavior by reinforcing a behavior earlier in the response class. From the talk — Matt Harrington

A response class is a group of behaviors that all do the same job for the learner. If a frown, a groan, and a hit all get a break, they are in the same class. By honoring the frown, staff make the hit less needed. Harrington links this to how PFA and SBT "move the window of reinforcement." The learner does not have to climb all the way to a crisis to be heard.

He also frames the enhanced choice model as a step beyond basic NCR. NCR gives good things on a schedule. The enhanced choice model gives them freely in the hang-out zone but still teaches new skills on the work path.

Using the enhanced choice model in schools#

Can this work in a public school? Harrington says yes, but it looks very different. In schools, teams often lean on universal protocols, meaning schoolwide strategies applied to every student rather than one learner, which look more like NCR. He has done it in schools, but it takes a lot of buy-in and careful steps.

Nicky Schneider used the research to win support at her school. She pitched the enhanced choice model to her director using a study with students who have social, emotional, and behavioral needs.

Is the ability to choose and to opt out of instruction, does that empower students to opt in more often? And what Dr. Rajaraman and colleagues found was it does. From the talk — Nicky Schneider

Schneider says the key is trust. If you honor assent and build a real bond, a student may feel ready to learn with you instead of for you. She also notes that much school pushback comes from "we always did it that way." That is not a reason to keep doing it.

Shari Malta raises the model in a school talk too. She finds choice very helpful with students who show a demand-avoidant profile. She notes it will never look perfect. It may work some of the time and not others. Still, she calls it a good option to start adding to practice.

Choice, autonomy, and demand avoidance#

Some speakers connect the model to learners who push back hard against demands. B. Kuerine Gray works with people who show PDA responses. PDA stands for pathological demand avoidance, a profile where demands can feel like a loss of control. Gray does not call for brand new interventions. Instead, the goal is to present the same interventions with autonomy first.

if you're familiar with that, like enhanced choice model, uh, where like, oh, do you want to engage or do you want to opt out? There are so many times I've worked with individuals who are presenting with PDA responses. And when they're given the choice, they continue... because it was their choice. From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray

Brian Middleton tells a story about a learner he wishes he had served differently. The boy was about 12 or 13. He showed high rates of aggression and running away, tied to demands and being told no. They were making real progress on values. But the case moved outside Middleton's scope, and he had to discharge. Soon after, he learned about the enhanced choice model and wished he had known it sooner.

What we've seen without fail from what I've read of the literature is that these learners will choose to do hard things because they have a choice. From the talk — Brian Middleton

Middleton ties this to curiosity. He says learners can only be curious when they feel safe.

Two ways clinicians read why it works#

All the speakers agree on the outcome. Learners given a real choice tend to stay and work. Where they differ is on why.

Harrington reads it mainly through reinforcement. In his view, the model works because every path leads to the same functional reinforcers.

So in the enhanced choice model, it's all about evening out the amounts of bad and good across conditions. And if possible, aligning what you're learning with learner values. From the talk — Matt Harrington

He says all things have to be equal across options. He adds that the work path was likely even richer because learners were gaining skills they valued. So they chose to do extra work to get there. His advice follows from this view. Audit your options. Make sure the "yes" path does not hide extra perks that the "no" path lacks.

Gray reads it differently. Gray pushes back on the idea that learners keep going just because they "yearn to earn."

There are so many times I've worked with individuals who are presenting with PDA responses. And when they're given the choice, they continue... because it was their choice. From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray

The point is that they keep going because it was their own choice. Autonomy itself is the active ingredient, not only the payoff. Middleton sits close to Gray. He stresses humanity, patience, and waiting without pressure. "I'm here when you're ready" is the key move in his telling.

These views lead to different first steps. A reinforcement reading has you balance the payoffs. An autonomy reading has you change how you offer the choice and how you wait. Many teams will do both.

The practical hurdles of letting clients leave#

The open exit is the part that gets the most pushback. Harrington says it is what draws the most press in enhanced choice model talks. The worry usually sounds like this. What happens if insurance learns we let the child leave? Can we still bill for that time?

He calls these valid concerns. He has had them himself when promoting the model inside his own company. He does not claim to have the answers on billing for clinic-based therapists. He also names staff expectations as part of the challenge. Still, he points out that the basic setup is simple. You need a work area, a hang-out area, and a clear way to end the session.

He encourages clinicians not to fixate on the exit alone. The other pieces did a lot of the work. Removing physical prompts helped. Using safety signals helped. Offering choice at every turn helped. Together, these made leaving rare. A team that cannot offer a full exit can still build in the rest. Harrington walks through these setup choices in Analyzing Assent and Taking Data.

What the research says#

The model was first described in a study of children with dangerous problem behavior. The team wanted to treat that behavior without any physical management. They added an enhanced choice model to skill-based treatment. Three children took part in an outpatient clinic and two in a special public school. Children could join treatment, hang out with free access to preferred items, or leave. They overwhelmingly chose treatment. Problem behavior was eliminated, and new skills held up even during long, hard stretches without reinforcement (Rajaraman et al., 2022). The authors also report that no child's behavior escalated to dangerous levels in the clinic study.

A later study tested the same approach in a public day school for students with emotional and behavioral disorders. Three children took part. Their asking skills, waiting skills, and cooperation went up, and early warning behaviors went down. Severe behavior was rare. Students spent most of their time choosing the treatment over a break area or regular class (Staubitz et al., 2022). The authors say this shows promise for teaching safer skills in schools.

FAQ#

Do kids just leave or hang out all day under the enhanced choice model?

Usually not. In the original study, children chose treatment most of the time. Speakers report that leaving was rare once choice, safety signals, and fair payoffs were in place.

Is the enhanced choice model the same as skill-based treatment?

It is built on skill-based treatment. It keeps shaping and synthesized reinforcement. It adds trauma-informed pieces like no physical prompting, more choice, and an open exit.

Can the enhanced choice model work in a school?

Yes, with buy-in and planning. A school-based study found students mostly chose treatment. Practitioners say school versions often look more like simpler, NCR-style universal protocols.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch 12 days of PFA & SBT with Matt Harrington and earn 3 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert
Free learning pathStep 1 of 3 in Master PFA and SBTSee the whole path →