Synthesized Reinforcement: When One Reward Is Not Enough

Synthesized reinforcement gives several reinforcers at once, like a break, toys, and attention. See what experts and research say about using it in ABA.

Key takeaway

Synthesized reinforcement means giving several reinforcers together, at the same time, after one behavior. A child might get a break, their toys, and an adult's attention all at once.

12 days of PFA & SBT
Watch the full CEU recording

12 days of PFA & SBT

Matt Harrington · 3 CEU · 156 min
Watch on openceu.com →
Free learning pathStep 1 of 3 in Master PFA and SBTSee the whole path →

Experts who cover this

2 recordings on openceu cover synthesized reinforcement.

  • Featured talk3 Learning CEUs

    12 days of PFA & SBT

    Matt HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub

    Day 2's key finding (Ghaemmaghami 2015): challenging behavior only fully reduced when the FCR led to the full synthesized reinforcer (escape+tangible+attention…

  • 2.5 Learning CEUs

    Solving Clinical Challenges with Research

    Matthew HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub

    Harrington raises synthesized or multiply-controlled functions as a possible confound when a school-based FA doesn't cleanly differentiate single functions…

Synthesized reinforcement means giving several reinforcers together, at the same time, after one behavior. A child might get a break, their toys, and an adult's attention all at once. A reinforcer is anything that comes after a behavior and makes that behavior more likely to happen again.

Most behavior plans pick one reason for a behavior and treat that one reason. Synthesized reinforcement starts from a different idea. Some behavior happens because the person wants a whole package of things together. Experts in schools, clinics, and research labs have looked hard at when that package matters. They also look at when it does not.

What makes a reinforcer "synthesized"#

A regular plan often looks at one consequence at a time. Clinicians call each of these a "function," which just means the reason a behavior keeps happening. Common functions are escape (getting out of a task), tangibles (getting an item), and attention.

A synthesized reinforcer combines these into one moment. The child does not get a break, then later a toy, then later some praise. They get all three together. Practitioners call the rule that links the behavior to this package a synthesized contingency. A contingency is simply an "if this, then that" rule.

Nicky Schneider, who works in public schools, puts it in plain terms. She stresses that you cannot point to a single object and call it the reward.

In synthesized reinforcement, if you don't know about practical functional assessment, skill-based treatment... it's not something you can just hold in your hand. It might be a whole bunch of things together that really will motivate the individual and change the behavior.

From the talk — Nicky Schneider

Schneider also notes this can work in both directions. The package can help increase a behavior or decrease one.

Why all three parts mattered for Dan#

Matt Harrington walks through a 2015 article from Behavioral Interventions. He describes it as coming one year after Hanley's key 2014 paper. The study compared a synthesized analysis to a single-function analysis. It then compared treatment that gave one reinforcer to treatment that gave the full package.

The case was a client named Dan. During treatment, Dan learned an FCR. An FCR, or functional communication response, is a request the person is taught to use instead of problem behavior. At first, Dan's request only earned escape. His behavior dropped some, but it bounced around. Next, the request earned escape plus a tangible item. Behavior dropped more. Last, the request earned escape, tangibles, and attention together. Behavior mostly disappeared.

Harrington sums up the main finding this way.

the function was only identified in the synthesized contingency and the challenging behavior was only fully reduced when the FCR led to a synthesized reinforcer.

From the talk — Matt Harrington

He then draws the lesson for Dan in particular.

that tells us that for Dan the escape tangible and attention that synthesized reinforcer all happening at the same time was really necessary to reduce that challenging behavior.

From the talk — Matt Harrington

Harrington is careful to say "at least in his case." The point is that one part alone was not enough for this client.

Going straight from assessment to treatment#

Harrington pulls a second, practical lesson from the Dan study. It is about saving time. Once a synthesized function shows up in an assessment, a clinician might feel they must test each part alone. That step is called a component analysis. It means breaking the package apart to see which pieces matter.

Harrington argues this step is often not needed. He says the study lets clinicians "breathe a little easier." They can be more confident moving right from an IISCA into treatment. An IISCA is an interview-informed synthesized contingency analysis. In plain words, it is an assessment that tests the full package of reinforcers a caregiver describes.

He also frames synthesized reinforcers as sometimes the only option that works. In the talk, he says the finding gives clinicians a lot of confidence to program with synthesized reinforcers. In some cases, he says, they seem to be the only thing that will get the behavior to stop.

Taking apart a working package can cost weeks of extra sessions. For Harrington, the Dan data suggest that cost is often not worth it. The package is the treatment.

How the synthesized reinforcer works inside a short analysis#

Dr. Joshua Jessel focuses on how a synthesized reinforcer behaves during an assessment itself. He describes a single-session version of the ISCA. In it, the reinforcer is given and then taken away many times in one session.

Jessel splits the session into two kinds of time. When the reinforcer is absent, that works like a test condition. This is a period meant to bring out problem behavior. When the reinforcer is present, that works like a control condition. This is a calm period where problem behavior should not happen.

He uses a child named Zeke as an example. Zeke had no problem behavior during any of the times he had his reinforcers.

So when he had his synthesized reinforcement he was happy, relaxed, engaged at this time.

From the talk — Dr. Joshua Jessel

Jessel then describes a newer "performance-based" version. It still gives the full package after any problem behavior.

Much like any other ISCA, the synthesized reinforcer is provided following instances of any problem behavior.

From the talk — Dr. Joshua Jessel

The twist is timing. If the child is not calm for at least 30 seconds while they have the reinforcer, that time keeps getting longer. The analysis ends after five presentations of the hard situation. Jessel says the goal is to avoid starting a hard moment when the child is already upset.

Using synthesized reinforcement in schools#

Nicky Schneider raises a problem that clinic settings may not face. In a school, parts of the package are often not available. A student may want more adult attention than staff can give. A student may want to play video games all day. Schneider notes there are limits, and schools have rules.

She will not build food rewards into school plans. It is usually not snack time or lunchtime. If a student's answers point to food, she asks more questions about meals instead. She checks whether the student is getting enough to eat.

Schneider has also found that students often tell her what they think she wants to hear. That makes interviews less reliable. To find the real package, she sometimes works with a student outside the classroom first.

I do find that sometimes it's easier to do it in a pullout environment to test it and to find that turnoff switch.

From the talk — Nicky Schneider

The "turnoff switch" is the mix of things that leads to a happy, relaxed, and engaged student. Schneider tries to get students back into class as soon as she can. She then brings her findings to the teacher. She asks which parts of the package the teacher is comfortable with and which parts are not workable.

Spotting a synthesized contingency when a plan stalls#

In a separate talk, Matthew Harrington shows how this concept helps when a school plan is failing. His example is a student with frequent, worsening aggression. Escape extinction is already in place. Escape extinction means the student no longer gets out of a task by acting out.

If behavior keeps getting worse, Harrington says there are two options. Either staff are not using the plan with fidelity, meaning not doing it the same way every time. Or the team has the wrong function.

If the behavior is attention maintained or a synthesized contingency, escape extinction isn't going to do anything.

From the talk — Matthew Harrington

He then reviews a latency-based functional analysis from the research. In that study, no behavior happened during play. Behavior was frequent in the attention, tangible, and escape conditions. The test conditions stood apart from play, but not from one another. Harrington's takeaway is that a school assessment may not show a clean escape-only result. Teams should expect some fuzziness in the data. He covers this full problem-solving process in Solving Clinical Challenges with Research.

Where experts disagree#

The speakers agree that synthesized reinforcers can be powerful. They differ on how much to take the package apart.

Matt Harrington leans toward keeping the package whole. Based on the Dan study, he says clinicians can go right from the IISCA into treatment. He sees no need to do a reverse component analysis on the synthesized function first.

Nicky Schneider takes a more cautious line for schools. Her reason is about fit, not doubt. After she finds the full package, she sometimes needs a contingency analysis. That means testing certain parts alone to see if they still keep a student happy, relaxed, and engaged without everything. In her setting, a teacher may say no to some parts. So trimming the package is sometimes a must.

There is also a naming debate. Looking at the latency-based analysis, Matthew Harrington says the student showed "multi-controlled behavior slash potentially, you could argue synthesized." He openly declines to settle it in that talk. Multiply controlled means several reasons each work on their own. Synthesized means the reasons work best together. The research below shows why that line matters.

What the research says#

Several studies test when the synthesized package truly matters. Their results do not all point the same way.

Fisher and colleagues compared an IISCA to a standard functional analysis that tested each reinforcer alone (Fisher et al., 2016). Four of five participants showed behavior that was sensitive to single reinforcers. None showed the response pattern the IISCA assumes.

A later study added a standardized synthesized analysis to the comparison (Greer et al., 2020). The standard analysis identified what kept problem behavior going for 11 of 12 people. Errors looked similar for both synthesized versions. That raised questions about the interview and observation steps that inform the IISCA.

On the treatment side, one study taught an "omnibus mand" (Ward et al., 2021). A mand is a request. This one, "My way, please," earned all the reinforcers at once. Problem behavior stopped right away for all three children. They later learned separate requests for each reinforcer too.

A lab study with rats added a warning about durability (Smith et al., 2024). Synthesized reinforcement for an alternative behavior cut target behavior faster and more fully. But when reinforcement stopped, the old behavior came back more. This return is called resurgence.

FAQ#

What is the difference between synthesized and isolated reinforcement?

Isolated reinforcement gives one reinforcer, like only a break, after a behavior. Synthesized reinforcement gives several together, like a break, toys, and attention at once. In the Dan case, behavior only fully dropped when his request earned all three together.

Do you have to test each part of a synthesized reinforcer before treatment?

Not always. Matt Harrington argues clinicians can often move straight from the assessment into treatment. Nicky Schneider notes that schools may need to test parts alone, since a teacher may not allow every piece of the package.

Can synthesized reinforcement make problem behavior come back later?

It can in some cases. A 2024 lab study found synthesized reinforcement reduced target behavior faster. But when reinforcement stopped, the old behavior returned more than after isolated reinforcement. Planning for breaks in treatment is worth the effort.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch 12 days of PFA & SBT with Matt Harrington and earn 3 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert
Free learning pathStep 1 of 3 in Master PFA and SBTSee the whole path →