Rule-Governed Behavior: When Rules Help and When They Hurt

Rule-governed behavior is acting on a stated rule, not direct experience. See how rules help, when they go rigid, and how BCBAs build flexibility.

Key takeaway

Rule-governed behavior is doing something because of a spoken or written rule, not because you directly felt its result. A child cleans up because a parent said a treat is coming.

Leadership Alignment in Supervision
Watch the full CEU recording

Leadership Alignment in Supervision

Allyson Mullins · 1 CEU · 60 min
Watch on openceu.com →

Free learning path on this topic

Supervision, Done Right

Four supervision CEUs that build on each other. What reflective supervision is, how to build a supervision system, how to assess supervisee competence instead of counting hours, and how supervision affects provider outcomes. Each course is free and issues its own certificate.

Start the path →4 courses · 4 supervision CEUs · Watch at your own pace

Experts who cover this

6 recordings on openceu cover rule-governed behavior.

Rule-governed behavior is doing something because of a spoken or written rule, not because you directly felt its result. A child cleans up because a parent said a treat is coming. A supervisor studies for hours because "good leaders have all the answers." In both cases, the rule is driving the action, not the outcome itself.

This matters because rules are everywhere in applied behavior analysis (ABA). We teach clients to follow instructions. We hand staff written protocols. We also carry private rules about how we should act. Rules save time and prevent mistakes. But a rule can hang around long after it stops working. Four speakers show both sides here. They cover teams at work, supervisors, young learners, and teens and adults with ADHD.

What rule-governed behavior means#

B. F. Skinner introduced the idea of rule-governed behavior decades ago. The core contrast is simple. Some behavior is shaped by direct contingencies. That means what actually happens right after you act. Other behavior is shaped by words that describe what will happen. Those words are the rule.

Think about a hot stove. You can touch it once and learn the hard way. Or someone can tell you it is hot, and you never touch it at all. The second path is rule-governed. It lets people learn from outcomes they have never felt.

Jason Stauffer, who applies behavior science to groups at work, starts from a broad view of behavior. He treats thoughts, emotions, and ideas as behavior too. In large groups, he says, you have to account for them. The barriers groups face are "often not just about direct contingencies." They are often about rules, narratives, and histories. These are built with language and kept alive by the setting people are in.

Rule-governed behavior is the broad umbrella. Pliance is one type inside it, where a person follows a rule mainly because someone else will approve. So all pliance is rule-governed, but not all rule-governed behavior is pliance. This page covers the full umbrella.

Why rules are useful shortcuts#

Rules are not the enemy. Stauffer and Allyson Mullins both say so plainly before they get to the problems.

Stauffer calls rule following a shortcut. You do not have to learn every lesson by trial and error. If you follow a rule, you might skip some unpleasant side effects or consequences entirely. He adds a twist that matters later. Following a rule can feel rewarding in itself. It can bring "similar rewards as the actual consequences themselves." Doing the right thing can become its own payoff.

Mullins, speaking on leadership alignment in supervision, makes the same point about workplace rules. She shares a list of leadership rules her audience offered. They include "clear is kind," taking responsibility for errors, checking capacity, and modeling the behavior you want to see. Another is "listen to understand." She asks her audience to acknowledge that these rules are actually helpful. In her words, they "can help or organize our behavior efficiently and effectively."

So the starting point is balance. Rules let us act well in places we have never been. They let a new staff member do the right thing on day one. The trouble starts when a rule stops matching the world around us, and we keep following it anyway.

When rules get in the way#

Stauffer names three kinds of rules that cause trouble. The first kind is followed for social reasons, not because it works.

"Rules can also get in the way. Rules that we follow not because they're efficient or effective, but because someone else cares that we follow it."From the talk — Jason Stauffer

The second kind he calls zombie rules. These rules once were helpful but no longer are. The setting changed, but the rule kept walking. Picture a clinic rule written for an old billing system that nobody uses now. Staff still follow it, and nobody remembers why.

The third kind is rules that never worked in the first place. We just told ourselves they did. These can be the hardest to spot. Nothing in daily life pushes back on them, because people rarely test them against real results.

For a team leader, this list works as a quick audit. Pick a rule your team follows. Ask who it serves, whether it still fits, and whether it ever got the results it promised.

Rewarded for following, not for results#

Stauffer then points to the hidden cost. Because following a rule can feel good on its own, people can lose track of what the rule actually produces.

"We can become more driven by doing what's right rather than what works. Just rule following becomes reinforced, not actually the consequences it's producing."From the talk — Jason Stauffer

Reinforced means the behavior is strengthened, so it happens more often. Here, the thing being strengthened is the act of obeying. The real-world result drops out of the picture.

He links this to experiential avoidance. That is acting to escape feelings or threats, even ones that have not happened yet. Humans can imagine future pain and build elaborate "what-if" scenarios. Then they act to escape things that never occurred. In a group, these verbal patterns can block a team from working well together. This can happen even when the direct payoffs clearly favor cooperation. In Stauffer's view, that is why simply rearranging rewards often fails. The rules and stories in people's heads keep pulling behavior somewhere else.

Stories we tell ourselves work like rules#

Stauffer stretches the idea from single rules to whole stories. Humans love to tell stories to make sense of the world. Those stories then guide what we do.

His main example is "homo economicus." This is the story that people are rational actors who always chase their own self-interest. He ties it to Garrett Hardin's well-known "tragedy of the commons." The problem, he says, is that the story can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. If you tell yourself people are "kind of crappy," you will behave as if they are. Following that story leaves two options. You can force people to do things, or you can exploit their self-interest.

"Narratives can be seen as functioning as like verbal SDs. The stories we tell ourselves are like verbal SDs."From the talk — Jason Stauffer

An SD, or discriminative stimulus, is a cue that signals a behavior will pay off right now. Stauffer says our stories do the same job. They signal which sources of reinforcement are available in our dealings with other people, and when. His practical advice is to start today. Ask what stories you tell about others. Then ask how changing those stories might change what you do. He calls changing the narrative "a really potent piece" of building groups where helping each other can thrive.

Rigid rules in supervision#

Allyson Mullins brings rule-governed behavior into the supervision relationship. She frames supervisor avoidance as a time-scale problem. A supervisor may know the right action is to address an issue with a supervisee. But the quick relief of putting it off is more noticeable than the later benefit. That avoidance gets negatively reinforced. In plain terms, it keeps happening because it removes discomfort right away.

Negative reinforcement is one driver of avoidance. Mullins names rule-governed behavior as another.

"you might have some rigid leadership roles that can really narrow responding."From the talk — Allyson Mullins

She uses her own rule as the example: "a competent leader should have all the answers." That rule narrowed her behavior. She had to do all the research first. She had to have all her ducks in a row, because she did not want to say or do the wrong thing. The rule restricted what she was willing to try, and it gave her one more reason to wait.

What changed things for her was a model. She had a supervisor who could say "this is what I know" and admit it might not be everything. Seeing that more workable pattern showed her a different rule was possible. A rule learned from words can often be loosened by watching someone live a better one.

How rigid rules strengthen misalignment#

Mullins makes a second, sharper point. A rule that helped in the past can pull you away from your values in the present.

"If they're rigid, they... They can strengthen misalignment."From the talk — Allyson Mullins

Misalignment, in her talk, means a gap between what a leader values and what that leader actually does. Her explanation is careful. Suppose you act in line with a rule because it worked before. But in your current setting, it no longer helps. Then you may do something that does not fit what you truly value as a leader. The rule wins, and your values lose.

This is the same pattern Stauffer calls zombie rules, seen from inside one supervisor. The rule is not wrong in every case. It is wrong for this moment, and the person following it may not notice. Her audience's own list shows a healthier version. One rule they offered was that leaders "don't always have the answers and they will get back to you." That rule leaves room to respond to the real situation in front of you.

For supervisors, the takeaway is practical. Write down the rules you follow about being a good leader. Then ask whether each one still fits your current role, team, and goals.

Teaching learners to follow rules flexibly#

Dr. Tom Szabo teaches acceptance and commitment training (ACT). ACT is an approach that builds flexible, values-based action. He looks at rules from the client side and ties them to a task list item about using instructions and rules.

He notes that a large part of ABA teaches kids to respond well to instructions and rules. That is valuable work. But it raises a harder question. What about kids who get overly attached to rules? Some rules change from one setting to the next. A learner may need to respond differently at home, at school, and on the playground. New and unfamiliar situations may also demand a different response than the old rule calls for.

"we talk about rule-constricted behavior as a target of acts so that behavior can come under the control of the relevant rules in their context."From the talk — Dr. Tom Szabo

The goal is not to stop following rules. It is to follow the right rule in the right place. Szabo also connects this to multiple exemplar training, a standard ABA method that teaches with many varied examples. Inside an ACT frame, the same method can help learners tell apart events that look alike but call for different responses. For a clinician, this turns "too rigid" from a vague complaint into a teachable skill.

Helpful rules as a coping tool#

Not every rule is a problem to loosen. Ryan Baker-Barrett, who works with teens and adults with ADHD, shows how a rule can be built on purpose to help. His focus is self-compassion. He treats self-compassion and self-criticism as operant behaviors. That means they are learned and shaped by the environment, like any other behavior.

He points out that people with ADHD often get more negative social feedback. That history can set up a coercive cycle. Harsh feedback leads to low confidence and poor follow-through, which brings more harsh feedback. Shame and avoidance can follow, along with escape-maintained problem behavior. That means acting out to avoid or escape the bad feeling.

"a mediating verbal rule governed behavior whereby Individuals learn to respond adaptively to setbacks rather than engaging in avoidance."From the talk — Ryan Baker-Barrett

A mediating rule sits between a setback and the next action. Instead of "I always mess up, so why try," a client learns a kinder statement that keeps them moving. In his framing, self-compassion also lowers how painful failure feels. That makes it easier to try again rather than escape. This fits the other speakers well. A rule is a tool. The question is always whether it serves the person in the setting they are in now. To go deeper, see Prosocial in the Workplace and Self-Compassion is an Imperative in Teen and Adult ADHD Services.

What the research says#

Published studies back up and sharpen the points above. Most of them look at what makes a rule take hold, and what makes it stick too hard.

A study titled "I'll do it when the snow melts" gave four similar rules to eight preschool children. Rules that named only the response did not reliably control behavior. Rules with an immediate deadline worked, even when the reward came a week later. Rules with no deadline and a delayed reward had little control. The authors concluded that a deadline matters more than the delay to the reward. They also argued this challenges the common idea that self-control problems come from an inability to wait.

A related study compared "compliant" and "noncompliant" preschool boys. With immediate rewards, rules worked about equally for both groups. As rewards became more delayed, the noncompliant boys' performance dropped. In a second experiment, rules that stated a reward produced high compliance in both groups. This held even after a 15 to 20 minute wait. The authors suggest rules can change how later events function, not just prompt an action in the moment.

A study with college students looked at sensitivity. That means how fast behavior changes when the real payoff changes. Fully instructed responding showed little variety and did not adjust to a new schedule. When a later instruction said varied responding would work best, five of six people became more varied. This mirrors Stauffer's zombie rules in a lab, and Szabo's push for flexibility.

Rules also shape the work of behavior analysts themselves:

Belisle, J. (2020). Model Dependent Realism and the Rule-Governed Behavior of Behavior Analysts: Applications to Derived Relational Responding. Perspectives on Behavior Science, 43(2), 321-342. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40614-020-00247-x

Belisle argues that our models of behavior are best seen as rules we pick to solve applied problems. They are not perfect pictures of nature. He suggests judging a model by how well it works in a given context. That is the same test Mullins applies to leadership rules.

Two commentaries widen the lens. One notes that rule-governed behavior may help explain why drug effects differ across people and situations. Another argues that paradigmatic behaviorism offers added tools for studying how words come to control motor behavior.

FAQ#

What is the difference between rule-governed and contingency-shaped behavior? Contingency-shaped behavior is learned from direct experience with what happens after you act. Rule-governed behavior is guided by a description of what will happen. You touch a hot stove and learn not to. Or someone tells you it is hot, and you never touch it. Most people mix both every day.

Is rule-governed behavior the same as pliance? No. Rule-governed behavior is the broad category. Pliance is one type, where the rule is followed mainly for social approval. Stauffer's example of rules followed "because someone else cares" fits pliance. His zombie rules can be any kind of rule that outlived its usefulness.

How do BCBAs address rigid rule following? The speakers here offer several routes. Mullins suggests noticing your own leadership rules and watching someone model a more workable one. Stauffer suggests examining the stories you tell about other people. Szabo uses ACT and multiple exemplar training to help learners match rules to the current setting. Baker-Barrett teaches kinder self-rules that help clients bounce back from setbacks.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch Leadership Alignment in Supervision with Allyson Mullins and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert

Keep going with a free learning path

Supervision, Done Right

Four supervision CEUs that build on each other. What reflective supervision is, how to build a supervision system, how to assess supervisee competence instead of counting hours, and how supervision affects provider outcomes. Each course is free and issues its own certificate.

Start the path →4 courses · 4 supervision CEUs · Watch at your own pace