Right to Effective Treatment in ABA: What It Means
The right to effective treatment means ABA clients deserve care that works. Learn its roots, its misuse, and why effectiveness must be collaborative.
Key takeaway
The right to effective treatment is the idea that every person receiving behavior services deserves treatment that truly works for them. It comes from a 1988 article by Van Houten and colleagues, and it still shapes ethics in behavior analysis today.
Alternatives to Extinction for Supporting Extreme Demand Avoidant Behavior
Free learning path on this topic
Ethics Essentials
Three free courses worth 5.5 CEUs, 4 of them ethics. Start with Matt Harrington's assent and data course, then ethical guardrails in behavior reduction, then cultural considerations in clinical practice. Each course issues its own certificate.
Experts who cover this
The recording behind this guide covers right to effective treatment.
- Featured talk2 CEUs (1 Learning, 1 Ethics)
Alternatives to Extinction for Supporting Extreme Demand Avoidant Behavior
Nicola Schneider, LBA-NJNRS Compassionate Behavior Services
Citing Bannerman et al. (1990), Schneider argues the right to habilitation and the right to choose are not in conflict, and that clinicians' ethical…
On this page · 9 sections▾
The right to effective treatment is the idea that every person receiving behavior services deserves treatment that truly works for them. It comes from a 1988 article by Van Houten and colleagues, and it still shapes ethics in behavior analysis today.
But "effective" is a slippery word. Who decides what works? Two clinicians, Dr. Shane Spiker and Nicola Schneider, help answer that question. Both argue that effective care is built with the client, not simply handed to them.
What the right to effective treatment means#
Dr. Shane Spiker calls the 1988 Van Houten article "a really great article" and "an important article." He sums up its core message in one plain line.
any person receiving services has a right to effective treatment.
From the talk — Dr. Shane Spiker
Spiker explains that the article breaks this right into six parts. He walks through several of them. The first is a therapeutic physical and social environment. That means a setting that supports healing and growth. The next is services whose overriding goal is personal welfare. In other words, the person's own well-being comes first. Spiker says he leans on that one "pretty heavily." Another part is treatment by a competent behavior analyst.
Spiker also says the intent behind the article is good. The value of effective treatment is good too. In his words, we do not want to spend resources on things that will not work for the person. We want treatment to work for the person. So the right itself is not the problem. The question is how the field has used it over the years.
Why "effective" is harder to define than it sounds#
Spiker says he agrees with the right "to an extent." His concern is about who gets to define what works. He argues the field has latched onto the idea that what clinicians think is effective should be the default choice.
He calls this a pervasive problem, meaning it shows up almost everywhere. According to Spiker, clinician ideas of "best" often come from three places. One is a Westernized version of the medical model. The medical model is a way of thinking that treats differences as problems to fix. Another is the clinician's own learning history, meaning their past experiences and training. A third is a narrow idea of what normal behavior looks like.
Spiker also raises a point about social validity. Social validity asks whether the people served find the goals and methods acceptable. He says the field talks about it a lot, and he thinks it matters. Yet he warns that social validity often reflects internalized Western culture. It can carry a neurotypical idea of what it means to have no problem behavior. Neurotypical means typical brain development, without autism or similar differences.
How the right can drift toward crisis management#
Spiker links this narrow view of "effective" to a specific risk. When clinicians decide alone what works, their own plans get put in place most often.
what we think is effective is what is most often put into place. That leads to overuse of... crisis management strategies.
From the talk — Dr. Shane Spiker
Crisis management strategies are steps used to handle dangerous behavior in the moment. Spiker is careful here. He says the problem is not necessarily punishment. The problem is a plan built around a single goal: the problem behavior must not happen. That goal sounds reasonable. But it can push a plan toward reacting to crises instead of preventing them.
Spiker suggests a different starting question. If a crisis is happening, what did someone do to lead to it? What could have been prevented? He says that question is what the field should really focus on. In this view, effective treatment looks at the conditions that set up a crisis. It does not just look at how to stop one once it starts.
Making effectiveness collaborative#
Spiker's main fix is a shift in thinking. He notes that the Van Houten article is 34 years old at the time of his talk. He says the field now needs a new way to read it.
the key paradigm shift... is that what we deem effective has to be combated. It has to be reconciled. It has to be collaborative with the people that we're serving.
From the talk — Dr. Shane Spiker
A paradigm shift is a big change in how people see a problem. Here, the change is about who holds the definition of success. Spiker says clinician views must be checked against what the people served think is effective. The two views have to be reconciled, meaning brought into agreement.
Spiker sounds hopeful about this. He says that as long as the field reframes the right this way, "I think we'll be okay." So he is not asking anyone to throw the right away. He is asking clinicians to share it. Effective treatment becomes something the client and the clinician define together. This keeps the welfare goal from the 1988 article at the center of care.
Effective treatment and the right to choose#
Nicola Schneider comes at the same idea from another angle. She points to a 1990 article by Bannerman and colleagues. She says people often know it by a playful nickname.
1990 this was written, Bannerman et al. It's a seminal article and people really know it as the right to eat. Too many donuts and take a nap.
From the talk — Nicola Schneider
Schneider says the main message of that article is simple. The right to habilitation and the right to choose are not in conflict. Habilitation means learning the skills a person needs for daily life. Schneider notes that we balance learning and choice every day in our own lives.
She also pushes back on a common worry she hears in classrooms. Some staff feel that trauma-informed care, meaning care that accounts for a person's past difficult experiences, just lets clients "do what they want." Schneider reads Bannerman's answer from 1990.
This does not mean that service providers should sit back and allow clients. to do their own thing because clients may make a number of bad choices that would hinder their habilitation.
From the talk — Nicola Schneider
Instead, Schneider says, providers should work harder at teaching. They should offer choices within the context of what is important and meaningful to the person.
Building learning environments that work#
Schneider shares a line she found especially meaningful. It was pulled out as a featured quote in an article in Behavior Analysis in Practice.
It is a behavior analyst ethical responsibility to promote effective learning environments rather than teach individuals with disabilities to tolerate an ineffective one.
From the talk — Nicola Schneider
She puts it in plain terms. If clients cannot learn the way we teach them, we have to teach the way they learn. That is part of the job. Clinicians must help shape the environment so it becomes the most effective and comfortable place for that person to learn.
Schneider also stresses the role of the treatment plan. She reminds staff that they should not make a new function-based decision in the moment. Function-based means based on why the behavior happens. Staff should follow the function-based procedures the behavior analyst has already laid out. The analysis and assessment guide the plan. This keeps effective treatment steady and planned, not improvised. Her talk applies these ideas to alternatives to escape extinction, which means removing all reinforcement for escape attempts. It focuses on people with extreme demand avoidance, an intense, anxiety-driven resistance to everyday demands.
How the two perspectives fit together#
Spiker and Schneider do not disagree on this topic. Their views line up well. Each one fills in a different side of the same right.
Spiker focuses on who defines "effective." He warns that clinician beliefs can quietly become the standard. When that happens, plans can lean on crisis management. His answer is to make effectiveness collaborative with the people served.
Schneider focuses on what clinicians owe the learner. She says respecting choice does not mean stepping back. Clients can make choices that hold back their own learning. So clinicians must work harder, teach within what is meaningful to the person, and fix the environment when it is not working.
Put together, the message is clear. The right to effective treatment is not a license to impose a plan. It is also not permission to do nothing. It asks clinicians to build treatment that works, with the client, inside a setting designed for how that person learns.
What the research says#
The right to effective treatment also appears in recent ethics writing. In a 2024 reply published in Behavior Analysis in Practice, Mary Jane Weiss addresses the right directly (Weiss, 2024).
Weiss, M. J. (2024). Ethics Dialogue: Spelling to Communicate – Reply by Mary Jane Weiss. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 18(3), 896-900. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40617-024-01024-x
Weiss responds to a case described by Quigley and colleagues (2024) in the same journal. The case involves a treatment recommendation for an adult with a developmental disability. The recommendation came up within a team of professionals from several fields. In her reply, Weiss stresses the right to effective treatment as a primary obligation of the treatment team.
Her review finds that the proposed intervention is unproven. It is also similar to an intervention known to be harmful. Weiss notes that many available resources support avoiding it. Her reply then highlights ways teams can make decisions in clinical settings.
This shows the right in action. It is not only about choosing what works. It also means steering away from methods that lack evidence or carry known risks.
FAQ#
Where does the right to effective treatment come from? It comes from a 1988 article on the right to effective treatment by Van Houten and colleagues. Dr. Shane Spiker explains that it says any person receiving services has a right to effective treatment. It breaks that right into six parts, including a goal of personal welfare.
Does the right to effective treatment conflict with client choice? No. Nicola Schneider cites Bannerman and colleagues (1990), who argued that the right to habilitation and the right to choose are not in conflict. Clinicians should teach and offer choices within what is meaningful to the person.
Who decides what counts as effective treatment? Dr. Shane Spiker argues it should not be the clinician alone. He says what we deem effective must be reconciled and made collaborative with the people we serve. Otherwise, plans can lean too heavily on crisis management.
Turn this topic into a CEU
You just studied this. Now get credit for it.
Watch Alternatives to Extinction for Supporting Extreme Demand Avoidant Behavior with Nicola Schneider, MA, BCBA, LBA-NJ and earn 2 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.
Keep going with a free learning path
Ethics Essentials
Three free courses worth 5.5 CEUs, 4 of them ethics. Start with Matt Harrington's assent and data course, then ethical guardrails in behavior reduction, then cultural considerations in clinical practice. Each course issues its own certificate.