Preference Assessment: How ABA Teams Find What Motivates
How ABA clinicians run preference assessments, from free operant and MSWO to feeding, staff, and sensory uses, with tips from 12 practicing experts.
Key takeaway
A preference assessment is a structured way to find out which items, activities, or experiences a person likes most. A clinician offers choices or watches free play, then ranks what the person picks or uses most.

5 Days of Manding Mastery
Free learning path on this topic
Verbal Behavior: Beyond WH-Questions
Dana Pettus's three-part series on building generative verbal behavior. Why WH-question programs stall, how to establish speaker-listener repertoires, and how to scaffold advanced verbal skills like recall and simple inference. Three hours, three CEUs.
Experts who cover this
11 recordings on openceu cover preference assessment.
- Featured talk2.5 Learning CEUs
5 Days of Manding Mastery
Matt HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
The presenter's practical workflow: start with a free-operant preference assessment (tallying engaged items every 5 minutes for an hour) to build a rough…
- 1 Supervision CEU
Delegating with Confidence: Training and Supervising RBTs to Support Assessments
Dr. Jessica OsosCopper Consulting Group
Preference assessments (paired choice, multiple stimulus) are given as a prototypical example of an RBT-appropriate activity billable under 97152, since the…
- 1 Ethics CEU
Article Club: A Child's Rights Approach to ABA
Pauli Catanese & Jasmine AbdelAchieve Behavior Partners
Illustrated via the Liam case: instead of imposing a hand-washing method, the BCBA ran a preference assessment across soap types and let the client's preferred…
- 1 Learning CEU
Article Club: Using Deposit Contracts and Reinforcement Thinning to Increase Physical Activity
Pauli Catanese & Morgan JohnsonAchieve Behavior Partners
Discussion extends preference assessment methodology playfully to identifying a cat's top reinforcer before using it to shape litter-box behavior, illustrating…
- 1 Supervision CEU
Dunder Mifflin’s Guide to Training and Onboarding: Lessons from The Office
Mellanie PageThe ABA Collective, LLC.
Page recommends assessing staff preferences early and often, using a tracked spreadsheet, to identify what reinforces individual team members beyond just…
- 1 PDU
Mastering Your Time: Preparing for Service Delivery
Ashley AndrewInnovative Behavioral Therapy
Andrew suggests doing informal, on-the-fly preference assessments when a learner's engagement drops, to identify new motivators beyond the current materials.
- 1 PDU
Mastering Your Time: Preparing for Service Delivery
Ashley AndrewInnovative Behavioral Therapy
Andrew recommends being ready to conduct an informal preference assessment when a learner becomes disengaged or satiated on previously preferred materials.
- 1 Supervision CEU
The Architecture of Supervision: Sequencing Competencies Across Specialties
Nicole ParksRooted Consultation, LLC
Parks notes that fieldwork students must learn to adapt standard preference assessment procedures, since a paired-stimulus preference assessment designed for…
- 1 Supervision CEU
Toward an Evidence-based Supervision Model: Training Students in Independent Fieldwork
Dr. Allison Bowhers-PeutinWillow Mentorship & Consulting, LLC
Before baseline, supervisors completed a preference assessment ranking items like food or gift cards, which were then delivered contingent on their supervisory…
- 1 Learning CEU
The Interdisciplinary Case Conference
Michelle VencesThe Mindful Learner LLC
Michelle references using a sensory preference assessment to determine whether self-injurious behavior is reinforced by sensory input, connecting an ABA…
- 1 Learning CEU
Rad N Bad: Parent Buy-In as a Clinical Variable — Caregiver Training, Generalization, and Least-Restrictive Service Design
Sean Yocum, LBA & Michael CarreroHickory Learning Group
Yocum grounds the argument for prioritizing engaged families in basic behavior-analytic principles, noting that identifying reinforcers through preference…
On this page · 18 sections▾
A preference assessment is a structured way to find out which items, activities, or experiences a person likes most. A clinician offers choices or watches free play, then ranks what the person picks or uses most.
This matters because reinforcement only works when the payoff is something the person truly wants. Guessing at rewards can waste whole sessions and stall progress. The clinicians below use preference assessments with children, adults, families, staff, and even a pet cat.
The main formats clinicians use#
There is more than one way to run a preference assessment. Matt Harrington lists the common options in his course on manding. A mand is simply a request, like asking for a toy or a snack. To teach requests, you first need to know what the learner wants to ask for.
Now for preference assessments, we can use things like the multiple stimulus without replacement, the paired stimulus preference assessment, the free operant preference assessment... Concurrent chains preference assessment.
From the talk — Matt Harrington
Here is what those names mean in plain words. In a multiple stimulus without replacement assessment, or MSWO, you lay out several items at once. The learner picks one, and that item stays out of the next round. In a paired stimulus assessment, or PSPA, you show two items at a time and note which one is chosen. In a free operant assessment, you let the learner roam freely and watch what they play with. A concurrent chains assessment gives the learner a choice between different arrangements or conditions.
Dr. Jessica Osos adds that some formats go by other names. She mentions paired choice and multiple stimulus versions as tasks a technician can run. Each format trades speed, detail, and comfort for the learner in a different way.
Starting with free operant observation#
Matt Harrington has a clear habit. He nearly always begins with a free operant assessment. That means he watches the learner move through the room with open access to items.
Personally, I like to start with a free operant preference assessment. Almost always.
From the talk — Matt Harrington
He says he cannot recall ever starting a case with a formal PSPA. The free operant view gives him two things at once. First, he sees what behaviors and challenges the team may face. Second, he learns what the client likes to do inside the clinic.
It also answers a practical question. Can this learner sit at a table for something like 150 trials of a PSPA? Or would a quicker method fit them better? Watching first helps him choose.
His method is simple. A staff member writes down the item the learner engages with most during each short block of a few minutes. They repeat this for about an hour. Harrington says you end up with about 20 data points. He admits it will not be perfect. It is not a second by second account. It is a rough, useful picture of what draws the learner in.
Confirming the top items with a quick MSWO#
The free operant data gives Matt Harrington a starting list. Next, he tightens it up. He takes the items that showed up most and runs them through a short MSWO.
I take the ones that occurred in the top four, top five, and I put them, if possible, into a multiple stimulus without replacement preference assessment.
From the talk — Matt Harrington
He describes this as a really quick MSWO done with his technician. The goal is a hierarchy. A hierarchy is a ranked list, from most liked to least liked. Once he has that ranked list, he moves on to mand training.
This two-step plan has a logic to it. The open observation casts a wide net with little pressure on the learner. The MSWO then sorts only the strongest few items. That keeps the formal part short. It also means the learner is not asked to choose among items they barely care about.
Harrington then notes a separate choice clinicians face. Some teams like constant, ongoing mand training that follows whatever the learner wants in the moment. He calls that great, since it uses the learner's current motivation. But he warns that taking precise data gets hard when anything could be a target.
Preference is not the same as reinforcement#
A ranked list tells you what someone likes best. It does not prove that item will make behavior grow. Matt Harrington makes this point with a snack example. He might pick Skittles over chips. But if he dislikes both, he will not work for either one.
He calls this getting "the best of the crappy stuff." In other words, your preference assessment can rank items that are all too weak to act as reinforcers. A reinforcer is a consequence that makes a behavior happen more often in the future.
So what should you do? Harrington offers a balanced view. If you run into a brick wall while teaching requests, take time to run a reinforcer assessment. That is a test of whether an item actually strengthens behavior when you deliver it.
But he also argues for clinical efficiency. In his view, you typically do not need a formal reinforcer assessment in a busy clinic setting. The preference data usually carries you far enough. You can save the deeper test for cases that stall. This is a practical rule of thumb, not a claim that reinforcer testing has no value.
When the real problem is motivation#
In a separate talk on solving clinical problems with research, Matthew Harrington shows when a preference assessment is the right tool. He uses the example of a learner who will not sit at the table for discrete trial training. Discrete trial training, or DTT, is a structured teaching format with short, repeated practice trials.
He asks whether the learner's refusal is about motivation or about a missing skill. Maybe the token board, a chart where earned tokens are later traded in for rewards, doesn't have backup rewards that are strong enough.
Maybe the token board doesn't have backup reinforcers that are strong enough.
From the talk — Matthew Harrington
If motivation is the issue, his answer is direct.
The intervention for motivation is going to be a preference assessment.
From the talk — Matthew Harrington
But if the learner lacks the skill of sitting or waiting for rewards, the fix is different. That calls for a shaping process instead. Shaping means rewarding small steps toward a goal behavior. Harrington warns that searching the research for "kid not sitting at the table" may lead you to the wrong answer. Naming the true cause first points you to the right tool.
Preference assessments in feeding treatment#
Dr. Holly Gover uses preference assessments at the very start of feeding treatment. She lays out the core steps. Her team interviews caregivers first. Then they run a preference assessment with both liked and disliked foods.
We're conducting a preference assessment with preferred and non-preferred foods to identify what you're using in treatment.
From the talk — Dr. Holly Gover
After that, they run an ISCA. That is a functional analysis built from the caregiver interview, used to learn why a behavior happens. From there, treatment relies on shaping and differential reinforcement. Differential reinforcement means rewarding the wanted behavior while not rewarding others. Gover says the children end up setting the pace, based on the steps that give them trouble.
One surprise in her work is how much kids enjoy the assessment itself.
Kids actually really end up liking the preference assessment because you're, like, would you like an M&M? And they're, like, yes.
From the talk — Dr. Holly Gover
She describes offering a carrot and hearing a firm "no." The child gets to be in control of the choice. Gover says this relaxed start helps with transitions. Her team also targets preferred foods, not only disliked ones. So the first sessions feel like a game, not a fight.
Letting the client lead the plan#
Pauli Catanese and Jasmine Abdel shared a case from a child's rights approach to ABA. Parents wanted their child to learn hand washing. It was an important routine in their family.
Rather than just marching him to the sink, the BCBA, the Board Certified Behavior Analyst who designed the treatment plan, asked a better question. What did the child dislike about washing hands? To find out, the team tested options.
And they actually did a preference assessment on different ways you can wash hands.
From the talk — Pauli Catanese & Jasmine Abdel
They offered soap with water, a dry soap bar, liquid soap, wet wipes, foam soap, dry towels, and hand sanitizer. After following his lead, they found he liked wet wipes best. The parents were fine with that choice. The hosts called it a common ground between the family's goal and the child's comfort.
This case stretches the idea of a preference assessment. It is not only for finding rewards. It can also shape how a goal is taught. Catanese and Abdel tied this to building a positive relationship. That also meant following his lead and modeling his requests on his AAC device. AAC stands for augmentative and alternative communication, like a speech app or picture board.
Reading the type of reward a student wants#
Nicky Schneider works in schools. With students who can talk about their choices, she returns again and again to a first choice reinforcement menu.
I've come back to this first choice reinforcement menu and I love it... it does tell me about what kind of reinforcement they're looking for and not just attention or tangible.
From the talk — Nicky Schneider
Her menu sorts choices into categories. These include adult approval, competitive approval from friends, peer approval, independent items, and consumables. Consumables are things you eat or drink. The menu has many items, not just five. They are randomized but balanced across each type of reward.
Schneider says she rarely uses edible rewards in school. It is often not snack or lunch time, so it is just not possible. Still, she treats a strong food preference as a clue.
It is telling though, when a student, when consumable comes up as the top preference on this choice menu... I often go down the route of asking more questions about their meal time in school, their snack time.
From the talk — Nicky Schneider
She asks whether the student has enough to eat at school. In her hands, a preference result can point to a basic need, not only a reward.
Sensory preferences and self-injury#
Michelle Vences works closely with occupational therapists, or OTs. She uses a sensory preference assessment to understand self-injurious behavior, often shortened to SIB. Head banging is one example she gives.
when I think about my sensory preference assessment that is associated with OT and ABA
From the talk — Michelle Vences
Vences asks why a client uses a behavior like head banging. Is it for escape, or does it give sensory input? Maybe it is a mix. She points out that SIB is a sensory-rich choice for the person. So, in her words, it is still a preference at the end of the day. Her sensory preference assessment can show whether SIB is part of what the person likes.
That finding shapes the plan. If the behavior seems to give its own sensory payoff, she and the OT look for safer sources of the same input. She names proprioceptive input, which is the sense of body position and pressure. She also names vestibular input, which is the sense of motion and balance. Giving that input before problems start may make head banging a less likely choice.
Refreshing preferences in the middle of a session#
Ashley Andrew speaks to technicians about planning sessions well. She stresses using a learner's known interests ahead of time. If a child loves cars, plan several ways to build goals into car play.
But interests do not stay fixed. Andrew asks how to grow beyond the same favorite items. Maybe trucks or airplanes will work. Maybe the child likes that cars go round and round, so other spinning items could work too.
When a learner runs away from you, she has a blunt guess. You do not have anything they want. Her advice is to try a quick, informal preference assessment right then. Gather some new items and see what sparks interest. She also asks whether you are just the person who shows up to make demands. Pairing, or building yourself up as a source of good things, matters here too.
I'd be prepared to do a preference assessment too, because maybe puzzles, coloring, and building are just done.
From the talk — Ashley Andrew
Andrew also suggests changing how familiar items are used. Tape a puzzle on the wall. Color on a whiteboard. Swap Duplo blocks for magnet tiles or Jenga. If engagement still falls short, she says to bring your questions to your BCBA.
Who can run it: RBTs and billing#
Dr. Jessica Osos looks at preference assessments through supervision and billing. She explains which assessment tasks a BCBA can hand off to a registered behavior technician, or RBT. These tasks fit under the 97152 billing code, which covers technician support for assessment.
stimulus preference assessment, that one is like specifically named in a lot of different areas.
From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos
She lists paired choice and multiple stimulus assessments as examples. She notes that a multiple stimulus assessment probably will not fill a whole 15 minute billing unit. But if a team is stumped and lacks strong reinforcers, she suggests a fuller paired choice assessment. That can gather more data on what the client likes.
Osos also frames this within supervision rules. She notes RBTs need supervision for at least five percent of their monthly service hours. That includes at least two real-time contacts each month. She says her clinic runs well above that, at about 11 percent. Her clinic keeps guides on what can be delegated and what needs more training first. During these sessions, the RBT should also be taking data.
For more on handing off assessment tasks, see Delegating with Confidence: Training and Supervising RBTs to Support Assessments.
Adapting the method for adults#
Nicole Parks trains fieldwork students who work with many adult clients. She wants them to know assessment in theory and in practice. She stresses that the right tool depends on the client in front of you. In her view, running a paired stimulus assessment designed for children with an adult client is just not practical, so students need to figure out how to adapt the method instead.
Parks's program teaches students several ways to run preference assessments. They also learn motivational interviewing, a talk-based method for drawing out a person's own reasons for change. Her team built an adult interest tool that students can modify. The goal, she says, is competence and fluency. Students should be able to customize for each client.
Her view echoes a theme across these talks. A preference assessment is not a single script. A long series of two-item choices may suit a young child. An adult may be better served by an interview or interest list. Parks wants students to be flexible and contextual, not to treat assessment as a one-to-one match of tool to task.
Preference assessments for staff and supervisors#
Preference assessments are not only for clients. Mellanie Page applies them to staff training and onboarding. Her point is that motivation does not just happen. Even a clear sense of purpose is not enough, because people have different preferences.
it's so important to assess preferences early and often and be clear about what reinforces team members.
From the talk — Mellanie Page
Page offers a practical tool for managers.
I've got a preference assessment here where you can kind of track your team members on the top of this spreadsheet and then score their preference for each of the items and include some of your own items.
From the talk — Mellanie Page
She urges leaders to look past concrete items. If social time reinforces someone, invite them to your next meeting. Other ideas include lunch with leadership and public recognition. Many of these cost nothing. She answers a common pushback directly. Yes, you cannot buy everyone everything they want. But you can still learn preferences and act on some of them.
Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin described a supervision study that used the same idea.
Before baseline, supervisors completed a preference assessment to identify a rank ranking of various items such as food or gift card.
From the talk — Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin
Supervisors earned points for each correct step of a target skill. Higher scores unlocked highly preferred items. Lower scores unlocked moderately preferred ones.
Parents have preferences too#
Sean Yocum takes the idea one step further, to parents. He grounds his view in the basic principles of the field. Behavior analysts work with reinforcement, schedules of reinforcement, and contingencies. A contingency is an if-then link between a behavior and its result.
He points out what clinicians already do with every child before treatment begins.
We should be getting to know them and getting preference assessments done, correct, and understanding.
From the talk — Sean Yocum
Yocum then asks why that same thinking should stop at the child. He asks what the number one reinforcer for parents is. His answer centers on providers helping with the family's problems. If that is what reinforces parents, it can guide how teams build parent buy-in.
This is a quick, direct take. It reminds clinicians that caregivers are people with their own motivation. The same tools used to find a child's favorite toy can help explain what keeps a parent engaged. Yocum frames this as part of making caregiver training and generalization work in real life.
Beyond humans: a cat's favorite treat#
Preference assessments even showed up in a chat about pets. In Morgan Johnson's article club, the group asked who had used ABA with their animals. One member described a cat that kept going outside the litter box. When the cat used the box, she got a treat right away. It was a special treat saved only for that behavior.
I did a preference assessment. With my cat.
From the talk — Morgan Johnson
The group was delighted. Someone admitted they had never thought to run one with an animal, but it made sense. When asked about the method, the answer pointed to a paired stimulus style approach. The cat is picky. Several treats were set in front of her, and she was told to pick one. She would smell them all and choose her favorite.
The story is light, but it shows the core logic well. Offer real choices. Watch what gets picked. Then use the winner only when the target behavior happens. That keeps the reward special and tied to the goal.
Different starting points for different situations#
The experts here all agree that preference assessments matter. Where they differ is which format they reach for first, largely because they work with different clients and constraints.
Matt Harrington leans hard toward open observation. He almost always starts with a free operant assessment. He worries that some learners cannot sit for something like 150 PSPA trials. He then uses a quick MSWO on only the top few items.
Dr. Jessica Osos takes a different angle when a case is stuck. If a team lacks strong reinforcers, she suggests a fuller paired choice assessment to gather more data. She sees the longer, structured format as a way to dig deeper, not a burden to avoid.
Nicole Parks adds a third view based on who the client is. She says a PSPA with an adult is not very practical. For her, the client's age and context should drive the choice.
These are differences in clinical defaults, not disagreements about whether to assess. They are about how. The research section below shows why each view has support. Some formats give steadier rankings. Others produce less problem behavior. Picking one means weighing those trade-offs for the person in front of you.
What the research says#
Studies help explain why clinicians pick different formats. Verriden and Roscoe compared four preference assessment methods (Verriden & Roscoe, 2016). Paired stimulus and MSWO rankings stayed most stable across repeated runs. Free operant rankings matched less well across runs. So did a stricter free operant variation called response restriction. But the free operant method was linked with the lowest levels of problem behavior.
Herbek and colleagues compared a response-restriction free operant assessment with a PSPA (Herbek et al., 2026). They studied six children seen at a severe behavior clinic. Both produced similar rankings. The free operant version led to less challenging behavior for four of the six children. However, the PSPA took less time to finish.
Lill and colleagues built a decision model to help practitioners choose a format (Lill et al., 2021). They note that MSWO and paired choice results agree closely on top items.
Bigwood and colleagues adapted standard assessments for four people with dementia (Bigwood et al., 2026). Both versions picked similar items. The adapted version led to more signs of happiness for three of the four people.
FAQ#
What is the difference between a preference assessment and a reinforcer assessment? A preference assessment ranks what a person likes or chooses most. A reinforcer assessment tests whether an item actually makes a behavior happen more. Matt Harrington notes that a top-ranked item can still be too weak to work. He suggests running a reinforcer assessment when teaching hits a wall.
Which preference assessment should I use first? It depends on the person. Matt Harrington starts with free operant observation, then runs a short MSWO on the top items. Dr. Jessica Osos suggests a fuller paired choice assessment when a team is stuck. Nicole Parks says paired choice formats are often not practical with adults. Research shows free operant formats tend to produce less problem behavior, while paired and MSWO formats give steadier rankings.
Can an RBT run a preference assessment? Yes, in many settings. Dr. Jessica Osos says stimulus preference assessments are named as a task technicians can do under the 97152 billing code. The BCBA still sets the plan and provides supervision. Her clinic keeps guides on which tasks can be delegated and which need more training first.
Turn this topic into a CEU
You just studied this. Now get credit for it.
Watch 5 Days of Manding Mastery with Matt Harrington and earn 2.5 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.
Keep going with a free learning path
Verbal Behavior: Beyond WH-Questions
Dana Pettus's three-part series on building generative verbal behavior. Why WH-question programs stall, how to establish speaker-listener repertoires, and how to scaffold advanced verbal skills like recall and simple inference. Three hours, three CEUs.
Want the primary literature? Read the Preference Assessment research roundup on our sister site, Behaviorist Book Club.



