Competing Stimulus Assessment: How It Works in ABA
A competing stimulus assessment finds items that lower automatically maintained behavior. Learn how CSAs and augmented CSAs work, with research.
Key takeaway
A competing stimulus assessment (CSA) is a test that finds items which lower a challenging behavior when the items are freely available. It is most often used for behavior that is automatically maintained, such as some self-injury or stereotypy.

Prediction and Probabilities: Three foundational equations to successful behavior reduction
Free learning path on this topic
Master PFA and SBT
Matt Harrington's 12-article walk through practical functional assessment and skill-based treatment, from Hanley's 2014 study to the enhanced choice model. Then assent, since SBT depends on it, and the ethical guardrails that keep behavior reduction defensible. Five CEUs, one of them ethics.
Experts who cover this
3 recordings on openceu cover competing stimulus assessment.
- Featured talk2 Learning CEUs
Prediction and Probabilities: Three foundational equations to successful behavior reduction
Matt HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Matt introduces contingency strength as a measure (roughly -1 to 1) of how reliably a behavior has contacted reinforcement, drawn from Lloyd et al. (2021). He…
- 1 Learning CEU
Stronger Together: Care Collab
Matt HarringtonThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Matt draws a cross-disciplinary parallel, comparing OT sensory diets to ABA's competing stimulus assessments and augmented competing stimulus assessments as…
- 1.5 Learning CEUs
PDA Caregivers, Complex Profiles, Replacement Behaviors, and Being Trauma Informed
B. Kuerine GrayThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Mentioned as an SBT-adjacent tool for efficiently testing which of many competing stimuli work for a learner without provoking behavior, gathering data quickly.
On this page · 8 sections▾
A competing stimulus assessment (CSA) is a test that finds items which lower a challenging behavior when the items are freely available. It is most often used for behavior that is automatically maintained, such as some self-injury or stereotypy.
"Automatically maintained" means the behavior pays itself off. Nobody has to hand the person anything. The behavior itself produces the good feeling. That makes it hard to treat by changing what other people do. A CSA tries a different path. It looks for things the person can do instead that "compete" with the behavior.
How a competing stimulus assessment works#
A CSA is a pre-treatment assessment. That means you run it before you build the treatment plan. The goal is to find stimuli, usually toys or other leisure items, that bring the behavior down.
During a CSA, the learner gets free access to one item at a time. Free access means the item is there without any rule attached. The learner does not have to earn it. While the item is out, you measure two things. First, how much the challenging behavior happens. Second, how much the learner engages with the item.
Items that go with big drops in behavior are the winners. Researchers often call an item "high competition" when behavior falls by at least 80% with it. The idea behind the test is reinforcer competition. In plain words, the item gives the person something good that crowds out the behavior.
A CSA is related to a preference assessment, but it asks a different question. A preference assessment asks what a learner likes. A CSA asks what actually lowers the behavior. Those two answers do not always match. A favorite toy may still sit right beside ongoing self-injury or stereotypy.
Why this tool fits automatic reinforcement#
When behavior is maintained by attention or escape, you can often change how adults respond. You can stop giving attention, or stop removing demands. Automatic reinforcement does not work that way. The payoff comes from the behavior itself, so there is nothing for adults to withhold.
That is why competing items matter so much here. If you cannot take the payoff away, you can offer something that competes with it. A good competing item gives the learner a strong source of good stuff. Behavior that once filled empty time now has a rival.
The items found in a CSA are often used later as part of treatment. They may be set out during free time, during transitions, or in settings where the behavior tends to spike. Because the items are given freely, this treatment often looks a lot like non-contingent reinforcement. That link matters for the next point about fidelity.
Fidelity means how closely a plan is carried out as written. Real clinics, homes, and classrooms rarely hit 100% fidelity. Staff get busy. Parents get tired. A treatment that keeps working when people slip up is worth a lot in daily life.
Why free access holds up when fidelity slips#
In his talk on behavior reduction, Matt Harrington uses a measure called contingency strength. It is the chance that a future behavior will lead to a reinforcer. A strong contingency means a long, steady learning history behind the behavior.
Harrington walks through what happens to that number under two treatments. The first is extinction. Extinction means the behavior no longer produces its reinforcer. At perfect fidelity, he explains, the result is dramatic.
Extinction at 100% fidelity doesn't just weaken the contingency strength. It breaks that sucker apart. It completely shatters the contingency, right?
From the talk — Matt Harrington
The trouble comes when someone slips. Harrington shows that at 75% fidelity, extinction leaves a contingency strength of about 0.3. A few missed responses let the old payoff sneak back in. Non-contingent reinforcement, where good things come freely on a schedule, barely changes. At the same 75% fidelity, it loses only about 0.01.
If you have a situation where fidelity is worrisome, a contingency strength perspective would absolutely argue that NCR is a better approach for that behavior reduction rather than extinction.
From the talk — Matt Harrington
This gives a useful lens on competing stimuli. Items from a CSA are usually offered freely, not earned. So the plan that uses them shares the forgiving shape Harrington describes. If a parent forgets a step, free access to a good item still does its job.
The augmented version: prompting and blocking#
A plain CSA does not always find a winner. Some learners will not touch the items at all. Others play with an item but keep doing the behavior at the same time. The augmented competing stimulus assessment, or A-CSA, was built for these cases.
The A-CSA adds two short-term tactics. The first is prompting, which means guiding the learner to engage with the item. The second is response blocking, which means gently stopping the behavior as it starts. These tactics are then pulled away. The team checks whether the item still competes once it is simply left out.
In the first report on this method, prompting and blocking were used in a row. When they were withdrawn, the number of effective competing items grew in all six cases (Hagopian et al., 2020). The authors suggest the A-CSA may do more than find competing items. It may help build them, too.
A later study looked at 16 people with automatically maintained self-injury (Frank-Crawford et al., 2023). Fewer high-competition items were found for people with treatment-resistant subtypes. Even so, every participant ended up with at least one high-competition item. The authors note the extra tactics may not be needed for everyone.
Testing many items fast without causing behavior#
Speed matters in a CSA. Each trial takes time, and the learner may engage in harmful behavior during testing. B. Kuerine Gray raises this point in a talk on caregiving and complex profiles.
Gray describes the value of trying things out in a safe way. In that talk, Gray points out that there is no single method that works for every learner. Plans have to be individualized, and that means testing options. Gray ties this directly to the augmented CSA.
an ancillary to that would be like the augmented competing stimulus assessment where you're rotating through 20 different potential competing stimuli very efficiently. So you're not causing behavior. But at the same time, you're getting a lot of data to see what works.
From the talk — B. Kuerine Gray
Gray's framing puts two goals side by side. You want lots of data, and you want low risk. A well-run assessment can rotate through many items without pushing the learner into a hard moment. You can hear more of Gray's thinking in PDA Caregivers, Complex Profiles, Replacement Behaviors, and Being Trauma Informed.
Same goal, different words across fields#
ABA is not the only field that tries to give people something better to do. In a talk on working across disciplines, Matt Harrington compares ABA tools to tools from other fields. He describes a talk with an occupational therapist about a weighted blanket. They used different terms, but they were really talking about the same thing.
you look at a lot of sensory diets and you could compare that to competing stimulus assessments in the aba world you look at a lot of augmented competing stimulus assessments and you can compare that to learning play the play skills in the pediatric mental health world
From the talk — Matt Harrington
A sensory diet is a plan of activities an occupational therapist builds to meet a person's sensory needs. Harrington's point is that the outcome everyone wants is the same. The learner should feel safe, comfortable, and free to live a good life. He urges teams to think less about labels and more about what is actually happening. That mindset helps a BCBA explain a CSA to OTs, play therapists, and families.
What the research says#
A CSA's success rate depends on who is studied and how results are reported. A systematic review looked across published CSA studies (Haddock & Hagopian, 2020). It found over 92% of CSAs found at least one high-competition stimulus.
A later inpatient study told a less rosy story. It covered 35 consecutive cases (Laureano et al., 2023). Only 47% of those CSAs found one or more high-competition stimuli. The authors point to differences in participants and in reporting methods.
That same study repeated an earlier finding. How much a learner engages with an item was only loosely tied to drops in behavior. In plain terms, a busy learner is not always a calmer learner. This is one reason a CSA measures behavior directly.
Time is another real cost. One study tested a latency-based CSA to make the process faster (Imler & Weyman, 2024). Latency means how long it takes before the behavior first occurs. Each trial ended at the first instance of challenging behavior. Items with the longest latency worked best in a brief treatment test. One participant still needed procedure changes.
FAQ#
What is the difference between a CSA and an A-CSA? A CSA tests items under free access and measures behavior and engagement. An A-CSA adds prompting and response blocking for a time, then removes them. This can help when a plain CSA finds no winners.
What counts as a high-competition stimulus? It is an item linked with at least an 80% drop in the challenging behavior. Finding at least one is the usual goal of a CSA.
Is a competing stimulus assessment the same as a preference assessment? No. A preference assessment shows what a learner likes. A CSA shows which items actually lower the target behavior. A liked item does not always compete well.
Turn this topic into a CEU
You just studied this. Now get credit for it.
Watch Prediction and Probabilities: Three foundational equations to successful behavior reduction with Matt Harrington and earn 2 free BCBA CEUs. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.
Keep going with a free learning path
Master PFA and SBT
Matt Harrington's 12-article walk through practical functional assessment and skill-based treatment, from Hanley's 2014 study to the enhanced choice model. Then assent, since SBT depends on it, and the ethical guardrails that keep behavior reduction defensible. Five CEUs, one of them ethics.


