Compassionate Care in ABA: Empathy Put Into Action

Compassionate care in ABA turns empathy into action that eases suffering. See how BCBAs define it, measure it, and debate its evidence.

Key takeaway

Compassionate care in Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) is the practice of turning empathy into action that eases a person's suffering. It is not just feeling sorry for someone.

The Supervision Breakthrough: Bringing Empathy to BCBA Supervision Through Behavior Science
Watch the full CEU recording

The Supervision Breakthrough: Bringing Empathy to BCBA Supervision Through Behavior Science

Bailey Payne · 1 CEU · 60 min
Watch on openceu.com →

Free learning path on this topic

Supervision, Done Right

Four supervision CEUs that build on each other. What reflective supervision is, how to build a supervision system, how to assess supervisee competence instead of counting hours, and how supervision affects provider outcomes. Each course is free and issues its own certificate.

Start the path →4 courses · 4 supervision CEUs · Watch at your own pace

Experts who cover this

7 recordings on openceu cover compassionate care.

Compassionate care in Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) is the practice of turning empathy into action that eases a person's suffering. It is not just feeling sorry for someone. It is doing something specific to make their situation better, then checking whether it worked.

The idea applies to clients, caregivers, and staff alike. BCBAs (Board Certified Behavior Analysts) and RBTs (Registered Behavior Technicians) use it in sessions, in parent meetings, and in supervision. Some experts see it as the core of good ABA. Others think the field adopted it faster than the research can support. Both views are worth knowing.

Compassion is empathy that moves into action#

Most speakers on this topic start in the same place. Empathy and compassion are related, but they are not the same thing. Bailey Payne describes empathy as perspective taking. That means trying to understand and feel another person's experience. She adds that we can never fully be in someone else's shoes. We can only get as close as possible.

Compassion goes one step further. Payne says it moves beyond understanding and toward action meant to ease difficulty.

To me, compassion is more about the action.From the talk — Bailey Payne

She puts it simply. Empathy is more about the person. Compassion is more about the action. And as behavior analysts, the action is what we can see and measure.

Matthew Brodhead uses nearly the same definition in his review of the topic. He also frames it in behavior analytic terms. He calls it a complex operant, meaning a learned behavior shaped by its results. Its function is to reduce aversive stimuli, or unpleasant conditions, in another person's life.

compassion refers to the application of empathy or the conversion of empathetic feelings into compassionate act. Actions specifically intended to alleviate the suffering of another.From the talk — Matthew T. Brodhead

This shared definition matters. It means compassion is not a mood. It is a set of behaviors you can teach, observe, and improve.

Why pity is not compassion#

Penny Holloway draws a sharp line between pity and compassion. She leans on the Taylor, LeBlanc, and Nosik article, which separates pity, sympathy, empathy, and compassion. Holloway calls that article a game changer for her own practice.

Her main point is about how we see clients. Pity looks down on a person. It frames them by what they lack.

our clients do not deserve our pity. It's not, poor Johnny, Johnny doesn't have any skills.From the talk — Penny Holloway

Holloway pushes back on that frame directly. In her words, Johnny is perfect and Johnny is awesome. He does not need our pity. What he needs is someone who will act on his behalf.

But compassion, yes, compassion takes empathy a step further, brings action to an empathetic response. In this regard, compassion converts empathy into an act aimed at alleviation of suffering.From the talk — Penny Holloway

This matters for daily practice. A clinician who pities a learner may lower the bar or skip teaching. A clinician who feels compassion still teaches. They just look for the path that causes the least distress. Holloway also ties this to rapport. A learner who trusts you is a learner who can keep growing. That trust includes knowing you won't take away their iPad for no reason.

A ladder from perspective taking to alliance#

Nicky Schneider lays out compassion as one rung on a ladder. Her talk focuses on behavior change in schools. Her core message is that adults must change their own behavior first. Only then can they expect the student's behavior to change.

The ladder starts with perspective taking. That means thinking about how another person feels. Next comes empathy.

Empathy takes it a step further, putting yourself in the other person's shoes, understanding emotional responses.From the talk — Nicky Schneider

Then comes compassion. Schneider stresses that it is something you build together with the person, not something you do to them.

Compassion really is a plan that you set with the individual on how to relieve their suffering, whether they're able to communicate it vocally or non-vocally, you come together to make a plan.From the talk — Nicky Schneider

Notice the word "together." A learner who does not speak still gets a voice in the plan. Schneider then adds one more rung above compassion. That top rung is the therapeutic alliance, a working partnership built on trust. She notes that pairing, the step where staff become linked with good things, shows up in research. But in her view, pairing alone is not enough. The alliance goes further than pairing, perspective taking, empathy, or compassion alone.

Your social partner decides if it was compassionate#

Bailey Payne makes a point that shifts who gets to judge compassion. The helper does not decide whether an action was compassionate. Payne says her social partner, the person on the receiving end, does.

This is a very behavior analytic idea. A behavior is defined by its effect, not by the intent behind it. If your action did not feel helpful to the other person, it did not function as compassion. Your good intent does not change that.

Payne gives practical steps for checking. First, admit what you don't know. You might say that you can't fully know what someone is going through, but you want them to tell you. Then listen. After that, ask for feedback directly. A simple question works well. "Was the way I responded helpful?"

She asks clinicians to check in on their own behavior often. How often do we ask whether our attempt at compassion landed? Without that check, we have no data. And without data, we can't say whether we were truly compassionate. This links closely to social validity, which asks whether the people we serve find our work acceptable and useful.

Compassion in supervision does not lower the bar#

A common fear is that compassion means going soft. Bailey Payne rejects that idea. She says empathy is not lowering competency standards. It is not avoiding corrective feedback, even when giving that feedback feels uncomfortable.

Her focus is supervision. She asks supervisors to think about bosses they have had who were not kind or understanding. In her view, it is up to today's supervisors to break that mold. They can model the behaviors they want staff to show clients.

Payne frames the key supervision question as being about action. It is not whether we feel empathy. It is what we actually do. The behaviors she points to are observable. A supervisor listens. A supervisor asks for feedback on their own responses. A supervisor still holds the standard and still gives correction.

This view treats compassion as a skill that helps people learn. It does not replace performance expectations. It changes how we help someone meet them. Payne says she hopes supervisors walk away with objective ways to be more compassionate. That word "objective" is the key. She wants compassion defined in terms anyone could observe.

Her approach also generalizes. She notes that the same skills we use with clients should carry over to how we treat adults on our team.

Identifying suffering contingencies#

Pauli Catanese and Jasmine Abdel discussed an article on a child's rights approach to ABA. One line from it stood out to them. It defines compassionate behavior in a way that sounds a lot like a task list.

behavior analyst must identify suffering contingencies and take actions to help individuals in distress.From the talk — Pauli Catanese & Jasmine Abdel

A contingency is the link between a behavior and what follows it. A suffering contingency is any part of the setup that causes distress. In their view, spotting these is what separates good ABA from bad ABA. Good ABA watches for the emotional effects of treatment while it is running.

They raise questions every clinician can ask during sessions. Are we respecting the client's choices? Does the client trust us? Are we listening when they show discomfort? Are we hearing it when they say they need help?

The article they reviewed includes a checklist drawn from the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. It covers safety, education, privacy, play, choice, dignity, and freedom from discrimination. They also believe the BACB (Behavior Analyst Certification Board) ethics code touches on these ideas, but only lightly.

I feel like the, BACV does, like, with, like, just reading the first couple of these, like, will have stuff in our ethics code, but it's like, the surface level.From the talk — Pauli Catanese & Jasmine Abdel

Their point is that the code names good practice but rarely explains how each right could become a barrier.

A system, not a marketing slogan#

Matt Harrington worries that "compassionate care" and "assent-based care" are losing meaning. Assent-based care means treatment that continues only with the learner's ongoing agreement, not just upfront consent. Many clinicians now hear these terms as buzzwords. He wants the field to see them as real changes in how ABA gets done.

ascent-based ABA is just a different way of doing ABA, some slight tweaks, some different frameworks, instead of this marketing buzzword that we immediately shift off and push away and say, oh, that's just something that the big private equity companies say so they can get people to work there.From the talk — Matt Harrington

Harrington draws on a 2023 article about a multi-level framework (Denegri et al., 2023). It looks at compassionate care at three levels. The first is the organization, including its mission and its OBM, short for organizational behavior management. The second is the clinician. The third is the direct technician. Each level shapes the others.

He also makes a business case. Compassion matters to the learner. But it matters to others in the organization too.

compassionate care typically leads to more satisfied consumers.From the talk — Matt Harrington

He adds a key condition. The outcomes still need to be strong. When they are, the route you take to reach them matters too. He gives the example of a goal of zero self-injury. One route might take three months and rely heavily on extinction, which means withholding the reward that used to follow a behavior. That route could also involve response blocking, or physically preventing the behavior, and resurgence, the return of old behaviors that had stopped. Many families would still be happy with that result. His point is that the path itself is part of what families experience.

Ethical guardrails for every intervention#

In a separate talk on behavior reduction, Matt Harrington describes a set of personal ethical guardrails. He compares them to the bumpers at a bowling alley. As long as you stay inside them, the ball eventually heads the right way.

He built these guardrails from three bodies of work: assent-based care, trauma-informed care, and the constructional approach to behavior analysis. Trauma-informed care means treatment that accounts for a person's past trauma. The constructional approach focuses on building new skills rather than only removing problem behavior.

So the reason why I bring up my guardrails, which is that every intervention is fully informed and assented to throughout, we're causing no further harm, and we're building resistant repertoires, is because the guardrails are a strong reason why you as a clinician need to make changes in your programming.From the talk — Matt Harrington

So there are three guardrails. Every intervention is fully informed and has the learner's assent throughout. Treatment causes no further harm. And it builds lasting skills that hold up over time.

Harrington is careful about what the guardrails are not. They are not a list of banned procedures. He does not say "never use extinction" or "never run a functional analysis" (a structured test that identifies why a behavior happens). Some procedures fit some clients and not others. The guardrails are boundaries to keep an intervention inside. He believes most ABA interventions can live and thrive within them. When an inherited plan falls outside them, that is a reason to change it.

Measuring compassion in treatment integrity#

Penny Holloway takes compassion one step further into daily practice. She measures it. The Taylor, LeBlanc, and Nosik article includes measures of compassionate behavior. Holloway builds those measures into her treatment integrity checklists. Treatment integrity means checking whether a plan is being carried out as written.

What I really like about this article is they have measures for compassion and compassion. And I really have woven them into my treatment integrities that I sometimes take with whomever I'm observing.From the talk — Penny Holloway

She uses these checks with whoever she is watching. That might be an RBT. It might be a parent. Either way, she is clear about her purpose. She is not grading anyone on whether they are a compassionate person. She is not judging.

Instead, the data open a conversation. She might point out a moment where compassion could apply. Then the two of them talk about how to work toward it. This turns a vague value into something both people can see and practice.

This approach fits well with Payne's view. Both treat compassion as a set of observable actions. Holloway's checklist simply gives those actions a place on a data sheet. That makes them easier to coach and easier to track over time.

Compassion fatigue is not the same as burnout#

Compassion has a cost for the people who give it. B. Kuereine Gray separates two kinds of strain that clinicians often mix up. One is burnout. The other is secondary traumatic stress, which many people call compassion fatigue. Gray notes that the term "compassion fatigue" became common during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Gray explains that research treats burnout as a professional issue. It affects your ability to provide care. It affects the organization, the client, and clinical outcomes. Compassion fatigue, by contrast, is a personal issue. You carry it with you outside of work.

Gray lists specific signs tied to compassion fatigue. They include intrusive thoughts and trouble managing emotions. Avoidance shows up as cancelled sessions and low drive to engage. Empathy toward clients drops. The person may not want to be present at work. They may even stop enjoying their favorite activities at home.

The research she reviewed looked at variables like age, caseload size, and pandemic-related anxiety. For supervisors, the lesson is clear. A staff member losing empathy may not need a lecture on compassion. They may need support for their own stress.

Where experts disagree on the evidence#

The speakers mostly agree on what compassion is. They do not agree on how strong the case for it is.

Matthew Brodhead says openly that he has doubts.

I am skeptical about compassionate careFrom the talk — Matthew T. Brodhead

He explains that being skeptical means asking questions about the validity or value of something. He supports the goal of reducing suffering. His concern is the evidence. He credits Bridget Taylor and colleagues with sparking today's interest. But he says adoption has far outpaced the research behind it.

We found 15 articles on the topic of compassionate care and ABA, eight of which are empirical.From the talk — Matthew T. Brodhead

Empirical means based on data collected through research, not just opinion. His team found that most of those articles appeared in a single journal. Only 14 percent of their recommendations were aimed at practitioners. He also wants more replication, meaning other researchers repeating the study and getting similar results. He stops short of calling it a fad. He says it could get there with more research.

Matt Harrington takes a more confident stance. He says that in his opinion, assent-based and compassionate care actually go faster than traditional, extinction-heavy approaches. He also argues it improves consumer satisfaction. Holloway, Payne, and Schneider all treat compassion as settled practice worth building into daily work.

So the split is real. Practitioners report clear value in their own work. Brodhead asks whether published data yet back those reports. Both positions can push the field forward.

What the research says#

The modern push started with a paper examining whether attending to caregiver relationships could improve treatment outcomes (Taylor, LeBlanc, & Nosik, 2019). The authors note that most BCBAs are fairly new and trained mainly in technical skills. They argue that working with families also takes strong relationship skills, and they outline ways to build them.

A follow-up survey checked how BCBAs were trained (LeBlanc, Taylor, & Marchese, 2019). Most respondents had no formal coursework on relationship-building. About half got guidance from a supervisor. Most said formal training in this area is very or extremely important.

Teaching these skills appears possible (Rohrer & Weiss, 2022). Four master's students learned compassion skills through behavioral skills training, a structured teach-practice-feedback method, delivered over telehealth. All four improved and kept the skills at follow-up.

The focus is now widening (Kristiansen et al., 2025). Early work centered on caregivers. Newer work looks at learners and at compassion inside the workplace. These are still small studies, which echoes Brodhead's call for more data.

FAQ#

What is the difference between empathy and compassion in ABA? Empathy is trying to understand and feel what another person is going through. Compassion takes that feeling and turns it into action. The action aims to ease the person's suffering. In ABA, compassion is the part you can observe and measure.

Can compassionate care be measured? Yes. Some clinicians add compassion items to their treatment integrity checklists. Others ask the person directly whether a response felt helpful. Since the receiver decides if an action was compassionate, their feedback is key data.

Is compassion fatigue the same as burnout? No. Burnout is a professional issue that affects care quality and outcomes. Compassion fatigue, or secondary traumatic stress, is a personal issue. Signs include intrusive thoughts, avoidance, cancelled sessions, and lower empathy toward clients.

For a closer look at the evidence debate, see Assent and Compassionate Care: Ethical Issues and Considerations for Practice.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch The Supervision Breakthrough: Bringing Empathy to BCBA Supervision Through Behavior Science with Bailey Payne and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert

Keep going with a free learning path

Supervision, Done Right

Four supervision CEUs that build on each other. What reflective supervision is, how to build a supervision system, how to assess supervisee competence instead of counting hours, and how supervision affects provider outcomes. Each course is free and issues its own certificate.

Start the path →4 courses · 4 supervision CEUs · Watch at your own pace