Creative Hopelessness in ACT: How the Mind Keeps Us Stuck

Creative hopelessness is an ACT idea about how the mind bends information to keep us stuck. Learn what it means and how it pairs with hope.

Key takeaway

Creative hopelessness is an ACT term for the way the mind changes information to keep a person stuck. ACT stands for Acceptance and Commitment Therapy.

Playing the Game of Life with ACT: The ABAA Process of Human Behavior Change in the Real World- Part 2
Watch the full CEU recording

Playing the Game of Life with ACT: The ABAA Process of Human Behavior Change in the Real World- Part 2

Kaitlin Wilder · 1 CEU · 50 min
Watch on openceu.com →

Free learning path on this topic

Sleep for Behavior Analysts

Lindsay Anderson's three-part series on sleep. Start with the science of sleep and how it affects your own health and work, then build an individualized bedtime routine, then work through why a child keeps waking at 2 AM. Three hours, three CEUs.

Start the path →3 courses · 3 CEUs · Watch at your own pace

Experts who cover this

2 recordings on openceu cover creative hopelessness.

Creative hopelessness is an ACT term for the way the mind changes information to keep a person stuck. ACT stands for Acceptance and Commitment Therapy. It is an approach that helps people act on what matters to them, even when hard thoughts show up.

In her ACT courses, Kaitlin Wilder calls creative hopelessness a term you need to know. She explains that the mind can bend facts to fit its own plan. That plan is often to stay right where we are. She also pairs it with an opposite idea, creative hope. This page walks through both, using her words.

What creative hopelessness means#

Kaitlin Wilder gives a clear definition. She says creative hopelessness is the mind's ability to change information. The mind does this to fit "whatever the mind or body's agenda" is. In plain terms, our thinking can reshape what we see and hear. It does this so the facts match what we already believe.

The word "creative" matters here. The mind is not lying in a simple way. It is building something new out of the facts it gets. It can twist them "in any which way," as Wilder puts it. The word "hopelessness" matters too. The result of all that building is a sense that change is not possible. We end up stuck, and the story in our head explains why.

So according to ACT in Creative Hopelessness and Relational Frame Theory, we can take information and change it creative. In any which way, so that we can keep ourselves stuck.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Wilder ties this idea to both ACT and Relational Frame Theory. Relational Frame Theory is a behavior science account of how people relate words and ideas to each other. You do not need to know it well to follow her point. The key is that minds link ideas in ways that can hold us in place.

"Manipulate" does not mean what you think#

Wilder is careful with one word. She says the mind can "manipulate" information. Then she stops to explain what she does and does not mean. In ABA settings, people sometimes call a child "manipulative." That label suggests the child is scheming or trying to trick someone. Wilder says that is not her meaning at all.

Hopelessness is the mind's ability to, hear me now. Manipulate information, and I don't mean manipulate like we talk about, oh, that kid's so manipulative. I'm talking about actually, literally changing. information in order to fit whatever the mind or body's agenda.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Her meaning is more literal. To manipulate information is to change it. The mind takes in a fact and reshapes it. This is not a moral failing. It is something minds do. That framing is useful for practitioners. It lets us talk about stuck patterns without blame. A client is not being sneaky when their mind bends the facts. Neither are we when ours does the same thing.

How the mind keeps us stuck#

Wilder explains how this plays out in daily life. We hold beliefs and thoughts about who we are. We also hold beliefs about our lives, our behavior, and what we can and cannot do. When we are tightly attached to those beliefs, we make up stories. The stories explain why we can or cannot do certain things.

ACT has a name for being tightly attached to thoughts. It is called fusion. Wilder says we can be "so fused" to these beliefs that the stories feel like plain facts. That is where creative hopelessness does its work. The mind uses the stories to explain away any chance of change.

Wilder also points out a key risk. We may never question these stories at all. They just sit there and guide what we do. Even when we do start to question them, the mind can keep working to protect them. That is part of what makes the pattern so sticky. The stories feel true because the mind has shaped the facts to fit them.

Why it shows up around things we want#

Here is the part Wilder admits sounds odd. You might expect the mind to make up stories about things we fear or dislike. But she says creative hopelessness often forms around things we really want to do. The goals that matter most can be the ones we talk ourselves out of.

Think about what that means in practice. A person may care a great deal about a goal. Yet they hold a strong story about why it is not for them. The story might be about their skills, their past, or who they are. Because they care so much, the story can feel even more serious. So they stay away from the very thing they value.

Wilder links this to valued action. Valued action means doing things that line up with what matters to you. Creative hopelessness gets in the way of that. It gives the mind a reason to avoid the step forward. This is why she treats the concept as a core term in ACT and not a side note.

The other end: creative hope#

Wilder does not present creative hopelessness alone. She sets it up as one end of a spectrum. The other end is creative hope. As she likes to say, "there is no light without dark." Each side helps us understand the other.

In her first course, she defines hope in simple terms. Hope is expecting an outcome with confidence and trust. That holds true even when there is no certainty.

that is, um, expecting, um, an outcome with confidence and trust. Um, even if there is not certainty, like we may not know how we may not know when we may not know why, but we are able to choose to trust that process

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Notice the word "choose." In Wilder's view, hope is something we can pick, not just something we feel. We may not know how, when, or why things will work out. We can still choose to trust the process. That is a direct contrast to creative hopelessness. One side bends facts to keep us stuck. The other side lets us move forward without needing every answer first. Wilder even calls ACT "the hope factory." She sees hope as something practitioners help clients build, and build in themselves too.

Where it fits in the ABAA process#

Wilder teaches creative hopelessness as part of a larger model she calls the ABAA process of human behavior change. In her second course, the concept comes up right after she talks about making the right choices in a given moment. She describes that as "climbing of the adaptive peak," an idea she returns to often.

She frames her teaching around a simple pairing. First, there is what we love, which is our life. Then there is the problem that comes along with it. Creative hopelessness sits on the problem side of that picture. It is one of the things that keeps a person from climbing toward what they love.

This framing helps place the concept for learners. Creative hopelessness is not a diagnosis. It is a pattern that can show up for anyone. It lives alongside the good things in life, not apart from them. If you want the earlier groundwork for this model, Wilder covers it in The ABAA Process of Human Behavior Change in the Real World- Part 1.

Judgments, rules, and the stories we tell#

Wilder's first course offers useful context for why minds build these stories at all. She says judgments, assumptions, and rules are normal. They help make our thinking and our lives more efficient and automatic. If we had to stop and decide on every single thing, life would take a very long time.

So the mind's habit of shaping information is not a flaw to wipe out. It is part of how thinking works. The trouble comes when those quick rules start to run our choices without question. That is when a helpful shortcut can turn into a story that keeps us stuck.

Wilder's answer is to notice. She says we can notice that we are judging. Then, right in that moment, we can work toward non-judgment. This fits well with the idea of creative hopelessness. The first step is not to fight the story. It is to see the story as a story. Once a person can notice it, they have a little more room to choose what to do next.

Experience and letting go of outcomes#

Wilder also speaks about experience. She defines it as awareness, knowledge, and skills gained by watching, by self-observation, and by living through events. She says we should give more credit to experience than we ever have before.

She briefly connects this to workability, an ACT term for whether a way of thinking helps someone live well. It does not ask only if the thought is right or wrong. In her words, whatever someone has lived through or believes is true for that person, through that lens.

Wilder then names a real cost. She says we build a lot of aversive history when we push ourselves and others to hold tight to an outcome. This also creates avoidance. Aversive history means a past full of unpleasant experiences. Avoidance means steering away from things to escape discomfort. Her alternative is to allow what is true for us to be true. This links back to creative hopelessness, since holding tight to a set outcome can feed the same stuck stories the mind is already building.

FAQ#

What is creative hopelessness in simple terms? It is the way the mind changes information to keep a person stuck. Kaitlin Wilder describes it as the mind reshaping facts to fit its own agenda. Often this happens around things the person truly wants to do.

Is creative hopelessness the same as being manipulative? No. Wilder is clear on this point. She does not mean manipulative in the sense of a child trying to trick someone. She means the mind literally changes information. It is a normal thing minds do, not a moral flaw.

How does creative hope relate to creative hopelessness? Wilder treats them as two ends of one spectrum. Creative hopelessness keeps a person stuck. Creative hope means expecting an outcome with confidence and trust, even without certainty. She calls ACT "the hope factory" because it helps people build that hope.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch Playing the Game of Life with ACT: The ABAA Process of Human Behavior Change in the Real World- Part 2 with Kaitlin Wilder and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert

Keep going with a free learning path

Sleep for Behavior Analysts

Lindsay Anderson's three-part series on sleep. Start with the science of sleep and how it affects your own health and work, then build an individualized bedtime routine, then work through why a child keeps waking at 2 AM. Three hours, three CEUs.

Start the path →3 courses · 3 CEUs · Watch at your own pace