Respect for Autonomy in ABA: Letting People Decide

Respect for autonomy means a person makes informed, uncoerced choices. See how ABA experts apply it to grief, body consent, and caregiver decisions.

Key takeaway

Respect for autonomy means honoring a person's right to make informed and uncoerced decisions about their own life. In behavior analysis, this reaches into grief, touch, treatment plans, and the choices families make about providers.

Grief Support at the Front Lines: Training Day Hab and Group Home Staff to Support Adults with IDD Through Bereavement
Watch the full CEU recording

Grief Support at the Front Lines: Training Day Hab and Group Home Staff to Support Adults with IDD Through Bereavement

Tricia Lund · 1 CEU · 60 min
Watch on openceu.com →

Free learning path on this topic

Ethics Essentials

Three free courses worth 5.5 CEUs, 4 of them ethics. Start with Matt Harrington's assent and data course, then ethical guardrails in behavior reduction, then cultural considerations in clinical practice. Each course issues its own certificate.

Start the path →3 courses · 5.5 CEUs (1.5 learning, 4 ethics) · Watch at your own pace

Experts who cover this

4 recordings on openceu cover respect for autonomy.

Respect for autonomy means honoring a person's right to make informed and uncoerced decisions about their own life. In behavior analysis, this reaches into grief, touch, treatment plans, and the choices families make about providers.

Four OpenCEU talks look at this idea from different sides. One covers grief in adults with disabilities. One covers working with other providers. Two more cover child rights and personal values. All of them land in the same place. The person who lives with a choice should help make it.

What respect for autonomy means#

Kaitlin Wilder gives the clearest short definition. She lists autonomy as one of several core values in her talk on human behavior change. Her wording is simple and easy to remember.

Autonomy is a human's right to make informed and uncoerced decisions. Um, we're kind of coercing ourselves all the time.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Her definition has two key words. "Informed" means the person knows enough to choose well. "Uncoerced" means nobody pushed them into the choice. Coercion is any pressure that takes the real choice away.

Wilder adds a twist that many people miss. She says we coerce ourselves all the time. People push themselves toward outcomes they feel they must reach. In the same talk, she warns that clinging to a set outcome builds avoidance. She says this creates "aversive history," which means a past full of unpleasant pressure. In plain words, pressure makes people want to escape.

That is true when the pressure comes from a clinician. It is also true when it comes from inside a person's own head. So respect for autonomy is not only a rule for staff. It is a habit of asking who is really making each choice, and why.

Why both parts of the definition matter#

A choice needs both parts to count as free. If someone has no information, their choice is a guess. If someone has information but feels forced, the choice is not really theirs. Each speaker on this page leans on one part, the other, or both.

Tricia Lund focuses on sharing information first. She wants a grieving person to know what is coming before they decide. Matt Harrington makes a similar point about families. He says caregivers cannot make an informed decision when providers keep their work separate.

Pauli Catanese and Jasmine Abdel lean toward the uncoerced side. They ask whether a person is being moved or held without a real say. Their focus is the body, and who gets to decide what happens to it.

Together, these views show a clear pattern. Clinicians hold a lot of knowledge. Respecting autonomy means passing that knowledge along in a way people can use. Then it means stepping back so they can use it. Giving facts without the freedom to act is not enough. Giving freedom without the facts is not enough either. Both steps have to happen.

The caring focus model and its blind spot#

Tricia Lund trains day program and group home staff. These staff support adults with IDD, which stands for intellectual and developmental disabilities. Her talk covers what happens when someone in a client's life dies.

Lund describes a common pattern she calls the caring focus model. Under this model, staff try to shield the person from death. They might skip the funeral. They might take away pictures of the person who died. They might say "lost" or "went to heaven" instead of the word dead. They try to distract the person from hard feelings.

These moves come from kindness. But Lund points out a big problem. Outside people decide how much the person gets to grieve. The person does not get a say. She offers a different mindset.

I'm wondering if we can shift the mindset to something that's more focused on autonomy, where we're equal and we're talking about it... You are the expert on your own grief. You are the expert on how much of this you can do.

From the talk — Tricia Lund

The key phrase is "where we're equal." Staff share information. The person tells staff how much they can handle. Nobody assumes they already know the answer.

Letting the person set the limits#

Lund does not stop at the big idea. She shows what it looks like with real clients. One tool she uses is a simple schedule of the funeral.

I've had clients where the funeral is an option and I have a schedule that shows you everything that's going to happen at this funeral. And you are able to tell me I can do this part, but not this part.

From the talk — Tricia Lund

This turns one huge choice into many small ones. The person does not have to pick between going to everything or going to nothing. They can say, "I can keep it together for this long, but not this long." That is close to Lund's own wording.

Lund also says the person does not have to go at all. If staff have shared enough information, and the person says no, that is fine. In her words, "That was your choice. That was not me making that decision for you."

She adds that staff can prepare people ahead of time. If a death is expected, staff can share information before it happens. They can also suggest ways to hold a memorial. Each step gives the person more ways to take part on their own terms. The person stays involved, even when they choose to step back.

Agency as an intervention#

Many clinicians think of autonomy as an ethics topic. Lund frames it as a treatment tool too. She calls agency one of the best interventions there is. Agency means a sense that you can act and make things happen.

giving agency is, I think, one of the best interventions ever. Giving a little bit of agency. When someone feels empowered, when someone feels that they have control, grieving will be easier.

From the talk — Tricia Lund

Lund is careful not to oversell this. She says grieving will still be hard. But she says it would be even harder with no control and no autonomy. Choice does not remove pain. It removes an extra layer of helplessness on top of the pain.

This matters for staff who work with adults with IDD. Many of these adults have spent years with others deciding for them. A death can make that feel even worse. Lund's approach gives staff something concrete to do. They can share facts, offer options, and then honor the answer.

Notice that Lund says "a little bit of agency." She is not asking staff to hand over every decision at once. Small, real choices can still make a difference. That makes her advice easy to start using right away.

Body autonomy and physical prompting#

Pauli Catanese and Jasmine Abdel lead an article club on a child rights approach to ABA. They walk through a checklist with several domains. One domain is bodily autonomy, which Catanese and Abdel sum up simply: a person has the right to decide what happens to their own body.

The hosts tie this right straight to physical prompting. A physical prompt is when a staff member uses their hands to help a learner move. Graduated guidance, a hands-on prompting method, is one common example. The hosts note that this is where the idea of "I'm going to help you" often shows up.

They suggest a question every clinician can ask. Does this treatment unnecessarily restrict movement? If staff use a named crisis procedure such as PCM, it is usually for safety reasons. The hosts say the person should meet the set criteria before staff use it. If the person does not meet those criteria, staff should look closely at the choice.

Catanese and Abdel also stress respect in daily interactions. They say staff are role models for how to treat other people. They want sessions to feel like a positive life experience rather than an aversive one. To hear the full checklist discussion, watch Article Club: A Child's Rights Approach to ABA.

Autonomy for caregivers, not only clients#

Matt Harrington brings a different angle. His talk is about working well with other providers, like speech therapists and psychiatrists. He lists respect for autonomy as one reason this teamwork is an ethical duty.

His point is about the caregiver's choice. When providers do not work together, caregivers feel stuck. They feel they must pick one provider over another.

when you don't care collaborate, caregivers are going to end up feeling like I have to choose one or the other... by not care collaborating, we're not giving them the information to then turn around and make an informed decision

From the talk — Matt Harrington

Harrington is honest about how caregivers often decide. He says they will probably go with the provider who has the best people skills. Or they will go with the simpler option. They may pick the one that fits what they already expected. That is not always the one that is best for their child.

He does not blame caregivers for this. He notes that clinicians spent two years in grad school learning to weigh these choices. They also spent 2,000 hours in supervision. Caregivers cannot be expected to do that same analysis alone. So if providers work in isolation, the family's choice looks free but is not well informed.

The clinician's role: inform, then step back#

Harrington sums up the idea in one line. He says shared decision-making is meant to serve the family, not the clinician.

Shared decision-making supports autonomy, not by us making decisions, but for the client and the caregiver

From the talk — Matt Harrington

This line flips a common habit. Some clinicians treat teamwork as a way to win support for their own plan. Harrington says that is the wrong goal. He says clinicians should not go into conversations trying to win. They should go in trying to enhance the plan.

He lists a few habits that go along with this. Use transparent data, which means data others can see and check. Keep an ROI in place, which stands for release of information. Respect scope of practice, which means each provider stays within their training.

His example is simple. A behavior plan covers many areas. Another provider may have spent far more time on one area than the BCBA, or Board Certified Behavior Analyst, has. It would make little sense to ignore that other provider's input. When providers share what they know, the family gets the full picture. Then the family can make the choice that is truly theirs.

Where the speakers agree#

These four talks come from very different settings. Grief work, team care, child rights, and personal values do not often share a stage. Yet the speakers do not disagree about autonomy. Each one builds on the same core idea.

Wilder defines autonomy as informed and uncoerced choice. Lund shows how to inform a grieving adult and then accept their answer. Harrington shows how to inform a caregiver so their choice is real. Catanese and Abdel show how to protect a person's choices about their own body.

They do differ in focus. Lund and Harrington spend most of their time on the "informed" part. Catanese and Abdel spend more time on the "uncoerced" part, especially touch and movement. Wilder points inward and reminds us that people pressure themselves too.

None of them says autonomy means anything goes. Lund admits grief will still be hard. Catanese and Abdel accept that safety procedures sometimes happen, as long as the criteria are met. Harrington still wants providers to share expert advice. Respecting autonomy, in all four talks, means sharing what you know and trusting the person to decide.

What the research says#

Published work in behavior analysis supports the themes in these talks. Several recent papers name autonomy as a core goal for services.

One survey asked autistic people and people with related disabilities what they valued in behavioral treatment. Protecting people's autonomy was on that list (Mathur et al., 2024).

Another paper reports that some autistic advocates prefer the goal of autonomy over independence. Their reason, in the paper's words, is that "autonomy can often be achieved in cases where independence can't" (Allen et al., 2024). The same paper describes assent, an uncoerced sign that someone is willing to take part, as a related idea.

A third paper urges clinicians to truly consider individual preferences (McComas et al., 2025a). It also calls for teaching skills that build autonomy and self-determination.

A fourth paper argues that ABA should uphold autonomy, dignity, and well-being (McComas et al., 2025b). It quotes B. F. Skinner, the founder of behavior analysis, saying he wanted people "to feel freer than ever before."

FAQ#

What is respect for autonomy in ABA?

It is respect for a person's right to make informed and uncoerced decisions. Kaitlin Wilder uses this definition in her talk. In practice, it means sharing clear information and then honoring the person's answer. It applies to clients, and it also applies to their caregivers.

How can staff support autonomy for a grieving adult with IDD?

Tricia Lund suggests giving clear information about the death and any rituals. She uses a schedule of the funeral so the person can pick which parts to attend. The person can also choose not to go. Staff accept that choice as the person's own decision.

Does respect for autonomy mean never using physical prompts?

Not exactly. Pauli Catanese and Jasmine Abdel suggest asking whether a treatment unnecessarily restricts movement. Safety procedures may still be used when a person meets the set criteria. The goal is to protect a person's right to decide what happens to their body whenever possible.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch Grief Support at the Front Lines: Training Day Hab and Group Home Staff to Support Adults with IDD Through Bereavement with Tricia Lund and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert

Keep going with a free learning path

Ethics Essentials

Three free courses worth 5.5 CEUs, 4 of them ethics. Start with Matt Harrington's assent and data course, then ethical guardrails in behavior reduction, then cultural considerations in clinical practice. Each course issues its own certificate.

Start the path →3 courses · 5.5 CEUs (1.5 learning, 4 ethics) · Watch at your own pace