Evidence-Based Practice in ABA: The Three-Legged Stool

Evidence-based practice in ABA blends research, clinical expertise, and client values. Learn how BCBAs use all three to make sound treatment choices.

Key takeaway

Evidence-based practice in ABA is a way to make choices that blend research, clinical skill, and client values. It is not a list of approved treatments.

From Research to the Applied Setting: Breaking Down the Three-Legged Stool of "Evidence Based Practice"
Watch the full CEU recording

From Research to the Applied Setting: Breaking Down the Three-Legged Stool of "Evidence Based Practice"

Dr. Jessica Osos · 1 CEU · 60 min
Watch on openceu.com →

Free learning path on this topic

Child Development for Behavior Analysts

Typical development for behavior analysts. Kristen Byra's overview, then Kelly Brzak's deep dives on ages 2 to 5, 6 to 8, and 9 to 11, with milestones, common problem behaviors, and programming tips for each band.

Start the path →4 courses · 4 CEUs · Watch at your own pace

Experts who cover this

5 recordings on openceu cover evidence-based practice in ABA.

Evidence-based practice in ABA is a way to make choices that blend research, clinical skill, and client values. It is not a list of approved treatments. It is a way of thinking that you use with every client and every choice.

Many people call this idea the "three-legged stool." Each leg holds up the seat. If one leg is weak, the whole thing tips over. This page walks through each leg, the common myths, and how speakers on OpenCEU use the idea in daily work.

What evidence-based practice means in ABA#

The most common definition in behavior analysis comes from Slocum and colleagues in 2014. Penny Holloway built her talk on values around this definition. She credits Megan Miller with first showing her the article. Holloway reads the definition aloud and says it describes "the way we work."

this evidence-based practice is a decision-making process that integrates the best available evidence, clinical expertise, and client values and context.

From the talk — Penny Holloway

Look closely at the words in that line. A "decision-making process" means a series of steps you take to reach a choice. It is something you do, not something you own. The definition names three parts that must work together. The first is the best research you can find. The second is your own trained skill as a clinician. The third is what matters to the client and their family, along with their real-life setting. The short name for this idea is EBP. When BCBAs use the term, they mean all three parts together. They do not mean research alone. That one point clears up a lot of the confusion around the term.

The three-legged stool#

Dr. Jessica Osos gave a whole talk on this picture. She uses it to show how the three parts fit together.

it's a three legged stool of evidence based practice.

From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos

Osos explains each leg in turn. One leg is the best available evidence, which means going back to the research. The second leg is your own clinical expertise. The third leg is client values and context. When all three legs are there and balanced, she says, the seat on top stays stable. But if any leg is weak or missing, the stool is not safe to sit on.

She gives an example of a weak stool. What happens if a clinician relies only on research? The plan may look good on paper. But it may not fit the child, the family, or the setting. The same problem happens in the other direction. A plan built only on what a family wants may skip the science. Osos says this framework helps clinicians cut through the noise. It helps them practice in a way that is ethical, responsible, and effective.

A process, not a checklist#

Osos spends time on what evidence-based practice is not. She says some people assume it means a checklist. In that view, you pick from a list of approved treatments. If something is not on the list, you cannot use it. Osos says that view is actually the opposite of evidence-based practice.

evidence-based practice is not like a compliance exercise

From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos

A "compliance exercise" means doing something just to follow a rule. Osos points out that lists do exist. But those lists are about evidence-based interventions, meaning single treatments that have research behind them. Evidence-based practice is a bigger idea. She says it is not about memorizing or limiting yourself to certain brands of treatment.

it's best understood as a process, not a product.

From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos

Osos adds that it is not about any one or two treatments. In her words, it is really about how you think, not just what you choose. This matters for new BCBAs. It is easy to think the job is to find the "right" program and run it. Osos asks clinicians to see their whole decision path as the thing that must be evidence-based.

Why research support alone is not enough#

Osos names a second myth. Some people think that if a procedure has research support, that alone makes it the right choice. She says this is not true. A procedure with good evidence still has to match the client. It has to fit their setting and their goals. Evidence alone does not make a treatment evidence-based practice.

Osos also warns about labels. She says not everything called "affirming" or "natural" is evidence-based. Some people use these hot-button words to stir up feelings. But they may not have looked at the research behind the claim. A label is not proof.

She makes a careful point about the third leg too. Respecting client values does not mean accepting every viewpoint without question. This is most true when a viewpoint is shaped by false information. A clinician can honor what a family cares about. They can also share what the research shows. Osos says the larger decision-making framework helps ground clinicians in these hard moments. It gives them a way to weigh research, skill, and values together, so no single voice wins by default.

Clinical expertise: your judgment counts#

The second leg is clinical expertise. This means the skills and judgment you build through training and practice. Penny Holloway is clear that clinicians should not just copy what a study did.

we're not just going to follow the articles to the T, we are going to include our knowledge, our judgments, our critical reasoning

From the talk — Penny Holloway

Holloway lists what this leg includes. She names knowledge, judgment, and critical reasoning. She also names reading the graphs and making data-based decisions. That means you look at your client's progress data and let it guide your next step. A study can tell you what worked for a group. Your data tells you what is working for this child, right now.

Holloway still starts with the science. She says the evidence and the articles guide her practice. But she treats the research as a starting point, not a script. Her own training shapes how she uses it. For example, she talks about being mindful when using extinction, which means no longer reinforcing a problem behavior. She credits a Megan Miller webinar for shaping how she thinks about it. This is clinical expertise at work. The research says a method works. Your judgment decides how and when to use it with care.

Client values and context#

The third leg is client values and context. Holloway calls her approach "values-based practice." She says she did not invent it. She points back to the Slocum article as her guide.

Holloway names many things that belong in this leg. She includes the client's and the parent's point of view. She includes their values and their priorities. She also names their context, their hopes, and their culture. Each of these can change what a good plan looks like. Two children with the same skill gap may need different plans. One family may care most about mealtime. Another may care most about bedtime or school.

Dr. Jessica Osos ties this leg to two ideas. She says a balanced stool helps make goals "socially meaningful and feasible." Socially meaningful means the goal matters in the person's real life. Feasible means the family can actually carry it out. A goal can be backed by strong research and still fail if the family cannot use it at home. That is why this leg is not optional. It is one of the three supports that keep the whole practice standing.

What counts as evidence?#

Kristen Byra raises a question many clinicians skip. What does "evidence-based" even mean?

And what do they mean by evidence-based? Evidence-based is not synonymous with there's a published article on it.

From the talk — Kristen Byra

Byra points clinicians to the CAPTAIN website. She says all its resources are free. It covers 28 evidence-based practices, based on a 2020 review. Each one has a free learning module. Byra notes you probably cannot earn CEUs for them. But she says they are a good refresher. They also help supervisors teach these topics to people earning their hours. The site has printable job aids and downloads too.

Byra walks through how the review picked its studies. It used set rules for what to include and leave out. It looked at where each study came from. It used peer-reviewed journals, which means other experts checked the work before it was printed. It did not use dissertations or conference talks. Byra says those go through different levels of review. The review also only used studies in English. It looked at the type of treatment, the outcomes, the study design, and who took part. After that, the studies went through a quality check. So one article is not enough. A practice earns the label only after many good studies pass careful review.

Using evidence-based practice to pick treatment goals#

Dr. Jessica Osos also teaches about writing treatment plans that hold up with insurers. In those talks, she shows the three legs at work when picking goals, which she calls targets.

In selecting these targets, we also lean on the three components of evidence based practice, which is the best available research evidence, our clinical expertise, and the family's values and priorities.

From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos

Osos explains the steps around this choice. First, the clinician takes the diagnosis and assessment data. They turn that into specific behavior change needs. Each target must tie to a documented need. It must also be something behavior analytic methods can treat. Osos says targets should show up in places where the client lives, learns, and takes part.

The three legs help make sure targets are clinically sound and also matter to the family. Osos adds that each insurer sets its own rules for what care is needed. So targets also have to fit the client's plan. In her other treatment plan talk, she makes a related point. If a target does not fit neatly, clinicians should be ready to explain why it matters. Evidence-based practice gives them a clear way to make that case.

Evidence-based practice across ABA, speech, and OT#

A panel of speech, OT, and ABA providers talked about how this idea works across fields. Emily Miller, a speech-language pathologist, spoke about its place in every discipline.

evidence-based practice really is the gold standard. I just think ABA is built on this principle.

From the talk — Emily Miller

Miller also points out a real challenge. Some newer methods in speech and OT may not yet have enough research to be fully evidence-based. She says they are getting there. Evidence grows through practice, conversation, and training over time.

Theresa Praul-DeFrank, a BCBA on the same panel, named a risk on the ABA side.

BCBAs do sometimes and have been known to maybe aggressively question non-behavioral recommendations and then become no longer welcomed by the professionals that they're sitting at the table with.

From the talk — Theresa Praul-DeFrank

She points to a 2015 article by Matthew Broadhead on keeping good working relationships across fields. She says it offers a decision model for these moments. It also stresses keeping rapport strong with other team members. The panel's message is that a high bar for evidence and an open mind can go together. You can hold firm on science and still be a good teammate. If you want to hear the full panel, see A Panel on Collaboration in Practice: SLP, OT & ABA Services.

What the research says#

The published research backs the ideas the speakers share. Contreras, Hoffmann, and Slocum (2022) restate the Slocum definition as a decision process with three parts. They stress that the best evidence is not limited to a handful of set, manual-based programs, meaning rigid, step-by-step treatment packages. Instead, they say the science behind behavioral practice includes a rich body of work on complex treatments. They also frame evidence-based practice as a tool for ethical decisions.

Contreras, B. P., Hoffmann, A. N., & Slocum, T. A. (2022). Ethical Behavior Analysis: Evidence-Based Practice as a Framework for Ethical Decision Making. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 15(2), 619-634. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40617-021-00658-5

Gasiewski and colleagues (2021) compare ABA and occupational therapy. They note that ABA has been rooted in evidence-based practice since the field began. It is built into the seven dimensions of ABA, the field's core traits like being measurable and socially useful. It also appears in the BACB Task List and the Ethics Code. In OT, the push is newer. Its first published paper on the topic came out in 1999.

Gasiewski, K., Weiss, M. J., Leaf, J. B., & Labowitz, J. (2021). Collaboration between Behavior Analysts and Occupational Therapists in Autism Service Provision: Bridging the Gap. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 14(4), 1209-1222. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40617-021-00619-y

Logue and colleagues (2023) note that about 10,000 new behavior analysts joined the field in 2021 alone. Clinicians without enough training may turn to restrictive methods, meaning treatments that limit a person's freedom more than needed. This can happen even when less restrictive options exist. The authors describe a review panel that helped reduce the use of restrictive treatments in its first year.

Logue, J. J., Hustyi, K. M., Toby, L. M., & Outlaw, E. E. (2023). Promoting Ethical and Evidence-Based Practice through a Panel Review Process: A Case Study in Implementation Research. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 18(3), 861-874. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40617-023-00807-y

Jimenez-Gomez (2025) writes about staying focused on evidence during heated public debates. The advice is to act like a scientist-practitioner, meaning someone who treats their own practice as something to test and check. Do research to grow the evidence. Check your own behavior against the ethics code.

Jimenez-Gomez, C. (2025). Evidence-Based Practice in the Age of Culture Wars: Challenges for Culturally Responsive Applied Behavior Analysis. Perspectives on Behavior Science, 48(3), 633-640. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40614-025-00458-0

FAQ#

Is evidence-based practice the same as using an evidence-based intervention? No. An evidence-based intervention is one treatment with strong research behind it. Evidence-based practice is the larger process of choosing and using treatments. Dr. Jessica Osos says it blends research with your clinical skill and the client's values. A treatment with good research still has to fit the person in front of you.

Does one published study make a method evidence-based? No. Kristen Byra says evidence-based is not the same as having a published article. Reviews like the one behind the CAPTAIN website use strict rules. They pick studies from peer-reviewed journals and check the design, outcomes, and quality. Only methods that pass these checks across many studies earn the label.

What should a BCBA do when another provider suggests a method without much research? Emily Miller notes that some newer speech and OT methods are still building their evidence. Theresa Praul-DeFrank warns that pushing back too hard can cost a BCBA their seat at the table. She suggests a decision model from Matthew Broadhead to guide these talks. Then tie the idea back to the research, your data, and the family's goals.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch From Research to the Applied Setting: Breaking Down the Three-Legged Stool of "Evidence Based Practice" with Dr. Jessica Osos and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert

Keep going with a free learning path

Child Development for Behavior Analysts

Typical development for behavior analysts. Kristen Byra's overview, then Kelly Brzak's deep dives on ages 2 to 5, 6 to 8, and 9 to 11, with milestones, common problem behaviors, and programming tips for each band.

Start the path →4 courses · 4 CEUs · Watch at your own pace