Barriers Assessment: Finding What Blocks Learning
The VB-MAPP Barriers Assessment scores 24 obstacles to learning from 0 to 4. Learn how to score it, avoid common errors, and use it with caregivers.
Key takeaway
The barriers assessment is part of the VB-MAPP, short for the Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program. It finds 24 possible obstacles to a child's learning.
Mastering the VB-MAPP: A Deep Dive into the Milestones, Barriers, and Transitions Assessments
Free learning path on this topic
Child Development for Behavior Analysts
Typical development for behavior analysts. Kristen Byra's overview, then Kelly Brzak's deep dives on ages 2 to 5, 6 to 8, and 9 to 11, with milestones, common problem behaviors, and programming tips for each band.
Experts who cover this
2 recordings on openceu cover barriers assessment.
- Featured talk1 Learning CEU
Mastering the VB-MAPP: A Deep Dive into the Milestones, Barriers, and Transitions Assessments
Dr. Jessica OsosCopper Consulting Group
The barriers assessment identifies 24 potential obstacles to learning (e.g., prompt dependency, defective mands) scored 0-4 for severity, with 'defective'…
- 1 Learning CEU
Child Development Deep Dive: Early Childhood (2-5 year olds)
Kelly BrzakThe Behaviorist Bookclub
Kelly singles out the barriers assessment inside VB-MAPP as an underused tool, noting many clinicians own a VB-MAPP kit but have never opened this section, and…
On this page · 10 sections▾
The barriers assessment is part of the VB-MAPP, short for the Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program. It finds 24 possible obstacles to a child's learning. Each barrier gets a score from 0 to 4, where 0 means no problem and 4 means a severe problem.
The VB-MAPP has three parts. They are the milestones assessment, the barriers assessment, and the transition assessment. The milestones part shows what skills a child has. The barriers part shows what might be getting in the way. This page walks through how the barriers part works, how to score it well, and what research says about it.
What the barriers assessment looks for#
Dr. Jessica Osos explains that the barriers assessment covers 24 possible obstacles to learning. Two examples she names are prompt dependency and defective mands. Prompt dependency means a child waits for an adult's help before acting, even when they know the skill. A mand is a request, like asking for a snack or a toy. A defective mand skill means requesting is weak or not working well.
Osos says the goal is to answer two questions. First, does each barrier exist for this child? Second, how strong is it? Some barriers are small bumps. Others can stall progress across many skills. Knowing which is which helps you choose where to spend teaching time.
The list includes behavior items, too. The very first barrier on the form is negative behaviors. Other items cover skill areas that are not developing as they should. Together, the 24 items give a wide view of what slows a child down. That view is different from a skills list. A skills list says what a child can do. The barriers list says why learning might be hard.
How the 0 to 4 scale works#
Every barrier uses the same basic scale. Osos describes it simply.
you're scoring each barrier on a scale of zero to four. Zero is going to be it's not a problem at all. Four is going to be it's a severe problem.
From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos
The general scoring guide sits right under the title on the form. Osos calls it a quick reference. It reminds you of the big picture as you work through the page.
But she warns against stopping there. Each barrier has its own scoring guide with its own wording. For the negative behaviors item, you read each scoring option for that barrier. Then you pick the one that best fits the child. The general scale is a summary. The item-level guide is what you actually score from.
This matters because "severe" can mean different things for different barriers. A behavior barrier and a weak skill area are not the same kind of problem. The item guides keep scores fair and consistent across very different barriers. They also make it easier for two team members to land on the same score.
Scoring the defective skill domains#
Osos points out that 8 of the 24 barriers are about defective skill domains. A domain is just one area of skill. The eight are mand, tact, echoic, imitation, match-to-sample, listener, intraverbal, and social skills.
Here is a short plain-English key. A tact is a label, like saying "dog" when you see a dog. An echoic is repeating what someone else says. Imitation is copying someone's actions. Match-to-sample means matching items that go together, like two of the same picture. Listener skills are about following what others say. An intraverbal is answering a question or keeping up a back-and-forth talk.
The key point Osos makes is about what "defective" means here.
When you're just scoring the defective skills, it's really referring to, is that skill domain defective in comparison to the other domains?
From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos
So you are not asking whether the child has the skill at all. You are asking whether this one area lags behind the child's other areas. Osos notes that the scoring guide says this directly. It is easy to miss if you only glance at the general 0 to 4 scale.
A common scoring mistake to avoid#
Osos describes a mistake she sees often. People get comfortable with the general scale. Then they move through the defective skill items quickly. The child has no manding skills, so they score it severe. The child has no tacting skills, so that is severe too. They keep going. Soon all eight defective domain items have a 4.
According to Osos, that is not how the items work. A child who scores very low on the milestones assessment may simply not have many skills yet. That does not mean every domain is defective. The question is always about one area compared with the others.
Think about what all 4s would tell you. If every domain scores the same, the scores no longer point anywhere. You lose the very thing this section is meant to show. A good score pattern highlights the one or two areas that are lagging most. That points you toward a clear teaching target.
The fix is simple. Read the item guide every time, even if you have scored the form before. Ask, "Is this area weaker than this child's other areas?" Then score from there.
Using barriers and milestones together#
Osos stresses that the two assessments are linked. She puts it this way.
often the absence of skills and the presence of barriers are closely related.
From the talk — Dr. Jessica Osos
In other words, missing skills and learning barriers tend to show up together. That is why Osos does not treat either tool alone as the full picture. Looking at only one can give you half the story.
Osos says that comparing and using both assessments gives a clearer picture of the child. The milestones results show where the child is. The barriers results help explain why progress might be slow. Used side by side, they help you build a plan that teaches new skills and lowers what is blocking them.
This does not mean the two tools measure the same thing. The research section below shows they may behave quite differently. But in daily practice, Osos treats them as partners. Each one helps you read the other.
An underused part of the kit#
Kelly Brzak raises a practical point. Many clinicians own the VB-MAPP but skip the barriers section. She asks her audience whether they have ever used it.
You may have the VB map and have never opened to this part of the assessment.
From the talk — Kelly Brzak
Brzak challenges people to look at the VB-MAPP again, even if they do not like it. She says it holds very valuable resources for work with young children. Her talk focuses on early childhood, roughly ages 2 to 5. For that group, knowing what blocks learning can be just as useful as knowing what skills are present.
Brzak also asks those who dislike the VB-MAPP to share why. She does not push the tool as perfect. Her point is narrower. If you already have the kit, the barriers section is a resource you have already paid for. It makes sense to try it before you write it off.
Running it with caregivers#
Brzak suggests a simple way to use the barriers assessment. You can go through it with the child's caregiver. Or you can complete it after you have worked with the child for a while.
This identifies a lot of barriers to learning. And by simply running through this with the child's caregiver or after you've worked with them for a while, you can really help yourself focus on reducing some of these barriers to learning for your individual child.
From the talk — Kelly Brzak
Both routes make sense. Caregivers see the child across many settings and many hours. They may notice barriers that never show up in a short session. Waiting until you know the child also helps. You will have seen the child on good days and hard days.
Brzak's focus is on the individual child. The goal is not just a score. It is a short list of barriers to work on for this one learner. She also shares a quick yes or no checklist she made herself. It asks caregivers to check the actions their child engages in. It is not part of the VB-MAPP, but it shows the same idea in a lighter form.
Not a one-and-done tool#
Brzak makes a broader point about all assessments. She says assessment tools are meant to help us scaffold learning for the child. To scaffold means to give support in steps, then pull it back as skills grow.
She adds that assessments do not have to be one and done. That fits the barriers assessment well. A barrier that scores a 3 today may drop to a 1 after months of good teaching. A new barrier may show up as demands get harder. Running the form again lets you see those shifts.
Repeat use also turns the assessment into a progress check. If you target prompt dependency, the barrier score should move over time. If it does not, that is a signal to change the plan. In this way, the barriers assessment can guide both where you start and how you adjust.
If you want more on how this fits early childhood development, see Child Development Deep Dive: Early Childhood (2-5 year olds).
What the research says#
Research on the barriers assessment is mixed. Some studies support its use. Others raise real questions about how well it measures what it claims.
A national panel of 13 experts rated the milestones, the early echoic skills assessment, and the barriers assessment (Padilla & Akers, 2021). They checked content validity, meaning whether the items cover the right things. The panel found moderate to strong support overall. Still, some areas had limited or conflicting support, and a few domains may not be fully covered by their items.
A study titled "Inter-Rater Agreement for the Milestones and Barriers Assessments of the VB-MAPP" put this to the test. Two raters scored 32 children with autism on their own. Agreement on the total barriers score was moderate. But most single barrier domains showed poor agreement. The authors say high reliability for single domains should not be assumed. This connects to Osos's warnings. Careful use of each item guide may help raters agree more.
A study titled "Convergent and Discriminant Validity of the VB-MAPP and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales" looked at 235 children with autism. The Vineland is a separate, widely used tool that rates everyday skills and behavior problems. Barriers scores showed no significant link to the Vineland's problem behavior scores. The authors say this questions the barriers assessment as a measure of maladaptive behavior. Maladaptive behavior means behavior that gets in the way of daily functioning.
On the other side, a study of 142 toddlers with autism used the barriers assessment to track change. Toddlers who got natural environment teaching, alone or with discrete trial teaching, showed fewer barrier behaviors over time.
FAQ#
How many barriers does the VB-MAPP barriers assessment cover? It covers 24 possible barriers to learning. Examples include prompt dependency, negative behaviors, and eight defective skill domains such as mand and tact.
Should a child with very few skills score 4 on every defective domain item? No. Dr. Jessica Osos explains that these items compare one skill area with the child's other areas. A child with few skills overall is not defective in every domain.
Who should help complete the barriers assessment? Kelly Brzak suggests running through it with the child's caregiver. You can also complete it after you have worked with the child for a while.
Turn this topic into a CEU
You just studied this. Now get credit for it.
Watch Mastering the VB-MAPP: A Deep Dive into the Milestones, Barriers, and Transitions Assessments with Dr. Jessica Osos and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.
Keep going with a free learning path
Child Development for Behavior Analysts
Typical development for behavior analysts. Kristen Byra's overview, then Kelly Brzak's deep dives on ages 2 to 5, 6 to 8, and 9 to 11, with milestones, common problem behaviors, and programming tips for each band.
