Scope of Competence: What a BCBA Can Do Well

Scope of competence is the set of skills one behavior analyst can do well. Learn how it differs from scope of practice and how to grow it ethically.

Key takeaway

Scope of competence is the set of tasks one behavior analyst can do well and safely. It is based on their own education, training, supervised experience, and credentials.

Scaling Influence- Coaches
Watch the full CEU recording

Scaling Influence- Coaches

Mellanie Page · 1 CEU · 69 min
Watch on openceu.com →

Free learning path on this topic

Culturally Responsive Practice

Makenzie Sandler's three-part series on culturally responsive practice, each worth an ethics CEU. Cultural competence in clinical work, unconscious bias and values, then culture across teams and systems using OBM.

Start the path →3 courses · 3 ethics CEUs · Watch at your own pace

Experts who cover this

24 recordings on openceu cover scope of competence.

Scope of competence is the set of tasks one behavior analyst can do well and safely. It is based on their own education, training, supervised experience, and credentials. It is personal. Two BCBAs (Board Certified Behavior Analysts) with the same license can have very different scopes of competence.

The BACB (the Behavior Analyst Certification Board, which certifies behavior analysts) requires you to work only inside that scope. Its ethics code also asks you to keep checking it and to grow it with care. This page covers what scope of competence means, how to judge your own, and where experts see the rules a little differently.

Scope of practice vs. scope of competence#

These two terms sound alike, but they mean different things. Scope of practice is what the whole profession is allowed to do. Scope of competence is what you, as one person, can do well. Dr. Clelia Sigaud puts it simply. The profession sets the outer fence. Your own skills sit somewhere inside it.

She gives clear examples. Consulting on classroom behavior and treating feeding disorders are inside the behavior analyst's scope of practice. Surgery, flying planes, and giving legal or money advice are not. But even inside the fence, no single person can do everything.

Of course, our scope of competence will always be smaller than scope of practice. From the talk — Dr. Clelia Sigaud

Sigaud notes this is true for every field. People are smart and hard working, but no one masters every task a profession allows. Claudia, a presenter in a separate talk on school collaboration, makes a related point. She says professionals "just don't have that kind of time" to learn every setting and population. So your scope of competence might include early intervention or adult residential care, but not both. Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin gives another example. One BCBA may feel ready to treat severe self-injury, while another has only worked with milder cases.

What the ethics code actually says#

The rule lives in BACB ethics code 1.05, "Practicing within scope of competence." Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin reads the full text in her talk. It is worth reading slowly, because each part does work.

behavior analysts practice only within their identified scope of competence. They engage in professional activities and new areas. such as populations or procedures, only after accessing and documenting appropriate study, training, supervised experience, consultation, and or co-treatment. From the talk — Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin

Notice three things. First, the scope is "identified." You are expected to name it, not guess at it. Second, new areas are allowed. The code does not freeze you in place. It tells you how to move forward. The options are study, training, supervision, consultation, or co-treatment (working a case side by side with someone skilled in that area). Third, you must document these steps.

The code also gives a fallback. If you cannot get that support, you refer or hand off the case to an appropriate professional. Bowhers-Peutin sums it up this way. You want experience in an area, or a mentor who has it. If neither is available, you should move services to someone who is qualified.

Competence equals preparation plus performance#

The code's wording is long. Mellanie Page boils it down to a short formula she uses across several of her talks.

the way I like to simplify and boil down all of that language is competence. equals documented preparation plus demonstrated performance From the talk — Mellanie Page

Documented preparation means you have studied the topic and can show it. Think coursework, training, CEUs (continuing education units), and reading. Demonstrated performance means you have actually done the work. In her course-building talk, Page stresses that you need "some experience actually doing it, not just thinking about it." Reading about a skill is not the same as using it with real clients.

Page also warns against mixing up scope of practice and scope of competence. She says people often conflate the two. A BCBA might hear online that something is "not ABA" (applied behavior analysis, the broader science behind the profession) and stop there. But the real question is whether you personally have the preparation and the track record. Interest or passion alone does not count. Many BCBAs, she notes, have more of both than they give themselves credit for.

The building blocks: coursework, supervision, and current knowledge#

Dr. Clelia Sigaud breaks competence into parts. The first part is didactic, which means learned through teaching and study.

So, didactically, we can ask ourselves if we've had the coursework or the professional development experiences necessary to have that foundational knowledge in this area. From the talk — Dr. Clelia Sigaud

The second part is supervision. Sigaud says you need someone who is skilled in the area to teach you, watch you, and sign off. That sign-off can be formal, as in fieldwork. It can also be less formal, as in a consult. Either way, a skilled person must judge your work.

Claudia, speaking in a different talk on competence, makes a similar point using her own example. Sleep is not an area where she feels competent to treat clients. She has done a little of it in supervision, but she is not well read in the current sleep research. If she wanted to add sleep to her scope, she says the first step would be reading the most relevant studies. Then she would need supervised practice where she shows she can do it well.

The third part is staying current. A skill learned ten years ago may not match what the research says today. That is why competence needs regular upkeep, not just a one-time check.

A step-by-step path to independent work#

In her coaching talk, Mellanie Page lays out a path from new learner to skilled practitioner. It starts with foundational knowledge. Do you have the core concepts of the area? Have you had structured training, taken related CEUs, and read the research?

Next comes guided practice with feedback. Page asks if you have run a supervised case or project. Have you observed a mentor and debriefed with them? Have you reviewed plans, data, and decisions in that area? The goal is to show you tried, got feedback, and improved.

Then comes independent performance.

independent performance here means you can perform the work safely without direct oversight. From the talk — Mellanie Page

Page suggests starting small at this stage. Work with one person, one organization, or a small group. Run a pilot project or keep the scope limited. Do structured role plays. You do not have to charge money yet. Her self-check question is plain: "are my outcomes consistent and explainable?" After that comes maintenance and growth, where you keep the skill sharp and keep learning.

Competence is never finished#

Many people think a degree or a job title marks the end of learning. Mellanie Page pushes back on this idea hard.

None of us are eternally competent, right? The science is constantly evolving. And so our competence also needs to evolve with it. From the talk — Mellanie Page

She says many of us are "conditioned or convinced" that a certificate is the final level. Got the paper, so I'm competent. Got the job, so I'm competent. But in her view, nobody is competent in a "terminal way." The goal is to keep checking and keep building.

This links to ethics code 1.06, "Maintaining competence." In her talk built around the TV show The Office, Page reads this core principle as "remaining current and increasing your knowledge of best practices and advances in ABA." She jokes about Michael Scott's outdated views on a paperless world. The point is serious, though. A clinician who stops learning falls behind, just like a business that ignores change.

Patricia Lund makes the same point about grief work in people with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD). She notes that new research is starting to come out in this area. Staying relevant with it is part of keeping your competence.

Confidence and competence are not the same thing#

How sure you feel and how skilled you are can drift apart. Dr. Tyra Sellers says the ethics code requires behavior analysts to keep evaluating their scope of competence. This applies to both clinical and supervisory skills. She adds that this applies to supervisees and trainees too.

There's risk. There's risk if you're overconfident, which is what this graph is showing. But there's also risk if you're underconfident because you're unlikely to take risks to try some things. From the talk — Dr. Tyra Sellers

Overconfidence can lead you into work you are not ready for. Underconfidence has its own cost. You may avoid trying things you could do well. Sellers says the danger is a "mismatch across those two variables." The goal is to find the right balance.

Mellanie Page talks about the underconfident side. She says impostor syndrome (the feeling that you are a fraud despite real skill) is common in ABA. She sees it as a sign that you care about client results. But it should not hold you back. In one meeting, she heard a clinician list years of experience and then say they were "not really like an expert." Page's view was that this was real expertise the person just did not feel comfortable naming.

Where experts disagree: refer out or reach further?#

Every speaker agrees on the core rule. Do not practice outside what you can do well. The tension is about what to do when a case lands near your edge. Some speakers stress holding the line. Others stress growing past it.

On the "hold the line" side, Sean Yocum is blunt. He says giving advice outside your trained area is "genuinely dangerous to the public." Tricia Lund warns that "damage can be done" when staff act like counselors. Claudia answers people who say, "Let's just do the best we can." She agrees the need is huge. But she doubts that working outside competence really helps, since it can put clients, clinicians, and the field at risk.

On the "reach further" side, Mellanie Page calls her own view "nontraditional."

We're told that we need to stick to our scope of competence, which I completely agree with. My nontraditional view is that we have the ownership and accountability to expand that competence. From the talk — Mellanie Page

Page worries that some BCBAs skip a step. They say "I'm not qualified" and pass the client along. Then they never research the issue so they are ready next time. Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin shares a point she credits to Contreras and colleagues.

our scope of competence should now be never limit us. It should give us insight on how to expand our skills, but again, as a BCBA, we shouldn't be limited by what our current scope of competency is. From the talk — Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin

Page goes further in a talk on building coaching offers. She says the BCBA credential itself can become "a limiter" when people get stuck on rules. Her test is simple: imagine you do not hold a BCBA. Are you competent enough to teach this?

These views are not total opposites. Page still says you must learn a skill from a mentor, literature, and data "before I go and practice it." Yocum still celebrates clinicians who are experts in their own lane. The real split is in emphasis. One camp sees referral as the safe default. The other sees referral as a starting point for growth. Sellers' warning about both overconfidence and underconfidence sits right in the middle.

Why it matters for clients, funders, and the field#

Why care so much about this rule? Claudia, the presenter of the school collaboration talk, gives three reasons. The first is the client.

When we disregard scope of practice or scope of competence, we're not performing a service for our clients that's going to be optimally helpful for them. From the talk — Claudia

The second reason is honesty. Claudia says it is "deceitful for funders, for employers" when we present ourselves as able to do things we cannot. Insurance companies and agencies pay for skilled care. They trust that the person billing has the skill.

The third reason is the field as a whole. Over time, she says, poor or dangerous work can damage the reputation of behavior analysis. One clinician's mistake can shape how families and other professions see all BCBAs.

Sean Yocum calls staying within your competence part of the "minimum standard" of the ethics code. He lists it next to not exploiting clients and protecting confidentiality. In his words, these are "not for negotiation" and "not suggestions." But he also notes that following the code is not the same as thinking ethically. The code sets the floor. Good judgment has to fill in the rest.

Grief and mental health: where the line falls#

Grief is a clear case of working near a boundary. Patricia Lund says she worried about her scope when she first studied death, grief, and loss. She is not a trained therapist.

it's not our goal to help someone process their feelings of grief. Um, that's going to be a therapist. From the talk — Patricia Lund

Lund lists what BCBAs should not do. They should not try to process feelings as a therapist would. They also cannot diagnose grief disorders, such as prolonged grief disorder. But there is still a role. BCBAs can track how often behaviors happen and how they change in form. They can share that data and push for clients to get the right care. They can also collaborate with licensed counselors.

Ethical code 1.05, you want to make sure that you're practicing within your scope of competence. If you're not a mental health practitioner, then we're not going to do mental health practitioner things. From the talk — Patricia Lund

In a talk for day program and group home staff, she draws a kind line for direct support workers. Staff worry that grief support is "not their place." She tells them they are right. But compassion is still part of the job.

You're not a counselor. I'm not asking you to be a counselor. I am asking you to be a compassionate person and respond with compassion. From the talk — Tricia Lund

Knowing the diagnosis you are treating#

Sometimes staying in scope means learning more about the people you already serve. Nicole Stewart, BCBA, makes this case for ADHD. Many behavior analysts work with clients who have ADHD. She argues they need to understand how an ADHD brain works to treat it well.

Stewart ties this to several ethics codes. One is practicing within your scope of competence. Another is providing effective treatment. A third is considering medical needs. As she puts it, "ADHD is a medical diagnosis." It has biological effects that shape how a person learns and responds.

She compares it to a doctor treating strep throat. The doctor needs to know how the infection works and which antibiotics help. In the same way, a BCBA needs to know how ADHD affects behavior. Stewart admits that neurobiology may not "feel like ABA." But she says it fits the ethics code closely.

In a related talk on shaping, Stewart asks attendees a direct question. Is ADHD currently within your scope of competence, or is it a space you want to grow into? Many said they work with this group every day. That question is a good model. It helps you name where you stand before you treat.

School settings and clear boundaries#

Schools bring their own scope questions. Dr. Kaci Ellis says behavior analysts in schools are not there to teach academics. She lists it among her key tips: "Your job is not to provide academic instruction."

I would not expect an RBT to just know how to do this because again, that's outside of our competence. We are not meant to be providing academic instruction or therefore behavioral support. From the talk — Dr. Kaci Ellis

Her example is a token-style system called "dots for motivation." Teachers should pick which problems a student works on, so the student still meets grade standards. An RBT (registered behavior technician, a front-line staff member) should not make those academic choices alone.

Ellis offers a simple way to prevent problems. Before you start, build a contract or "matrix" that lists what you can do under your ethics code. Many educators do not know the BACB code. Later, if someone asks you to step outside your role, you can point back to that first meeting. You can say the task is outside your scope of competence. The contract sets clear boundaries before any conflict starts.

RBTs and the duty to speak up#

Scope of competence is not just for BCBAs. Anlara Hoskins explains how it applies to RBTs.

Next is 1.06, which really talks about ensuring competence prior to implementing any of the protocols that are in your client's treatment plan. From the talk — Anlara Hoskins

Hoskins uses an architect and a construction crew as a picture. The architect, like the BCBA, designs the plan and holds more liability. The crew, like the RBT, builds it. The BCBA needs to know the RBT can safely carry out what is asked.

The other half of this rule is self-advocacy. Say you are asked to run a procedure you have not been trained on. Hoskins says it is "incumbent upon you" to ask for more training or supervision. The same is true if a procedure confuses you or the client is not responding as expected. She ties this to the RBT code on practicing within your scope of competence. Feeling comfortable is not a luxury. It is the only way to make sure procedures are done correctly.

Supervisors: model it and refer when needed#

Supervisors carry extra weight. Dr. Tyra Sellers asks whether supervisors are teaching trainees to evaluate their own scope of competence. She says this should happen through modeling. You do it yourself, out loud, and help them through it.

Referring out is part of good modeling. Maya Griffin works in OBM (organizational behavior management, which applies behavior science to the workplace). She mostly does performance management and behavior systems analysis. She has not done behavior-based safety work. If a supervisee wanted that, she would point them to another mentor.

Because I want to practice within my competency. From the talk — Maya Griffin

Griffin adds that it is fine to have more than one mentor. Most people in OBM are not experts in every sub-area. Falon Roberson raises a similar point about ACT (acceptance and commitment therapy, a set of tools for building psychological flexibility). She notes that knowing ACT concepts is not the same as being competent to deliver ACT exercises. A supervisor who wants to use them should get extra training, consultation, or practice first.

Social media and public advice#

Online, the pull to weigh in on everything is strong. Sean Yocum sees this as a major risk.

The urge to be a public expert on everything is the single biggest ethical pitfall in social media ABA. From the talk — Sean Yocum

He gives a pointed example. A BCBA who works in early intervention should not give detailed advice on adult sex education or complex OBM. That is true even if those topics are trending. Yocum applies the rule to himself as well. He will not argue with occupational therapists or speech-language pathologists about research in their own fields.

Stay in your lane or get off the platform. From the talk — Sean Yocum

His reasoning is about the audience. People who read your posts trust your credential. Advice outside your training can mislead vulnerable people. He warns against confusing "five minutes of Google searching with a decade of specialization." In his view, your expertise is "your most valuable ethical asset." Posting outside it lowers the value of that asset.

Coaching, courses, and private services#

More BCBAs now offer coaching, consulting, and online courses. Mellanie Page has spoken often about how scope of competence applies here. In her niche talk, "profession" is the first of four pillars for picking a specialty. It asks what your clinical background qualifies you to do. Page calls this your scope of competence, and says it builds trust that coaching certifications alone cannot.

She suggests a few self-check questions. What clinical experience do you have? Which populations have you worked with most? Which assessments or interventions are you expert in? What do people often ask you about?

For teaching a course, Page uses the same preparation-plus-performance test. You do not need 25 years of experience. But you do need real practice, not just ideas. In a talk on getting clients, she adds that the BACB gives direct guidance on both scope of competence and marketing. Your job is to decide whether an offer is a behavioral service or a non-behavioral one. That choice shapes how you describe it on your website and in testimonials. Her talk Beyond 1:1: The Ethical Path to Creating a Scalable Course as a BCBA walks through this framework in more detail.

Ending the guesswork#

Every clinician has hit a point where they think, "Let's just try this." Amber Feick, BCBA, admits she has felt that way too. But she says the ethics code exists so we do not have to guess.

Feick says plainly that we should not just be guessing. We should work within the scope we have and keep up continual evaluation of our services.

Feick links scope of competence to quality checks. Are we doing what we said we would do? Do we have a way to track it? Science, she says, is not "throw it into the air and see." It means using methods that are backed by evidence and fit your defined role.

This gives a useful test for any case. If you notice you are guessing, that is a signal. You may be near the edge of your competence. It is time to collect better data, check the research, or ask for help from someone with more skill in that area.

How to grow your scope the right way#

The speakers agree on a practical path for growth. Start by naming your current scope honestly. Write down the populations, settings, and procedures you can handle alone. Then mark the areas where you want to grow.

Next, build the knowledge. Mellanie Page points to mentors, supervisors, research, and data. She also points to the free resources the BACB offers its members. She calls CEUs "probably the most engaging way" to build skills and to refresh topics you already know. Claudia says to begin with the most relevant studies in the new area.

Then get supervised practice. Find someone skilled in the area to watch your work and give feedback. Co-treatment is another option the code names. Keep records of every step, since the code asks you to document your study and training.

Finally, start small and keep checking. Page suggests one client or a pilot project first. Ask if your results are steady and easy to explain. Dr. Allison Bowhers-Peutin adds that agencies and clinical directors also have a role. They can help BCBAs grow their scope ahead of time, instead of scrambling when a hard case shows up.

What the research says#

Published work supports what these speakers teach. Brodhead and colleagues wrote a key paper calling for more discussion of this topic. They define scope of competence as tasks a practitioner can do "at a certain criterion level." One example is running a functional analysis accurately and safely. They also noted that the field had talked far more about scope of practice (Brodhead et al., 2018).

A later review of state licensure laws made the contrast plain. All behavior analysts work under one scope of practice. But each one generally has a different scope of competence. Scope of practice is what you could do. Scope of competence is what you can actually do (Morris et al., 2024).

Other research points to real gaps. Many behavior analysts do not get enough training and case oversight for clients with severe challenging behavior. Without that support, they may turn to more restrictive procedures when gentler options exist. One organization built a procedural review panel to address this, and it helped reduce restrictive treatment (Logue et al., 2023). A paper on "humble behaviorism" adds that a BCBA credential does not make you an expert in other content areas. Behavior analysts should lean on speech-language pathologists, occupational therapists, and other experts to serve clients well (Kirby et al., 2022).

FAQ#

What is the difference between scope of practice and scope of competence? Scope of practice is everything the behavior analysis profession is allowed to do. Scope of competence is the smaller set of tasks you personally can do well. Your scope of competence always fits inside the scope of practice.

Which BACB ethics code covers scope of competence? Code 1.05 covers practicing within your scope of competence. Code 1.06 covers maintaining your competence over time. For RBTs, the RBT ethics code includes a similar rule about ensuring competence before running a protocol.

Can a BCBA expand their scope of competence? Yes. The code allows new areas after you get and document study, training, supervised experience, consultation, or co-treatment. If you cannot get that support, you should refer the client to a qualified professional.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch Scaling Influence- Coaches with Mellanie Page and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert

Keep going with a free learning path

Culturally Responsive Practice

Makenzie Sandler's three-part series on culturally responsive practice, each worth an ethics CEU. Cultural competence in clinical work, unconscious bias and values, then culture across teams and systems using OBM.

Start the path →3 courses · 3 ethics CEUs · Watch at your own pace