Coercion in ABA: What It Is and Why It Harms

Coercion means using threats or power to force behavior. Learn how it harms clients and staff, and how BCBAs keep it out of programs and supervision.

Key takeaway

Coercion is getting someone to act by using threats, fear, or power over them, instead of real choice. In behavior analysis, it often looks like pressure that leaves a person worse off if they say no.

Child Development Deep Dive: Middle Childhood (6-8 year olds)
Watch the full CEU recording

Child Development Deep Dive: Middle Childhood (6-8 year olds)

Kelly Brzak, MS, BCBA · 1 CEU · 60 min
Watch on openceu.com →
Free learning pathStep 3 of 4 in Child Development for Behavior AnalystsSee the whole path →

Experts who cover this

4 recordings on openceu cover coercion in ABA.

Coercion is getting someone to act by using threats, fear, or power over them, instead of real choice. In behavior analysis, it often looks like pressure that leaves a person worse off if they say no.

Coercion can show up in client programs, in staff supervision, and even in business. The experts on this page agree it does real harm. They also share simple ways to replace it with choice, trust, and honest influence.

What coercion means in behavior analysis#

Behavior analysts have tried to define coercion for a long time. One helpful article by Goltz (2020) describes two ways of looking at it. The first is the pressure approach. Here, someone uses threats to push a person into doing something they do not want to do. The second is the enforcement approach. Here, someone uses a gap in power to shrink another person's choices.

A key idea is the difference between a threat and an offer. A threat says, "Do this, or things get worse for you." An offer says, "Do this, and things get better for you." The person receiving an offer can still freely say yes or no. Goltz quotes an older writer who put it simply: threats coerce, but offers do not.

Goltz also suggests the definition should grow. Taking away the tools someone needs to earn good things could count as coercion. So could hidden systems that steer choices without the person's knowledge or consent. In plain terms, coercion is not only loud threats. It can also be quiet pressure that a person cannot see or escape.

Why coercion harms learners#

Dr. Camille Kolu speaks about coercion in her talk on trauma-informed care. She is clear that the costs are high. She notes that coercion is a big enough topic that she teaches a separate workshop on it with Dr. Evelyn Gold. In her trauma talk, she lists what coercion does to a person's body and behavior.

Effects of coercion are awful. Somebody's experiencing arousal, emotional responding, biological changes, long-term physical outcomes.

From the talk — Dr. Camille Kolu

Arousal here means the body's stress response. It is the racing heart and tense muscles of feeling unsafe. Dr. Kolu explains that these effects do not stay small. She says a person's repertoires become restricted. A repertoire is the full set of skills and behaviors a person can use. When coercion is common, that set gets smaller and more rigid. The person has fewer ways to respond to the world.

This matters a great deal for autistic clients. Dr. Kolu ties this topic back to the overlap between autism and trauma. People who already face higher risk deserve care that does not add new harm.

Coercion can look effective, and that is the trap#

Dr. Kolu raises a point many clinicians may not want to hear. Coercion can seem to work. She speaks to the person who thinks, "Well, at least it's effective." Her answer is honest. She admits that it is effective, but not in the way you want.

She says coercion transforms the function of your intended treatment effects. In plain words, the behavior change you hoped for turns into something else. You may get compliance today. But you also lose some of the good outcomes your treatment was meant to produce. And you add harmful ones on top.

You're conditioning new stimuli and settings and people as aversive and basically giving classes or giving rise to new classes of behavior with that avoidance and escape function.

From the talk — Dr. Camille Kolu

Aversive means unpleasant, something a person wants to get away from. Conditioning means learning by pairing. So the therapy room, the materials, and even the therapist can start to feel bad to the client. Once that happens, the client learns new ways to escape or avoid them. This is the opposite of what good treatment should build. A child who runs from the table has not learned the lesson. They have learned that the table is unsafe.

Keeping coercion out of programming#

Kelly Brzak is a Board Certified Behavior Analyst (BCBA). She makes this point with strong words in her talk on children ages 6 to 8. She repeats it on purpose so no one misses it.

Our programming needs to be absent of coercion and its tactics.

From the talk — Kelly Brzak

Programming means the goals and teaching plans a BCBA writes for a client. Brzak warns against goals that exist only for the adult's sake. She describes these as hoops.

We don't want to be programming hoops that kids are asked to jump through just for the sake of it.

From the talk — Kelly Brzak

Brzak links this to how children grow at this age. Kids from 6 to 8 start to talk about abstract ideas. They can hold a real back-and-forth conversation. Brzak notes that our closest relationships often include this kind of dialogue. So she asks clinicians to think ethically about how to bring out the child's own voice. She contrasts that with a voice that adults fabricate, or make up for the child. A scripted answer is not the same as the child speaking for themselves. She sums it up in three short words: "No means no."

Honoring a child's request to stop#

Brzak then gets practical. She says we must honor mands for removal, delay, or alternatives. A mand is a request. So a mand for removal is the child asking for something to stop or go away. A mand for delay asks for more time. A mand for an alternative asks for something different.

She walks through real moments. What if the child says, "Leave me alone"? Brzak suggests setting a timer and shaping the mand. Shaping means slowly building a better version of a behavior over time. What if the child yells, "I don't want to work with you"? Brzak says that if it is the first time the child has asked on their own, she would probably honor it.

But she adds a careful limit. She would not walk away for 45 minutes. That would be a huge dose of negative reinforcement. Negative reinforcement means a behavior grows stronger because something unwanted is taken away. Her point is balance. We want to honor the child's voice. We also want to teach in a way that keeps learning going. Respecting a "no" does not mean giving up on the child. It means treating their words as real.

Real choices versus sham choices#

In her talk on children ages 9 to 11, Brzak returns to coercion. She says it can quietly seep into practice if we are not careful. Her goal is to avoid power struggles. A power struggle is a tug-of-war where adult and child each try to win.

Make sure you train your technicians to offer and honor choices.

From the talk — Kelly Brzak

Brzak also points to a hidden driver of coercion: workload pressure. She imagines a supervisor handing a technician a list of 50 trials an hour. That target can push the technician toward a "do as I say" style with the child. The tech wants to hit the number. The child's wishes get pushed aside.

So steer clear of sham choices. Reduce the level of demands.

From the talk — Kelly Brzak

A sham choice is a fake choice. It looks like the child gets to pick, but every option leads to the same demand. Children notice this. Real choices give the child true control over part of the session. Lowering the number of demands also lowers the pressure. Both steps help keep the session cooperative instead of forced.

Coercion in supervision#

Coercion is not only about clients. Mellanie Page shows how it can enter the way BCBAs supervise RBTs. An RBT is a Registered Behavior Technician, the staff member who often works directly with clients. In her talk built around the TV show The Office, Page notices fear being used to control people.

there was a little bit of fear created or contrived in the office scenario. And sometimes without us really recognizing it, we may be using fear or some guilt to shape BT behavior.

From the talk — Mellanie Page

Page gives an example of what this sounds like. A supervisor might say the client will not respond, or will not make progress, unless the tech does it one exact way. That message uses guilt to push behavior. It may get quick results. But it puts the weight of a child's progress on the tech's fear.

Page offers a better path. She says there are ways to increase mentorship and influence. One foundation is building trust and what she calls relational depth. She credits this idea to a mentor who uses relational currency to build strong work relationships. In plain terms, people follow leaders they trust. Good supervision uses that trust instead of fear. Page also lists teaching tools that support this, like video modeling, job aids, and fidelity data.

Power, authority, and the ethics code#

Nicole Parks brings coercion into a different setting: marketing and business. She reminds BCBAs that the ethics code speaks to this directly.

behavior analysts do not abuse their power or authority by coercing or exploiting persons over whom they have authority.

From the talk — Nicole Parks

Parks says behavior science still applies when you coach or train others in business. You should still collect data and check whether people meet their goals. She also stresses that consent is not a one-time event. It does not end when someone signs a service contract. Informed consent means a person truly understands the risks and benefits of what they are agreeing to.

Parks is careful not to treat all business as bad. She says marketing is not the villain.

Sales and thinking about sales is not necessarily coercion.

From the talk — Nicole Parks

Being visible is not exploiting people. Making money is not unethical. The problem, Parks explains, is being misleading. You can sell in a coercive or manipulative way. Her goal is to help BCBAs build honest businesses that also make a profit.

Where the line falls#

The speakers here do not disagree with each other. They each look at coercion from a different angle. Dr. Kolu focuses on harm to the person. Brzak focuses on daily programming with children. Page looks at supervision, and Parks looks at business and ethics. Together, they point to the same idea. Coercion uses power or fear to remove real choice.

Still, each speaker draws a careful line. Brzak honors a child's "no" but does not reward it with 45 minutes away from work. Parks says selling is fine, but misleading people is not. Page does not say supervisors should stop giving feedback. She says feedback should come from trust, not guilt.

This fits the threat-versus-offer idea from Goltz (2020). An offer makes someone's situation better and leaves them free to decline. A threat makes saying no costly. Asking "Would this person be worse off if they refused?" is a simple test. If the answer is yes, coercion may be present. Graber (2024) adds a warning for clinicians too. Even pushing hard against a client's choice of a non-evidence-based treatment may become coercive.

What the research says#

Several articles support and extend what the speakers teach. Goltz (2020) suggests widening the definition of coercion. It could include removing the resources a person needs to earn reinforcement. It could also include hidden choice systems used without a person's consent.

Luna, Rapp, and Brogan (2022) apply the idea in juvenile justice settings. Their lab used Goltz's lens on coercion. They describe interventions that help staff start more positive interactions with youth. These staff changes aim to improve student behavior in turn.

Graber (2024) writes about a case involving spelling to communicate. He says behavior analysts should not provide non-evidence-based treatments themselves. But too much pressure on clients to avoid them may be a form of coercion. It may also hurt clients' trust in behavior analysts.

Shpall and Kuhn (2026) studied training for BCBAs on assent withdrawal. Assent is a client's agreement to take part freely and without coercion. After training with instruction, modeling, and feedback, all participants learned to spot and respond to assent withdrawal.

  • Goltz, S. M. (2020). On Power and Freedom: Extending the Definition of Coercion. Perspectives on Behavior Science, 43(1), 137-156. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40614-019-00240-z
  • Luna, O., Rapp, J. T., & Brogan, K. M. (2022). Improving Juvenile Justice Settings by Decreasing Coercion: One Lab's Perspectives from Behind the Fence. Perspectives on Behavior Science, 45(1), 295-325. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40614-022-00325-2
  • Graber, A. (2024). Ethics Dialogue: Spelling to Communicate – Reply by Abraham Graber. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 18(3), 888-891. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40617-024-01022-z
  • Shpall, C. & Kuhn, M. (2026). Evaluation of Assent Withdrawal Training for Board Certified Behavior Analysts: Impact on Competency and Clinical Practices. Behavioral Interventions, 41(1). https://doi.org/10.1002/bin.70080

To learn more about trust-based supervision, see Dunder Mifflin's Guide to BCBA Supervision: Lessons from The Office.

FAQ#

Is coercion ever okay if it gets results? The experts here say no. Dr. Camille Kolu admits coercion can seem effective. But she explains it adds harm and teaches clients to escape and avoid people and places. Those costs outweigh quick compliance.

How can I tell a real choice from a sham choice? A real choice lets the person truly control the outcome. A sham choice offers options that all lead to the same demand. Kelly Brzak advises training technicians to offer real choices and honor them.

Can supervisors be coercive with staff? Yes. Mellanie Page notes that supervisors may use fear or guilt without noticing. Saying a client will not progress unless a tech complies is one example. Building trust and mentorship is a better approach.

Turn this topic into a CEU

You just studied this. Now get credit for it.

Watch Child Development Deep Dive: Middle Childhood (6-8 year olds) with Kelly Brzak, MS, BCBA and earn 1 free BCBA CEU. Detailed certificate, delivered the moment you finish.

Watch and earn the CEU →Free account · No card · detailed cert
Free learning pathStep 3 of 4 in Child Development for Behavior AnalystsSee the whole path →