When the Foundations Are Right: Unlocking Advanced Verbal Repertoires

Free · 1 Learning CEU · certificate included

FreeDetailed certificate included
Register free & watch now

Claim your certificate as soon as you pass the quiz.

alphabeePRO1 Learning CEU60 minOn-demand

Presented by Dana Pettus

When the Foundations Are Right: Unlocking Advanced Verbal Repertoires

About this CEU

When learners have been taught with precise conditional discrimination and established speaker–listener mediation, advanced verbal repertoires become significantly more teachable. In this final installment of the series on engineering generative verbal behaviour, we examine how the tools introduced in the previous sessions can be systematically scaffolded to establish more complex skills. Question discrimination, autoclitic frames (e.g., “because I see…,” “because I hear…”), and verbal mediation function as critical sources of stimulus control for event description, recall of past events, and simple inferencing. Building on previously established discrimination and mediation repertoires, participants will analyze how learners move from tacting compound stimuli to recalling events in the absence of the original stimulus conditions and explaining the controlling variables for their responses. Emphasis will be placed on sequencing instruction so that recall and visually or intraverbally based inferences emerge from cumulative stimulus control rather than isolated task training. Applications will focus on strengthening event description, tacting sources of control, and establishing simple inferential responding. The session will briefly outline how these repertoires set the stage for later complex reasoning, highlighting the cumulative impact of earlier programming decisions.

Credits

1 CEU · 60 min

From the talk

What was covered

How listing, recall, and "because I see" prompts build real inference instead of memorized answers, from Dana Pettus on OpenCEU.

  • Do not end a listing session until the learner gives at least one or two brand new answers.
  • Keep token boards indiscriminate and say "tell me some animals," never "tell me five animals."
  • When a learner stalls, ask a related question that brings more clues to mind instead of giving the answer.
  • Before you call a recall error a memory problem, check whether the learner heard the question correctly.
  • Teach "how do you know" answers like "because I see sand" before you start inference programs.
  • Stretch recall by adding verbal distractor tasks during the delay so the learner cannot just rehearse.

The Surprise Cake Problem: Why Inference Looks Easy and Is Not

Dana Pettus opened the session with a short story and one task. A girl walks into the kitchen and sees a big cake. Her name is written on it. Her family stands around the table, smiling. She covers her mouth and says, oh my gosh. The chat filled up fast with the same answer: a surprise birthday party. Then came the harder question. How did you know?

Attendees named their own clues. A cake with a name on it means a birthday. A smiling group around a table means a party. A covered mouth and a gasp mean surprise. Stacking those clues into one answer takes real work. Pettus called that work covert verbal behavior (talking inside your own head). Most adults do it without noticing.

The second example came from daily life. You walk into a meeting room and everyone is sitting quietly. You guess the meeting is starting, so you stay quiet too. If people were talking loudly, you would keep your own chat going. That is inference (a guess based on clues) steering social behavior all day.

One hour cannot cover every skill behind the cake story. So the talk focused on what comes first: listing, recall, and naming the clues behind your own answers. Learners who miss those steps get lost in social moments later.

What assumptions are you making?

From the talk — Dana Pettus

Convergent and Divergent Control: The Review That Carries the Series

Parts one and two set up two ideas this talk leans on. The first is the pure tact versus the intraverbal tact (a tact shaped partly by a question). A pure tact (naming what you see) needs no words first. You see a chair and you say chair. Most real tacts also answer a question at the same time. "What color is it?" with a blue car in view pulls for blue.

That answer has two sources of stimulus control (what makes a response happen). The question and the car both push the same word. Pettus called this convergent control (many cues, one answer). Divergent control is the flip side: one cue pulls many answers. The question "what color" can pull blue, yellow, red, or green. The sight of a green ball can pull ball, green, or small.

The second idea is simple versus complex intraverbals (verbal answers to words). A simple intraverbal has a direct history. Two plus two is four. What color is the sky? Blue. A complex intraverbal starts more of your own verbal behavior first. Ask what someone ate for breakfast on Sunday. They talk themselves through it. Sunday, I was home. I cooked. Eggs and toast.

That self talk is verbal mediation (talking to yourself to problem solve). People do it all day. You repeat a grocery list on the way to the store. You prompt yourself with continents when a list of countries dries up. You repeat and rephrase a lecture while you listen. Teaching one cue, one answer, and a reinforcer skips all of it.

You're going to prompt yourself with these subcategories.

From the talk — Dana Pettus

Listing by Category: Build Generating, Not a Memorized List

The next activity was simple: name as many cold foods as you can. Answers came fast, then slowed. Pettus also asked what people did when they got stuck. Attendees pictured the inside of a fridge or freezer. Some walked the cold aisle of a grocery store in their head. Others thought about summer food or lunches they pack.

Those strategies are why listing earns a spot in a program. Listing is practice with divergent control. It also feeds later skills. A chat about football needs several team names on hand. Inference needs it too. Naming what you see at a birthday party is what makes the cake story readable.

Listing by category is the entry level and the first target in the curriculum Pettus follows. Tell me some animals. Tell me some foods or clothes. First, the learner should tact the class of many items. They should also answer class questions fluently, mixed with other questions. A monkey is an animal. An ambulance is a vehicle.

The goal is not a stored list. Pettus wants one or two new items every time you ask. Common teaching methods work against that. Showing animal pictures and then removing them builds a set list. So does an echoic model (repeating what you hear) that you fade. A memorized list has its uses, but it is not the skill that matters.

They should be able to be generating novel exemplars.

From the talk — Dana Pettus

Reinforcing Novel Answers and Running Thematic Prompts

Two changes turn listing into problem solving practice. First, reinforce novel responding (new answers, not repeats). Do not end the activity until one or two new answers come out. Mark every good answer as you go. Fingers, check marks, or tokens all work. A repeat gets nothing. Keep trying, and the activity rolls on.

The token board must stay indiscriminate (no set number to finish). A ten token board tells the learner when work ends. So does "tell me five animals." Say "tell me some animals" instead. Keep the target fair with the 50% rule. If you can name sixteen members of a class, ask for about half. Animals can carry a higher target than clothing.

When the learner stalls, the easy move is to feed an answer. Thematic prompting (asking questions, not giving answers) is the better one. Ask a question that adds clues for the right answer. One version asks the learner to tact the class. In the demo, the learner stalled on foods, so Pettus asked what a salad is. A salad is a food. Then she asked for foods again, and broccoli and corn came out.

A second version points at a subcategory. A question about a trip to the zoo brought giraffe, then more animals. For clothing, ask what you wear when it is cold. That often brings boots, coat, hats, and mittens. Repeats still get no mark, so the learner keeps working.

She doesn't know when the end is coming.

From the talk — Dana Pettus

List and Check, Visualizing, and Harder Listing Targets

Subcategory listing comes next. Farm animals instead of animals. Vegetables instead of food. The entry bar goes up. The learner already lists by class. They also answer questions about class, location, and features. A monkey lives in the jungle. Ice cream is cold, not warm.

The strategy here is list and check. The learner lists members of the big class first. Then you check each item against the rule. In the wings demo, the learner first said horse. Pettus asked whether a horse has wings, then asked for any animals. Cat, dog, bat, horse, and tiger came out. Then they walked the list item by item. Does a cat have wings? Does a bat? Last came the real target, and seagull followed. For some learners, write the list on paper and mark each item with a check or an X.

Visualizing is the other strategy, and attendees used it on themselves. Prompt the learner to picture what is inside the fridge. At first, make it real. Open the fridge door, or show a photo of a fridge or a store aisle. Then fade to a simple cue, then to nothing at all.

Harder targets keep the skill growing. List by feature, function, and class: things you can drive, things with wings. Add parts: vehicles you buy, drinks that are hot. Add negation: animals with no legs, foods that are not hot. Add context: things in a grocery store, things you do at the beach. That last one leads straight back to the cake.

We're giving them the tools to generate the answer.

From the talk — Dana Pettus

What Recall Actually Requires: Three Parts, Not One

Recall is one of the most requested skills from families. Parents want to hear what happened at school. Pettus defined recall as answering questions about past events. It takes three parts. Being verbally present during the event. Hearing the question correctly. Problem solving your way to the answer.

Verbally present means you did some verbal behavior about the event. Listening is behavior. While you listen, you build links between new facts and old ones. When you must remember something, you do more of that on purpose. You rehearse it. You think of examples. You picture it, or you build a mnemonic.

Salient events (big, meaningful, easy to notice) do that work for you. You talk about your wedding day for years, so repetition is built in. The dress, the cake, the music, and the guests all add links. A party four years ago has far fewer of them. Many learners sit in class without engaging verbally with the teacher. You can teach great question skills and still get nothing back later.

Question discrimination (telling one question from another) is the second part. "What did you do today?" carries three demands at once. The learner must hear an action, not a person or place. They must hear "did" as past, not now or later. They must hold the window to today. A learner who answers with a trip from months ago may not have a recall problem at all. The third part is problem solving. Breakfast on Sunday starts out divergent: toast, eggs, a smoothie, nothing. Self prompts narrow it to one answer. I was home, so no restaurant food. I cooked, so nothing fancy.

The important part of recall is being verbally present in the moment that you want to recall later.

From the talk — Dana Pettus

A Beginner Recall Program and How to Build It Up

Pettus walked through the beginner recall program used with new learners. The goal is answering a range of questions about past salient events. First, the learner should answer all of those question types about a picture, scene, or video in front of them, and do it fluently. Event description helps too. Show a park photo and the learner says two kids are playing, one on the swing and one on the slide. Not a flat list of trees.

Step one uses a simple picture: one agent, one action. In the demo it was a dog jumping over a log in a forest. Ask two or three questions while the picture is there. What is the dog doing? Where is the dog? Then remove it and run distractor trials (short tasks during the wait). Then ask the same questions again, plus one or two new ones. What color was the dog? That new question forces real work.

Errors will happen, since the skill is not taught yet. Do not hand over the answer. Use thematic prompts that bring the picture back to mind. Does the dog have fur or feathers? Was the dog white or black? Then return to your target question. If it is still hard, show the picture again, remove it, wait, and ask.

Then build in a few directions. Fade your questions to a point at the key part of the picture. Then fade to a simple prime that questions are coming. Stretch the delay. Make the distractor tasks verbal, since verbal work blocks plain rehearsal. That is the point, because you want recall strategies, not holding. Move to busier scenes, then to short videos or clips from a favorite show. Then use real salient events, first right after, then with longer gaps. Keep checking in during the event so the learner stays verbally present.

Because the goal is not that they get the answer right.

From the talk — Dana Pettus

Because I See: Naming Sources of Control, Inference, and Theory of Mind

Before inference, teach the learner to name their own clues. Show a picture and ask where they are. Then ask how they know. The answer uses a frame: because I see sand, waves, a bucket, and a shovel. Only relevant items count. Kids show up in many places. A seagull that is not in the photo does not count. Run the negative version too. Are we in a kitchen? No. How do you know? Because I do not see an oven or a fridge. This step primes them to label the sources behind their own answers, which inference programs build on next.

Simple visual and auditory inference comes next. The cues are three questions. What is the person doing? What do they want, or why are they doing it? How do you know? First the learner needs sharp question skills, tacts for the senses, and why answers about events and intentions. Why did the man put up the umbrella? To stay dry. You will need many pictures, so Pettus uses curricula like Think It Say It. Do not mark it mastered until the learner handles novel exemplars (new pictures you never taught). Errors get thematic prompts. Tell me what you see. How do you feel about food you do not like? Why might you throw out food?

The last activity showed where this leads. Someone sends a funny message to a group chat, and nobody replies. An hour later, she deletes it. Attendees inferred embarrassment. That takes several things at once. Her feelings differ from yours. Social attention may matter to her. You read all of it without seeing her face. Pettus called this perspective taking (seeing it from someone else's side), tied to theory of mind (knowing someone else's thoughts can differ from yours). One working definition: others may hold views, beliefs, and goals that differ from yours, and those differences predict what they do.

The Sally Anne task is the common check. Sally puts a ball in a basket and leaves. Ann moves it to the box. Where will Sally look? Pettus pointed to a long article by Dr. Espinoza that gives a verbal behavior account of this. In those terms, the learner contacts the clues controlling someone else's behavior, apart from their own. That makes the early targets concrete. Pronouns. Time words. Correct sentences like she will and she did. Reporting what controlled your own answer. From there, build predicting what others do, say, and think. Then show a picture facing away from you and ask who knows what is on it. Then false belief games and short stories. Staff pick the prompting up fast once you model it, and there is no wrong related question.

You have to figure this out.

From the talk — Dana Pettus

Common questions

What is thematic prompting?▾

It means asking a clarifying question that adds clues instead of giving the answer. If a learner stalls on foods, you ask what a salad is, then ask for foods again. The learner still generates the answer, so the problem solving gets practice. It works the same way in recall and inference programs.

Why should a token board be indiscriminate during listing?▾

A ten token board tells the learner exactly when the work ends. Once the last token lands, there is no reason to keep thinking. An open board lets you mark every good answer without signaling the finish. Pair it with "tell me some animals" rather than a set number.

Can I run recall with simple actions like touch your nose, then touch your head?▾

You can, and Pettus said those strategies can still be useful. The catch is that these actions are not very salient, so they are harder to remember. Pictures and scenes are closer to what the learner will actually need to recall in daily life. A silly or fun picture can also help.

Is recall with videos a harder prompt level than recall with photos?▾

Pettus treats photos and videos as separate steps, not a prompt hierarchy. A photo is one still scene with one main thing happening, so it is easier. Videos hold more action and more detail. Teach photos first, then move to short clips.

My learner answers recall questions about the wrong day. What should I check?▾

Check the question first. "What did you do today?" asks for an action, in the past, within today. A learner who answers with a trip from months ago may be missing those parts of the question. That is a question discrimination problem, not a memory problem.

About the speaker

Dana Pettus is a behavior analyst and registered behavior analyst in Ontario. Pettus has worked as a clinical supervisor with AlphaBee for many years, mostly with children and teens with autism, with much of that experience in early intervention and intensive behavior analysis. This talk was the third in Pettus's CEU series on verbal behavior, building on two earlier sessions.

This summary was generated from the recording’s transcript. Quotes are taken word for word from the talk.

What you'll learn

  1. 11. Analyze how previously established conditional discrimination and speaker–listener mediation repertoires facilitate the acquisition of recall and simple inferencing skills. 2. Differentiate between recall and inferential responding under cumulative stimulus control and responding produced by isolated task training. 3. Design instructional sequences that use question discrimination and autoclitic frames (e.g., tacting sources of control) to establish event description and recall of past events. 4. Program for simple visually and intraverbally based inferences by strengthening covert verbal mediations skills including the tacting of controlling variables.

Related talks

Talks that cover the same concepts

More from alphabeePRO

OpenCEU is supported by advertising from third-party sponsors. Sponsors are clearly labeled, have no influence over course content, instructors, or CEU decisions, and never appear on certificates. The BACB does not sponsor, approve, or endorse OpenCEU sponsors or their products.