Playing the Game in Daily Life: From Following Rules to Applying Flexible Standards in Context

with Kaitlin Wilder

$200 · 1 Learning CEU · certificate included

What you’ll learn

  • Explain “free will” (and lack thereof) within the context of radical behaviorism Identify and define the controlling relations that create coercion Use experiential exercise to explain the effects of coercion within the context of their ABA practice Use experiential exercise to explain the effects of coercion within the context of their own “problems” in daily life
Kaitlin Wilder
Wildside Behavior LLC1 Learning CEU50 minOn-demand

Presented by Kaitlin Wilder

Playing the Game in Daily Life: From Following Rules to Applying Flexible Standards in Context

About this CEU

This event introduces topics of free will, coercion, and rule following to allow participants to better understand human behavior within the context of daily life and allow participant to explore their own events and inner processes that impact their own behavior and ABA practice. Participants will explore areas of life where they may be coercing themselves into following rules that are unhelpful towards their ideal life and ABA Practice. The ABAA human model using flexible standards is introduced applying choices to daily in situations where participants feel inflexible and affected by their "problems".

Credits

1 CEU · 50 min

From the talk

What was covered

Kaitlin Wilder on free will, coercion, and rule following: how to spot coercive control in ABA practice and daily life.

  • Test any plan you write by asking what keeps the behavior going: getting something valued, or dodging something bad.
  • Positive reinforcement is non-coercive, but check what waits on the other end if the person does not earn it.
  • Expect rule-heavy systems to work best for people who can already follow rules, and to create more trouble for everyone else.
  • Rate your own rule-following from 1 to 10, then ask whether following each rule feels like a choice or a must.
  • Use ACT (acceptance and values based action) to see the options actually in front of you, not just the ones your rules allow.
  • Treat what you notice in these exercises as information about your history, not proof that you are good or bad.

What Radical Behaviorism Says About Free Will

The talk opens with a hard claim. In radical behaviorism (a science view of all behavior), people do not have free will. That does not mean choice is fake. It means every choice sits under behavioral control (behavior shaped by events and history).

So what controls it? The speaker names two sources. First, the things right around us, like other people. Second, everything we have already lived through. Those past events build the rules we carry. They tell us what we should and should not do. By the time a choice shows up, that history is already in the room with us.

The speaker does not stop at the no free will part. She pairs it with ACT (acceptance and values based action). ACT helps us look at our own history with clear eyes. Then we can see the real options in front of us, in a literal sense. From there we pick the move that goes toward the life we want. The choice is still controlled. It is just no longer on autopilot.

So according to radical behaviorism, we do not have free will because of those things.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

A Life Run on Rules: The Speaker's Own History

The speaker shares her own story early in the session. She believed that following rules would lead to success and make her a good person. She followed them fast, with no thought at all. Breaking even a small rule left her very uncomfortable. Worse, she had no idea what to do instead.

Open questions were the hardest part. Ask her where she would travel, and her brain said I don't know. A choice with no guidance brought intense fear. She could not pick a pillow or a painting for her house. The pain of choosing wrong was too much, so she skipped it. Her house stayed very plain. Conversation got hard too.

She names what was really going on. Rule following had replaced any sense of herself. Her intuition was gone. What grew in its place looked a lot like perfectionism.

And that is what formed my own perfectionism, which was really just avoidance of making choices that could potentially lead me to failure.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Three Controlling Relations: Where Control Ends and Coercion Starts

This is the distinction the whole talk rests on. Control is not the same thing as coercion (control through threat and punishment). Behavior analysts work with behavioral control all day long. Every person's behavior is controlled by something at some point. That fact alone does not mean we are using force.

The speaker draws the line using ideas from one book. She returns to it all night: Coercion and its Fallout by Murray Sidman. Broadly, there are three kinds of controlling relations (links between actions and consequences). Positive reinforcement (adding something to increase behavior) is non-coercive. Coercion enters with negative reinforcement (removing something bad to increase behavior) and punishment (a consequence that reduces behavior).

That gives you a simple working test. Ask what is keeping the behavior going. If the person acts to get something they value, you are in one world. If they act to dodge something bad, you are in the other. The behavior can look identical from the outside. The controlling relation is not.

All control is not coercion.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Where Coercion Hides in School Reinforcement Systems

The talk then turns to schools. Positive behavior supports (school wide reinforcement plans) came in for a good reason. Staff wanted to reinforce students for appropriate behavior and build those skills up. The principle itself was sound.

Then the speaker asks the question that usually gets skipped. A student can earn reinforcement at school. But what happens if the student does not do the expected behavior? The answer is the school discipline plan. That plan sits on the other end the whole time, even when nobody mentions it.

This explains a pattern most of us have watched up close. These systems work well for students who can already follow the rules. Students who cannot follow them tend to land in more trouble instead.

Why does that happen? Because the reward is really just the flip side of avoiding a consequence. The student complies to stay clear of what waits for them. Nothing in that loop teaches the skills they need. So the loop keeps running, and it does not hold up outside of school either.

This works better for the kids that already can follow rules, but for the kids that are not able to, they tend to just end up in more trouble.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

The Car Polishing Question From Sidman

The speaker reads a long passage from Sidman's book, and it does a lot of work. A boy polishes the family car. What is his reinforcer? Maybe it is the gleaming car and a word of thanks from his parents. Or maybe it is avoiding the scolding he would have gotten for skipping the job.

The passage says that difference does not stay small. If the boy's family life runs mostly on dodging censure, disapproval, and ridicule, that pattern spreads. It shapes how he deals with other people. It can change his general outlook on life. It may also push him to escape the family.

The speaker puts it in plainer words. When we do something because it means something to us, we get the real payoff. The clean car. The satisfaction of the effort we put in. When we do it only to avoid a bad outcome, the game changes completely. So look hard at what you recommend. Are people making meaningful choices? Or are they just taking the reinforcers we picked out for them?

Is a boy's reinforcer for polishing the family car the new look of the gleaming car and perhaps his parents' appreciation?

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Why Rule Based Systems Break Down Outside the Session

The speaker reflects on her own career here. Heavy use of rules is part of what brought the field to this point. In her view, it does not hold up in the real world.

Picture how that plays out. The rule gets followed on paper. Meanwhile the person quietly finds the gap in it. A new behavior shows up, and now you are managing two problems instead of one. The talk also names a quieter cost. Rule based reinforcement is often tied to nothing the person actually values. So no skill gets built, and nothing carries over.

That is the reason the speaker gives for looking elsewhere. She is not throwing out behavior analysis. She is seeking alternatives to coercive control inside it.

When we set up rules for people to follow them, they tend to find ways to get around them and to create new problems.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

From Rules to Flexible Standards in Context

The title promises a move from following rules to flexible standards. In the recording, the speaker builds that move in three steps. First, use ACT to understand the experiences you have been through. Those experiences shaped the rules you now follow without thinking.

Second, recognize the choices in front of you in a literal sense. Not the choices your rule allows. The ones that are truly available right now. Third, pick from what is there.

Notice what this approach does not need. It does not need free will. Your choice is still under control, and the speaker says so flatly. But a rule running on autopilot leaves you one option. Looking at the literal options leaves you with more than one. That is the whole difference, and it applies to your caseload and your own life alike.

And then choose amongst what we have available to move us closer to where it is that we want to go.

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

How to Run the Two Experiential Exercises Yourself

Most of this session is an experiential exercise (an activity you work through yourself). You will need paper and a pen. The speaker also asks for a noticing log and the opening paperwork nearby. Close the other tabs. Put the phone away. If you get distracted, she calls that a totally natural behavior. She says to pull a leash on that brain and bring it back.

The first exercise starts with a self rating. On a scale of 1 to 10, rate your rule following in daily life. A 1 means you will not follow anyone's rules and nobody can make you. A 10 means you follow every rule exactly or you lose your mind. With that number in mind, answer three questions. When a rule shows up, does following it feel like a choice? Or does your brain say you have to? What would happen if you did not follow it? What would that mean for your life and its outcomes? Sit with this for about ten minutes, even if nothing comes up.

The second exercise points at your work. Ask where coercion is hiding in your practice. Hunt for spots where positive reinforcement is in play. Then ask what sits on the other end if the person does not choose the reinforcer. Also notice how it feels to even consider this. The ground rule matters here: in this program there is no good or bad, only information. You are collecting data on your own history, not grading yourself.

Where does coercion hide in your ABA practice?

From the talk — Kaitlin Wilder

Common questions

Does radical behaviorism really say we have no free will?▾

In this talk, yes. The speaker states that we do not have free will because our behavior sits under behavioral control. Even real choices are shaped by our current setting and our whole history. Her point is that we can still see and use the options actually available to us.

What is the difference between control and coercion in ABA?▾

All control is not coercion, as the speaker puts it. Behavior analysts always work with behavioral control, because behavior is controlled by something. Control by positive reinforcement is non-coercive. Coercion enters when behavior is controlled by negative reinforcement or punishment.

Can a positive reinforcement system still be coercive?▾

It can, and that is one of the main points of the session. The speaker asks what sits on the other end when a student does not earn the reinforcer. If a discipline plan is waiting there, the person may be complying to avoid it. In that case the reward is just the flip side of escape.

Which book does this talk draw from?▾

The speaker takes her ideas about coercion from Coercion and its Fallout by Murray Sidman. She calls it one of her favorite books and quotes it several times. The car polishing passage about a boy and his family comes from that book.

Who is this session for?▾

It is aimed at behavior analysts who want to look at coercion in two places at once. One is their clinical practice. The other is their own daily life and their own problems. Be ready to write, to sit quietly, and to answer questions about yourself.

About the speaker

Kaitlin Wilder led this ABA Actionable session on free will, coercion, and rule following. She walks through the three controlling relations that separate control from coercion. She draws on Coercion and its Fallout by Murray Sidman and on ACT. She also shares her own history of rigid rule following and perfectionism, and how it shaped her daily life.

This summary was generated from the recording’s transcript. Quotes are taken word for word from the talk.

More from Wildside Behavior LLC

OpenCEU is supported by advertising from third-party sponsors. Sponsors are clearly labeled, have no influence over course content, instructors, or CEU decisions, and never appear on certificates. The BACB does not sponsor, approve, or endorse OpenCEU sponsors or their products.